VFL/AFL players who died young

Remove this Banner Ad

BigRex

Rookie
Sep 29, 2010
46
77
AFL Club
Collingwood
I'm doing some research into VFL/AFL players who died young.

I didn't feature several players from pre 1940 when, sometimes players even died during their playing career, or not long after.

Please share your stories and memories.

1736543058244.jpeg
 

Log in to remove this ad.

In SANFL, there is Scott Field

David Kantilla, from NT and played in SANFL https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Kantilla

Mark Naley was only 59, don't think I saw him on the list, but he may not have fit age criteria.

Brendon Howard was a Sturt player, he died in car accident at age 48.
 
Maurie Sankey was a Tassie boy, who had become Carlton's v-c and had played his 100th game by the time of his passing at the age of 25.

Here's an article I found about him.
 
Ronnie James, aged 19. Sadly died in a waterskiing accident.

Would have been a superstar. Followed the old school pathway of VFA - VFL.


IIRC Ron James at age 19 is the youngest AFL/VFL player to die, unless there were any younger players killed in action in the First or Second World Wars?

Jamie Tape, who died at age 29 in 2003 is one of the bizarre ones - having cancer then going into remission only to several months later have a cardiac episode while driving and die in the ensuing car crash - his time really did seem to be up.

Another eerie case is that of former Dockers and Giants player Cam McCarthy, who died last year. McCarthy's date of birth is 01-Apr-1995 - the same day the Fremantle Dockers made their debut against Richmond at the MCG - and the last Dockers match ever played in his lifetime before he died in May 2024 was Richmond vs Fremantle at the MCG.

There's an odd run with SANFL too, tragedies affecting teams that have broken long premiership droughts. In 1993, two of the Woodville-West Torrens Eagles premiership players - the first for the merged team and the first since West Torrens were premiers in 1953 - were Jamie Tape and Laurence Schache, and both had died within a decade. Central Districts Bulldogs finally broke through for their first premiership in 2000 and their captain was Daniel Hulm, who took a year off in 2001 to live and work in England, a trip he never returned from as he was hit and killed by a train in London in May of that year. Sturt celebrated the end of a premiership drought of 26 years in 2002, but tragically player Josh Deegan and former player and long-term trainer and committee member for the Double Blues Bob Marshall died in the Bali Bombings in October 2002. Port Adelaide won their first AFL premiership in 2004 but two of the assistant coaches - Phil Walsh and Dean Bailey - are no longer with us, while senior coach Mark Williams fought a long battle with cancer. In 2015 Mark Mickan coached the enigmatic West Adelaide to something of a fluke premiership over the Eagles but has since battled Parkinson's Disease.
 

Leigh McCartney, who was South Melbourne's captain and best player for season 1976, died on 10 August 1976 aged 18. He was just voted BOG in a match vs Melbourne and had an accident. He never regained consciousness and died. He played in the same South Under 19s team in 1976 with Terry Daniher. South legend John Heriot was the coach that year and said he would've played in the reserves and seniors in 1977.

Edgar Gunn, Geelong reserves and Under 19s player in 1979, died in a car accident in Parkville on the morning after watching the 1979 Grand Final with mates. Gunn played a few reserves games in 1979 and was a standout in 1979 in the Under 19s. He had just played in Geelong's 1979 Preliminary match vs Fitzroy the week earlier. He was 18.
IIRC Ron James at age 19 is the youngest AFL/VFL player to die, unless there were any younger players killed in action in the First or Second World Wars?

Jamie Tape, who died at age 29 in 2003 is one of the bizarre ones - having cancer then going into remission only to several months later have a cardiac episode while driving and die in the ensuing car crash - his time really did seem to be up.

Another eerie case is that of former Dockers and Giants player Cam McCarthy, who died last year. McCarthy's date of birth is 01-Apr-1995 - the same day the Fremantle Dockers made their debut against Richmond at the MCG - and the last Dockers match ever played in his lifetime before he died in May 2024 was Richmond vs Fremantle at the MCG.

