Trent Cotchin is the best player in the AFL

[Ricmel]

Well done, but please stop.

At least he didn't start another Cotchin thread.

I have a feeling he uses them to relieve the tension in his groin from time to time and so must ever create more and more.

 

[TheRoo32]

That's right people, I made a big call, and I am right. I make the big calls before they happen. Cotchin has taken out most of the individual player awards this year. You all should back down and accept that I was right and that Cotchin is the best player in the AFL on current 2012 form.

It feels good to have the balls to put my neck on the line to make these big calls and then be proven right. You all owe me an apology for the insults earlier in the year.

Get ya hand off it floggo...

 

[neroblack]

That's right people, I made a big call, and I am right. I make the big calls before they happen. Cotchin has taken out most of the individual player awards this year. You all should back down and accept that I was right and that Cotchin is the best player in the AFL on current 2012 form.

It feels good to have the balls to put my neck on the line to make these big calls and then be proven right. You all owe me an apology for the insults earlier in the year.

I'll agree with you on the basis that you promise to get extremely excited about how Richmond will play finals next year, and then start a thread about how shattered you are when they fail (again).

 

[The Goon]

Oh god, why won't it stop???????????????

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

He is a fine player. not the best. gary or buddy for me. as an aside i heard he got 3 votes for the freo game from 3aw. talk about home cooking. freo dominated that game and no way cotchin was best on ground. sure had stats but effect was not bog material. at least cotchin is generally damaging with the ball in hand. jobe watson on the other hand is not a game breaker. it would be sad to see a accumulator like watson beat cotchin for the brownlow

For the recent one? How did you hear this?

 

[Bazzar]

He is a fine player. not the best. gary or buddy for me. as an aside i heard he got 3 votes for the freo game from 3aw. talk about home cooking. freo dominated that game and no way cotchin was best on ground. sure had stats but effect was not bog material. at least cotchin is generally damaging with the ball in hand. jobe watson on the other hand is not a game breaker. it would be sad to see a accumulator like watson beat cotchin for the brownlow

I think you just making this up The top three were Ballantyne, Mundy and Sandi. From memory i think one commentator gave him 1 vote, but thats it. (He did get 4 coaches votes)

 

[Bazzar]

Well done, but please stop.

Why, didnt you just start yet another "Martin/Scully/Trengove" thread in the last hour or two? (and vote for Trengove...lol)

 

[Jobe Watson]

Let's hope Richmond supporters keep pouring money on him for the Brownlow.

 

[MiloStedman]

Nobody has been better this year. There is no possible argument you can put forward for anyone. Nobody is more damaging with the football and has been as consistant as he is. Ablett and Swan are stat padders, Watson has been great but he has had more bad games, Franklin has been injured and less consistant anyway, Scott Thompson has been very good but still not as damaging as Cotchin. Who else is there?

Eveyone who's better than him

 

[Righteo]

cotchin is the best player and richmond is the best team and yellow and black are the best colours

 

[richoatthedisco]

cotchin is the best player and richmond is the best team and yellow and black are the best colours

Finally, someone posts some sense.

 

[Ancient Tiger]

Finally, someone posts some sense.

Took the words out of my mouth

 

[TheRoo32]

Took the words out of my mouth

Taken ya hand off ya lad yet?

 

[Blaz]

Get ya hand off it floggo...

how keen are you

 

[Colonel Matrix]

cotchin is the best player and richmond is the best team and yellow and black are the best colours

Finally some sense in this thread

 

[captain blood 17]

Eveyone who's better than him

There is only one, possibly two who have matched Cotchin this year. They are Dangerfield - an absolute jet, and Seedsman - who has just possibly nudged out mcLean for my nomination.

 

[MiloStedman]

There is only one, possibly two who have matched Cotchin this year. They are Dangerfield - an absolute jet, and Seedsman - who has just possibly nudged out mcLean for my nomination.

Hilarious. In all seriousness, Cotchin > Dangerfield. Cotchin probs 5th best player in the league

 

[captain blood 17]

Hilarious. In all seriousness, Cotchin > Dangerfield. Cotchin probs 5th best player in the league

Yeah, so by bay standards, it is
1. Watts
2. Seedsman
3. Dangerfield
4. Heppell
5. Cotchin.

You're right, 5 best player in the league.

 

[MiloStedman]

Yeah, so by bay standards, it is
1. Watts
2. Seedsman
3. Dangerfield
4. Heppell
5. Cotchin.

You're right, 5 best player in the league.

Good stuff. I wanted blood and I got it

 

[LikaTiger]

Taken ya hand off ya lad yet?

Has Tippett signed yet? Lol

UMAD?

 

[Bailey01]

lol

 

[Roddy]

Quality bump this one, and well worth it...

 

[Righteo]

Quality bump this one, and well worth it...

I don't know about you but I've had many sleepless nights these past two months agonising over how Myles Stedman was going to formulate a memorable rebuttal in response to captain blood 17.

GTFO with your sarcasm Rod mate.

 

[Bazzar]

Sad part is Cotch is so far removed from the best player it isnt funny.

 

[BM123]

Sad part is Cotch is so far removed from the best player it isnt funny.

I'd write 2013 off when it comes to Cotchin. First year as captain with injuries concerns would have taken a lot out of him mentally.

Sad part is Cotch is so far removed from the best player it isnt funny.