Agree on Hampson but not sure on Jolly!!
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Mega Thread Trade Period: Lets get that delisted guy. He could be good, yeah?
- Thread starter caseman2
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Agree on Hampson but not sure on Jolly!!
- Sep 7, 2012
- 6,279
- 6,312
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Mount Buller Demons
Cox is still uncontracted.... And unrestricted... Big dollars for a couple of years until Longer comes along?
All for One
All for One
GOHORCS
All Australian
The hawks will have a more balanced side with Buddy gone. Hale rucking is not the answer and Lowden is unproven but a good chance to improve and take the number 1 spot. Grimley could also become the centre half forward who marks and competes in the air that Buddy wasn't. The prospect of Shoey coming in to the backline makes us tall back and front but highlights the need for a quicker midfield. So much potential but unproven and need games.The highlighted Blue are either inexperienced or coming back from injury. Spangher could fill CHF temporarily and I am already excluding Savage as he wants to go but would be a running role if he stays. Nagging feeling I am missing someone. ADAMS is the one who fills this void. A Suckling may be the key. Great currency and is the only player on our list who is suspect in a contested situation. I do not want to get rid of him but in a strong team he is shown up.
Backs: Gibson Lake Dureya
Half Back: Hodge Shoey Stratton
Centre: Smith Lewis Suckling
Half Forward: Gunston Grimley Rioli
Forward: Breust Roughead Hale
Ruck: Lowden(Longer)
Ruck Rover:Mitchell
Rover: Sewell(Hallahan)
I/C: Puopolo Anderson Woodward SUB:Simkin
Seems Shuey may want to return home. Would we be interested?
Does he have any pace?
Sent from my HTC_PN071 using Tapatalk 2
Does he have any pace?
Sent from my HTC_PN071 using Tapatalk 2
Spanish Sahara
Brownlow Medallist
Shiels also
I wouldn't mind seeing Shaw in brown and gold. I know a lot of people hate on him, and he can be a bit maniacal at times, but I think he'd fit in well with our group and play style. Could even give the opportunity for someone like Birchall to play on the wing all day.
Burgoyne ?!
Dewnior
Norm Smith Medallist
- Dec 22, 2007
- 9,918
- 18,047
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Whilst Jolly may not cost us a pick, he will cost us a large slice of the cap space we have now that Buddy's gone.
GOHORCS
All Australian
It is amazing how many I missed. Love it!
Burgoyne Shiels and Hill. Replaces woodward simkin and suckling
They make for handy depth. Suckling while he returns to form.
Sorry didn't want to make this a best 22 thing anyway. Light on for speed depth.
- Nov 21, 2010
- 13,790
- 18,219
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Chelsea, Detroit Pistons
Collingwood, Geelong and Richmond, as well as us, are chasing midfielders with a shopping list headed with Adams and seconded by anyone else available.
I doubt any of these teams will get 2 of the highly sought mids of the trade season.
I just cannot see a potential package that would deliver Shuey or Darling to Hawthorn.
We can pay them through the nose and they would be happy to come but they are both contracted so we would need to crowbar them out of WC.
Given that Shuey is pretty much their only midfielder with the class and explosiveness they are crying out for we have nothing to offer the Eagles that would replace him adequately. Remove him from their midfield group and it is pretty much toilers and accumulators.
We can pay them through the nose and they would be happy to come but they are both contracted so we would need to crowbar them out of WC.
Given that Shuey is pretty much their only midfielder with the class and explosiveness they are crying out for we have nothing to offer the Eagles that would replace him adequately. Remove him from their midfield group and it is pretty much toilers and accumulators.
Ditto
Wrighty has the force. We'll bundle up both with Ellis and a confusing array of late round draft pick swaparoos.
Whistling Hawk
Team Captain
I find our ruck situation interesting. I wonder how accurate this speculation about Hampson is? I would be happy to get Hampson provided it is cheap... Really cheap... like third round draft pick cheap.