There's an odd run with SANFL too, tragedies affecting teams that have broken long premiership droughts. In 1993, two of the Woodville-West Torrens Eagles premiership players - the first for the merged team and the first since West Torrens were premiers in 1953 - were Jamie Tape and Laurence Schache, and both had died within a decade. Central Districts Bulldogs finally broke through for their first premiership in 2000 and their captain was Daniel Hulm, who took a year off in 2001 to live and work in England, a trip he never returned from as he was hit and killed by a train in London in May of that year. Sturt celebrated the end of a premiership drought of 26 years in 2002, but tragically player Josh Deegan and former player and long-term trainer and committee member for the Double Blues Bob Marshall died in the Bali Bombings in October 2002. Port Adelaide won their first AFL premiership in 2004 but two of the assistant coaches - Phil Walsh and Dean Bailey - are no longer with us, while senior coach Mark Williams fought a long battle with cancer. In 2015 Mark Mickan coached the enigmatic West Adelaide to something of a fluke premiership over the Eagles but has since battled Parkinson's Disease.
"IIRC Ron James at age 19 is the youngest AFL/VFL player to die, unless there were any younger players killed in action in the First or Second World Wars?"

I think Ron James at 19, would be the youngest senior VFL/AFL player to die.

IIRC Ron James at age 19 is the youngest AFL/VFL player to die, unless there were any younger players killed in action in the First or Second World Wars?

Jamie Tape, who died at age 29 in 2003 is one of the bizarre ones - having cancer then going into remission only to several months later have a cardiac episode while driving and die in the ensuing car crash - his time really did seem to be up.

Another eerie case is that of former Dockers and Giants player Cam McCarthy, who died last year. McCarthy's date of birth is 01-Apr-1995 - the same day the Fremantle Dockers made their debut against Richmond at the MCG - and the last Dockers match ever played in his lifetime before he died in May 2024 was Richmond vs Fremantle at the MCG.

There's an odd run with SANFL too, tragedies affecting teams that have broken long premiership droughts. In 1993, two of the Woodville-West Torrens Eagles premiership players - the first for the merged team and the first since West Torrens were premiers in 1953 - were Jamie Tape and Laurence Schache, and both had died within a decade. Central Districts Bulldogs finally broke through for their first premiership in 2000 and their captain was Daniel Hulm, who took a year off in 2001 to live and work in England, a trip he never returned from as he was hit and killed by a train in London in May of that year. Sturt celebrated the end of a premiership drought of 26 years in 2002, but tragically player Josh Deegan and former player and long-term trainer and committee member for the Double Blues Bob Marshall died in the Bali Bombings in October 2002. Port Adelaide won their first AFL premiership in 2004 but two of the assistant coaches - Phil Walsh and Dean Bailey - are no longer with us, while senior coach Mark Williams fought a long battle with cancer. In 2015 Mark Mickan coached the enigmatic West Adelaide to something of a fluke premiership over the Eagles but has since battled Parkinson's Disease.

I think Ron James, at 19 was the youngest VFL/AFL player to die. I didn't check every former VFL player who died during wars but there could be a couple that died aged 19 (or younger).

Leigh McCartney, who was South Melbourne's captain and best player for season 1976, died on 10 August 1976 aged 18. He was just voted BOG in a match vs Melbourne and had an accident. He never regained consciousness and died. He played in the same South Under 19s team in 1976 with Terry Daniher. South legend John Heriot was the coach that year and said he would've played in the reserves and seniors in 1977.

Edgar Gunn, Geelong reserves and Under 19s player in 1979, died in a car accident in Parkville the morning after watching the 1979 Grand Final with mates. Gunn played a few reserves games in 1979 and was a standout in 1979 in the Under 19s. He had just played in Geelong's 1979 Preliminary match vs Fitzroy the week earlier. He was 18.
 
Last edited:

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Syd Barker Snr, ruckman for the 'Invincible' North Melbourne team of the 1910's died when he was only 42. He was a fireman by profession and died while at work, but it's unclear how he passed.

Former Hollywood superstar and North Melbourne player James "Jim" Stewart (the first part may not be true :)) died from appendicitis aged 24.
 
It’s still not well known after this. Go on.
You've only got to click on the Wiki link quoted, the first paragraph explains it.

James started his senior career at the age of just 14, when Williamstown coach Terry Wheeler picked him for the 1985 VFA Grand Final, despite having spent the entire season in the Under-19s. The club lost the match by six points but James was a member of their 1986 premiership team.
 
Some of these are really strange causes of death. Like Denis Strauch from Carlton and Port Melbourne who died from tetanus, which one might think would be unusual by 1965. And WTF with Collingwood's Graeme Reichman, who died in a murder-suicide in 2001?
 
Former Eagles rookie Michael Mascoulis died in a car accident at age 20

His mums dog died and he wanted to get another one that was of the same breed. He was on his way to NSW to get a pup for his mum when the accident occurred
 
It's a long list but I think it's worth posting.

155 VFL players were killed on military service (the number is slightly contested given you have men dying from wounds etc some time after serving, and the cause of death may not be completely clear).

