Trade Hypotheticals

[foj1]

I think it may need a little more though unlike some trades suggestions Carlisle is absolute quality and is a key position who has benefitted and grown from two years of development. I think he would be an upgrade on grant and at least on par with jones in terms of long term potential and would make your best 18 comfortably.
Caddy then mckenzie then prestia for mine.
I do think the bulldogs would at least contemplate this deal with a steak knife like our round 2 for their round three thrown in.

Yeah, we wouldn't just give our compo pick for Carlisle. We would expect more.
The compo pick will be a top 10 pick for the next few years.

 

[yaco55]

FOJ

Would you do this trade from an EFC point of view ?

 

[Igloo]

I think it may need a little more though unlike some trades suggestions Carlisle is absolute quality and is a key position who has benefitted and grown from two years of development. I think he would be an upgrade on grant and at least on par with jones in terms of long term potential and would make your best 18 comfortably.
Caddy then mckenzie then prestia for mine.
I do think the bulldogs would at least contemplate this deal with a steak knife like our round 2 for their round three thrown in.

I dont disagree. I think he is a better prospect than Grant, but I rate Jones higher.
I'd be ecstatic if we somehow got Carlisle, but for our compo pick we would expect a bit more.

 

[silverscope]

Thursfield for Walters

I really hope not. This also means he would knock back the contract that has been offered to him.

 

[Lemma]

Carlisle has shown more in 1 year than Grant has in 4

 

[Igloo]

Carlisle has shown more in 1 year than Grant has in 4

No one denied that. Grant has been very underwhelming.

I rate Jones more than Carlisle though. He will be a beast of a CHF.

 

[Danger in Texas]

Carlisle has shown more in 1 year than Grant has in 4

I agree, Carsile has shown much promise in the past year, while Grant hasn't been very consistent.

 

[UpTheGuts]

I really hope not. This also means he would knock back the contract that has been offered to him.

I only know we were into him, but if he has been cuddled a bit of late then he'd probably stay. Just a hypothetical

 

[chef]

Think that Carlisle is worth the Compo Pick - He is a better KP prospect than anyone on your current list - In saying that I wouldnt do the trade to get Caddy.

Jones is better.

 

[Slattery_20]

Ess & GC have gone to mediation over Caddy.

 

[UpTheGuts]

Ess & GC have gone to mediation over Caddy.

Just for the nonlawyers - mediation isnt binding

Gumbleton and Hooker (one of, I'm presuming) and pick 19 have been offered: Hutchy

 

[Slattery_20]

Jones is better.

Didn't they line up on each other in rd 21? And didn't Carlisle smash him ?
Very much up for question; Jones has played more, but Carlisle is a fair talent.

 

[boncer34]

Just for the nonlawyers - mediation isnt binding

Gumbleton and Hooker (one of, I'm presuming) and pick 19 have been offered: Hutchy

We get rid of Hooker we will take Fev IMO.

Hurley would have to go down back to cover Hooker leaving us short up front.

 

[yaco55]

Jones is better.

Could have sworn that Carlisle eclipsed Jones.