On Longer I think we are selling him short a bit. He still has plenty of maturing to do but at the same time, he might be a lot more ready than we think. He's listed at 102 kg already and will be stronger with another preseason.
Having a very simplistic glance at his stats he averaged 18 hitouts per game (he only played 4 games) in 2013 and 7 disposals. Bailey averaged 21 hitouts and 9 disposals. As I said this is a very simplistic look at the stats and doesn't take into account time on ground (of which Max is only about 60%).
Happy to be corrected on the above cause I didn't really see Longer play and am just going off stats for four games. I would actually like to see Hale, Longer and Lowden rotate throughout the year to give the two young guys game experience whilst not flogging them and give Hale a rest. Grimley could also give any of the other guys a chop out as well if he's playing. Hampson would then only be required for depth if there's an injury to the other three which is why I would only get him if he's cheap.
Oh, and there's Ceglar as well.
On Longer I think we are selling him short a bit. He still has plenty of maturing to do but at the same time, he might be a lot more ready than we think. He's listed at 102 kg already and will be stronger with another preseason.
Having a very simplistic glance at his stats he averaged 18 hitouts per game (he only played 4 games) in 2013 and 7 disposals. Bailey averaged 21 hitouts and 9 disposals. As I said this is a very simplistic look at the stats and doesn't take into account time on ground (of which Max is only about 60%).
Happy to be corrected on the above cause I didn't really see Longer play and am just going off stats for four games. I would actually like to see Hale, Longer and Lowden rotate throughout the year to give the two young guys game experience whilst not flogging them and give Hale a rest. Grimley could also give any of the other guys a chop out as well if he's playing. Hampson would then only be required for depth if there's an injury to the other three which is why I would only get him if he's cheap.
Oh, and there's Ceglar as well.
Hampson, like most rucks that aren't superstars, appears very very average.
He can clunk a mark, which is helpful, and I wouldn't be against it if we thought of a way to get more out of him. But if he comes across and performs at the same level then there isn't much at all to get excited about.
He can clunk a mark, which is helpful, and I wouldn't be against it if we thought of a way to get more out of him. But if he comes across and performs at the same level then there isn't much at all to get excited about.
Whistling Hawk
Team Captain
There just aren't that many people around that are over 200 cm. That height must be at least a couple of standard deviations from the mean. Also explains why KPP's are difficult to come by as well.
Savage and Ellis plus a first round draft pick (maybe a compo pick) for Shuey. He is a gun and would be a great get for us.
Brant
Brownlow Medallist
We don't own Ellis anymore I don't think - his Contract has/is expired & the word is that we've not offered to extend. Pretty sure he is free to sign with whomever he likes for free.
SSSSSS
Brownlow Medallist
- Apr 18, 2011
- 21,843
- 49,917
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Six decades of domination
I would love Shuey. We'd have to give up a bit though.
- Feb 13, 2003
- 21,724
- 24,129
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Where there's smoke there's fire, both Adams and Shuey want to come home no doubting that and yes we have plenty of $$ to offer and with 4-5 top Victorian clubs chasing both it's gonna be tough. In all seriousness what do we have to offer to the Eagles for him? What would they want? Savage would be firstly part of the deal and holds plenty of currency however I'd be be certain they'd want Stratton to be apart of discussions which we would knock on the head.
Generally if a player wants out and names a team he wants to go to then they generally get there, so with that in mind and given there is the Simpson connection the deal could go a bit like:
Savage + compensation 1st rd WCE
Shuey HAW
Generally if a player wants out and names a team he wants to go to then they generally get there, so with that in mind and given there is the Simpson connection the deal could go a bit like:
Savage + compensation 1st rd WCE
Shuey HAW
If we trade Savage for Longer, then what can we trade for Adams and Shuey?
Wanganeen2014
Draftee
- Oct 5, 2013
- 7
- 4
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
We've currently got only 10 guys (including the Internationals) that haven't tasted the heat of the big time on game day. Pretty healthy