Many are older than you would imagine footballers to be - they may have retired from football or left the VFL for other leagues before serving in the military.

Given the topic of the thread i've listed them in order of age.

The youngest is Bill Landy, who played two games for Geelong before being killed in France in 1916. He was 19yo.

PlayerClubGamesDate of deathPlace of deathAge
Bill LandyGeel
2​
19-Jul-1916​
Fromelles, France
19​
Les RogersEss
3​
04-Aug-1916​
France
20​
Gordon HamiltonSM
2​
23-Feb-1941​
Victoria
20​
Noel EllisMelb
3​
06-Jul-1942​
Queensland
20​
Ted McLeanGeel
2​
29-May-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
21​
Norman BradfordSM
7​
04-Aug-1916​
Pozières, France
21​
Harold BallMelb
33​
09-Feb-1942​
Singapore
21​
Alex NashHaw
1​
28-Mar-1944​
off Bougainville Island, New Guinea
21​
Norm OliverColl
13​
27-Jun-1944​
Madang, New Guinea
21​
Claude CrowlSK
3​
25-Apr-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
22​
Lou HolmesSK
1​
23-Jun-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
22​
Frank LugtonMelb
36​
29-Jul-1916​
Villers-Bretonneux, France
22​
Les LeeRich
2​
08-Jun-1917​
Messines, Belgium
22​
Jimmy GordonEss
8​
30-Sep-1918​
France
22​
George BrockNM
4​
02-Aug-1941​
Victoria
22​
Charlie FincherSM
9​
25-Apr-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
23​
Fen McDonaldCarl, Melb
11​
25-Apr-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
23​
Arthur JonesFitz
7​
07-Aug-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
23​
Dick GibbsUni
35​
19-Jul-1916​
Fleurbaix, France
23​
Alf WilliamsonCarl, Melb
19​
11-Apr-1917​
Bullecourt, France
23​
Godfrey GoldinEss
8​
07-Feb-1943​
New Guinea
23​
Wilf AtkinsonCarl
1​
12-Aug-1943​
over Sicily
23​
Jack KeddieEss
1​
15-Aug-1945​
Wewak, New Guinea
23​
Alan CordnerGeel, Coll
23​
25-Apr-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
24​
Arthur HinmanUni
24​
10-May-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
24​
Thornton ClarkeFitz
4​
19-Jul-1916​
Fromelles, France
24​
Jack WalkerSK
4​
27-Jul-1916​
Pozières, France
24​
Harold ParkerSK
3​
30-Jan-1917​
France
24​
Percy RodriguezUni, Melb
22​
20-Mar-1917​
The Somme, France
24​
Artie HarrisonRich, Fitz
20​
03-May-1917​
Bullecourt, France
24​
Billy HarveyEss
9​
14-Sep-1917​
Belgium
24​
Fred McIntoshUni, Ess
39​
28-Sep-1917​
Polygon Wood, Belgium
24​
Stan NealeUni
28​
29-Sep-1918​
Bellicourt, France
24​
Alf HedgeSM
16​
04-May-1942​
over Hamburg, Germany
24​
Mo ShapirNM
2​
15-Aug-1942​
Middle East
24​
Bill CosgroveRich
3​
11-Aug-1943​
off Goodenough Island Milne Bay
24​
Dick PirrieHaw
3​
06-Jun-1944​
Normandy, France
24​
Bill HudsonSK
5​
11-Apr-1945​
New Guinea
24​
Charlie MooreEss
30​
12-May-1901​
Kwaggashoek Farm, South Africa
25​
Jack WoodEss
2​
20-Oct-1914​
Melbourne
25​
Rupert BalfeUni
7​
25-Apr-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
25​
Stan McKenzieCarl
14​
08-Dec-1915​
Egypt
25​
George ChallisCarl
70​
15-Jul-1916​
Armentières, France
25​
Jack FreemanSM
22​
15-Nov-1916​
Rouen, France
25​
Malcolm KennedyMelb
17​
02-Jan-1918​
Belgium
25​
Bill RogersCarl
3​
22-Sep-1918​
Rouen, France
