Umps single handedly getting the Aints over the line
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Umpiring
- Thread starter eays
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Apr 10, 2013
- 6,904
- 17,664
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- East Fremantle
Meredith (#21) absolutely farrkking hates us! Dead set cheat!
Did everyone know you can now handball with one hand?
Umpires:
I like how Pickett and Dusty got done for holding the ball when they had a split second to dispose of the ball but Gulden can duck (was called a duck correctly, that is also your prior opportunity) but then get out of the tackle and sit on the ground for 5 seconds sooking, then gets tackled again and it's not holding the ball.
I also like how anyone who plays Richmond is no longer required to dispose of the ball legally. Throws are fine especially right near goal.
What I really enjoy is something from last week. Apparently you can punch a Richmond player in the face right infont of the umpires, bad enough to get suspended but not have the free paid against and cost your team a goal.
Seems legit.
I also like how anyone who plays Richmond is no longer required to dispose of the ball legally. Throws are fine especially right near goal.
What I really enjoy is something from last week. Apparently you can punch a Richmond player in the face right infont of the umpires, bad enough to get suspended but not have the free paid against and cost your team a goal.
Seems legit.
They really hate Pickett.
- Oct 29, 2017
- 21,943
- 42,965
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Umps last night in the 1st, 3rd and 4th were just guessing at decisions. Absolute lottery.
Even we got frees at times that weren't there.
Even we got frees at times that weren't there.
Groupie_
time to return the traditional Richmond yellow
we are better umpired when it rains as they get on heat and cant cheat as much
- May 1, 2011
- 699
- 1,872
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Still waiting for the vision from Lynchs goal last year....
Yeah they never really got back to the club on the proof.
Biggest scam in AFL history, just swept under the carpet. I pretty much know for fact now, that the call was made with the wrong intentions.
Area51
Club Legend
- Jun 6, 2022
- 1,093
- 3,898
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Where does knowledge of fact come from?
Truetiger
Moderator
- Jun 27, 2004
- 18,576
- 21,355
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Tasmania Devils
- Moderator
- #2,266
New angle emerges after AFL ticks off controversial review as ‘definitive behind’
Fan-shot footage of Tom Lynch’s snap for goal has surfaced, and it may just end the debate once and for all.
7news.com.au
Vision lol for what its worth
Illness rules Martin out of Lions clash
Roy Ward, with AAP
The sides will clash for the first time since last September’s elimination final thriller, when an opportunistic Joe Daniher toe-poke goal was the difference in a two-point win that featured 17 lead changes.
Tom Lynch thought he’d sealed victory for the visitors moments earlier, but his goal was overruled on review when replays suggested it had flicked the post.
When I read this in the Age before the Brisbane game, I emailed the campaigner to ask if he has actually seen this replay!!!???
No reply of course. The Age has gone to the dogs and Roy Ward is an amateur...
Groupie_
time to return the traditional Richmond yellow
clear goalNew angle emerges after AFL ticks off controversial review as ‘definitive behind’
Fan-shot footage of Tom Lynch’s snap for goal has surfaced, and it may just end the debate once and for all.
Vision lol for what its worth
was through the goal posts before it went up high
- Jan 25, 2018
- 5,615
- 18,517
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Liverpool
100% ****en rort
Groupie_
time to return the traditional Richmond yellow
wonder if big sexy like a lunatic celebrated if they wouldve even reviewed it
SDMTiger4
All Australian
- Dec 4, 2020
- 690
- 1,611
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Take a look at the Tylar Young highlights video on the Tigs website. At the 28 second mark, wraps up Buddy good and proper, and Buddy incorrectly disposes of the ball, but of course the ump calls play on. Buddy stops dead and calls for a free. Must be ingrained in the oppo now to expect a free coming their way.
p.s. loved seeing Buddy get towelled up by the young fella.
This is the one I am talking about. Not sure on the timestamp, but it happened a second time during that game. 1 handed handballs, outlawed in the game. *Except against Richmond
This one frustrated the everliving shit out of me. Once Gulden ducked there goes his prior opportunity.
The rules are extremely clear on this. That was a textbook holding the ball and would've resulted in just about the sealing goal rather than the margin being under a kick for the next few mins before JGTI stepped up.
What's the point of 4 umpires if none of them can call this??? It's either utter incompetence in them not knowing the rules or they decided to not pay it as it would've resulted in a Richmond goal. Either way it's just dogshit adjudication.
Adding on to this is the commentary. I don't know how much they're getting paid but not one of them said it should've been called holding the ball and was almost a sliding doors moment. They have access to the umpires microphones same as us, and would've heard the ump say that Gulden ducked hence why it wasn't paid high. Again, either utter incompetent commentating or they're being told to not mention clear missed free kicks (although they don't seem to mind calling them out anytime Buddy goes near the ball).
The Gulden non free was a shocker - wonder if the AFL will apologise to us for that? Nearly cost us the game.
Similar threads