25​
Jack AtkinsMelb
4​
01-Mar-1942​
Sunda Strait, off Java
25​
Jim KnightGeel, Carl
43​
11-Oct-1943​
Goodenough Island, Milne Bay
25​
Bob FleggSK
18​
07-Jul-1944​
over Feuersbrunn, Austria
25​
Gower RossSK
8​
14-Feb-1917​
Gueudecourt, France
26​
Jim NicholasUni
1​
20-Sep-1917​
Belgium
26​
Dave CummingUni
21​
03-May-1918​
Villers-Bretonneux, France
26​
Cyril SeelenmeyerUni
6​
08-Aug-1918​
Fouilloy, Somme, France
26​
Harry CollinsFitz
6​
10-Aug-1918​
Villers-Bretonneux, France
26​
Cliff BurgeMelb
5​
14-Aug-1918​
Villers-Bretonneux, France
26​
Gus YoungHaw
10​
29-May-1941​
at sea (Middle East)
26​
Keith TruscottMelb
50​
28-Mar-1943​
Western Australia
26​
Syd AndersonMelb
53​
20-May-1944​
Wewak, New Guinea
26​
Jack LynchGeel
25​
08-Sep-1944​
Far North Queensland
26​
Jeff GrieveSM
11​
08-Nov-1944​
Glen Shee, Scotland
26​
Sid O'NeillFitz
1​
07-Aug-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
27​
Hugh PlowmanSK
26​
19-Jul-1916​
Fromelles, France
27​
Bill NolanRich
30​
23-Jul-1916​
Fleurbaix, France
27​
Paddy RowanColl
82​
05-Dec-1916​
Western Front, France
27​
Bruce SlossEss, SM
84​
04-Jan-1917​
Armentières, France
27​
Jim MackieMelb
5​
20-Mar-1917​
Bapaume, France
27​
Stan MartinUni
65​
03-May-1917​
Bullecourt, France
27​
Tom McCluskeyCarl, Fitz
9​
04-Oct-1917​
Passchendaele, Belgium
27​
Les JamesGeel
72​
22-Oct-1917​
Passchendaele, Belgium
27​
Ron LarkingUni
1​
01-Apr-1918​
Neuve-Église, Belgium
27​
Claude ThomasSM
13​
05-Jul-1918​
Hamel, France
27​
Sam CampbellColl
1​
21-Oct-1918​
Sierra Leone
27​
Ron Barassi SrMelb
58​
31-Jul-1941​
Tobruk, Libya
27​
Stan ReidFitz
24​
29-Jun-1901​
Middel-Kraal, South Africa
28​
Alex RobertsonUni
10​
06-Aug-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
28​
Alick OgilvieMelb, Uni
28​
18-Aug-1915​
Malta
28​
Joe SlaterGeel
108​
03-May-1917​
Bullecourt, France
28​
Jack CooperFitz
136​
20-Sep-1917​
Polygon Wood, Belgium
28​
Otto LowensternSK
12​
01-Dec-1917​
France
28​
Leslie PrimroseUni
16​
04-Jun-1918​
The Somme, France
28​
Fred FieldingSM, Coll
18​
08-Aug-1918​
Villers-Bretonneux, France
28​
Jack DoubledayUni, Melb
53​
30-Oct-1918​
Died at sea, Indian Ocean
28​
Fred HeintzFitz
14​
20-Feb-1942​
Dutch East Indies
28​
Ted ReganMelb, Ess
11​
09-Jul-1943​
over Burma
28​
Beres ReillySK, NM, Melb
13​
23-Jul-1943​
over Crete
28​
Wallace MillsSK
1​
24-Nov-1943​
Far North Queensland
28​
Alan PearsallSM
2​
08-Mar-1944​
over English Channel
28​
Arthur CaldwellSK
8​
26-Jul-1915​
Valletta, Malta
29​
Gerald RyanEss
18​
06-Feb-1917​
Tidworth, England
29​
Dave GillespieCarl
5​
27-Mar-1917​
Melbourne
29​
Hector MitchellSK
1​
16-Jun-1917​
Singapore
29​
Max WheelerHaw
1​
11-Jun-1941​
Syria
29​
Gordon SawleySM
7​
14-Aug-1942​
over Scotland
29​
Clyde HelmerGeel, Melb
73​
24-Apr-1945​
New Guinea
29​
Harold ZuckerHaw
3​
07-Jun-1947​
South Australia
29​
Joe PearceMelb
152​
25-Apr-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
30​
Lewis BlackmoreEss
7​
23-Jul-1916​
Pozières, France
30​
Mal WilliamsUni
7​
02-May-1917​
The Somme, France
30​
Dick CloughEss
2​
02-Jun-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
31​
Joe CrowlGeel
3​
27-Jun-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
31​
Chris FogartyEss, Uni
28​
29-Nov-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
31​
Jack TurnbullSM
12​
02-May-1917​
Western Front, France
31​
John BellGeel
18​
27-Dec-1917​
Western Front, France
31​
Paul BellSK
15​
04-Jul-1945​
Borneo
31​
Ed HarrisonSM
7​
13-Mar-1917​
Étaples, France
32​
Tommy WorleColl
3​
31-Jul-1917​
Armentières, France
32​
George ElliottFitz, Uni
80​
25-Sep-1917​
Ypres, France
32​
Bert O'ConnellSK
2​
17-Oct-1917​
Belgium
32​
Jim ParkCarl
128​
09-Feb-1943​
Wau, New Guinea
32​
Herb HunterEss
3​
08-May-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
33​
James AitkenGeel
1​
08-Aug-1915​
Gallipoli, Turkey
33​
Charles LangtreeColl
1​
03-Aug-1916​
Corbie, France
33​
Jim BonellaMelb
1​
24-May-1918​
France
33​
Jack WadeSM
26​
11-Jun-1941​
Syria
33​
Len JohnsonEss, NM
69​
24-Jan-1942​
Singapore
33​
Percy RobertsFitz
18​
03-Aug-1943​
Burma
33​
Bill GarvieRich
9​
27-Jun-1944​
Far North Queensland
33​
Tom WrightColl
12​
12-Dec-1916​
France
34​
Ralph RobertsonSK
14​
11-May-1917​
Aboukir, Egypt
34​
Bill FischerMelb
1​
15-Oct-1917​
Belgium
34​
Ralph LancasterGeel
44​
28-Aug-1942​
New Guinea
34​
Bill DownieFoots, SK
69​
11-Sep-1943​
Burma
34​
Archie RobertsEss, Melb
48​
06-Jun-1945​
Dutch East Indies
34​
Hughie CallanEss, SM
71​
05-Feb-1917​
Bapaume, France
35​
Bill MaddenSK
26​
03-May-1917​
France
35​
Bill MaxwellMelb
2​
12-Oct-1917​
Passchendaele, Belgium
35​
Alf GiblettHaw
9​
19-Jun-1943​
New Guinea
35​
Len ThomasNM, Haw, SM
209​
17-Aug-1943​
Salamaua, New Guinea
35​
Bert PetersNM
17​
13-Jun-1944​
over English Channel
35​
Arthur McKenzieGeel
4​
18-Jul-1916​
Delville Wood, France
36​
Charlie MorleyEss
3​
13-Apr-1919​
London, England
36​
Arch CorbettUni
7​
25-Jun-1920​
Lost at sea off Toulon, France
36​
Jack SheltonSM, SK
2​
01-May-1941​
Libya
36​
Stuart KingSK
43​
28-Feb-1943​
off Cairns, Far North Queensland
36​
Henry ThomsonCarl
1​
21-May-1943​
Burma
36​
Norm Le BrunCarl, Coll, Ess, SM
50​
15-Nov-1944​
New Guinea
36​
Harry ComteSK
104​
30-May-1945​
Tarakan, Dutch East Indies
36​
Leo RankinMelb
1​
10-May-1917​
Dorset, England
37​
Albert GourlayCarl, Melb
6​
15-Aug-1917​
England
37​
Jack DrakeHaw
3​
23-Apr-1941​
Greece
37​
Alf GoonanNM
7​
22-Jan-1942​
Malaya
37​
Jim PenderCarl
15​
02-Jul-1916​
Bois-Grenier, France
38​
Bobby RoyleMelb
3​
03-Nov-1916​
France
38​
Harry DanielCarl
11​
10-Aug-1918​
France
39​
Barney WoodMelb
5​
09-Jun-1941​
Litani River, Syria
39​
Tommy CorriganFitz
107​
09-Jan-1943​
Heidelberg Military Hospital
39​
Paddy McGuinnessSK
1​
06-May-1918​
France
40​
Jack PriceHaw
10​
27-Jun-1941​
Syria
40​
Tasman RobertsSK, Fitz
58​
09-Apr-1942​
Rabaul
40​
Jim FarnanSK
1​
09-Aug-1916​
France
41​
Harold RipponMelb, SM
9​
16-Jan-1917​
France
42​
Peter MartinColl
15​
25-Mar-1918​
Melbourne
42​
Derek MollisonMelb
66​
19-Dec-1943​
Queensland
42​
Charlie OliverCarl
1​
29-Dec-1917​
Melbourne
43​
Ken MacLeodUni
54​
08-Apr-1940​
off Trondheim, Norway
49​
 

Remove this Banner Ad

VFL/AFL players who died young

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top