- Sep 11, 2009
- 1,688
- 4
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Banned
- #26
lol Mclean you put im ahead of Gibbs and Houilhan.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Votes Carlton def Geelong
- Thread starter blue gunslinger
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- May 29, 2009
- 29,823
- 14,883
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- LA Lakers
No I didn't you idiot, I gave Gibbs 5 votes and McLean none despite a team leading 8 tackles.
- Sep 11, 2009
- 1,688
- 4
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Banned
- #28
Kreuzer one of my favorites but he was one of the worst today with Henderson.Carrazzo had the ball a bit but he did butch the ball a bit.Mclean did ok for his first game back after injury but i reckon he do better then that.
Ill go Judd, Gibbs,Russell..Thought Army was fantastic today ,yes a few yips but really took them on to open up the game.Well done. Well done to coach Ratts whom went in with an unorthodox team to beat the Catters.Over all well done to the team that played cohesively and showed great poise when under pressure, yet applied pressure beautifully to a team that excells under pressure.Well done Blues ,may the likes of big red ,etc take the batton and create a match review?
5. Judd
4. Gibbs
3. Armfield
2. Russell
1. Scotland
4. Gibbs
3. Armfield
2. Russell
1. Scotland
- Sep 26, 2004
- 47,809
- 64,764
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #32
Impossible to do.
Divide the votes equally between all the players and Ratten.
No passengers out there today. A real team effort.
Divide the votes equally between all the players and Ratten.
No passengers out there today. A real team effort.
Marissa_45
Cancelled
- Banned
- #35
5. Gibbs
4. Rusty
3. Juddy
2. Scotland
1. Armfield.
Oh but really so many of them could have been in there.
4. Rusty
3. Juddy
2. Scotland
1. Armfield.
Oh but really so many of them could have been in there.
Marissa_45
Cancelled
- Banned
- #36
Oh yeah Jammo was inspirational today. haha
5. Judd - Set up the win. Was instrumental when it mattered and smashed Selwood in the first quarter.
4. Gibbs - Kicking is elite. Ran hard all day whilst still beating his opponent in many 1 on 1's.
3. Russel - Did Steve Johnson play?
2. Walker - Gave the "Spudahawk" a bath! Gave great run an carry...
1. Murphy - Has too much time all the bloody time. Just oozes class and will be an elite midfielder soon (if he isn't already).
Unlucky: Scotland, Houlihan, Armfield, Garlett, Carrazzo, Simpson.
4. Gibbs - Kicking is elite. Ran hard all day whilst still beating his opponent in many 1 on 1's.
3. Russel - Did Steve Johnson play?
2. Walker - Gave the "Spudahawk" a bath! Gave great run an carry...
1. Murphy - Has too much time all the bloody time. Just oozes class and will be an elite midfielder soon (if he isn't already).
Unlucky: Scotland, Houlihan, Armfield, Garlett, Carrazzo, Simpson.
i never usually post about votes for players, but i'm so fu#$%ng happy with the blues, i'll bite one time
5 - gibbs, class, composure and skill, a wonderful combination
4 - russell, tore stevie j an absolute new one
3 - judd... enough said, ok, first half, absolute on-field leadership
2 - armfield, best game for the club if you ask me
1 - our new mosquito fleet on the half forward line, yarran, bloody great goal at start of the 4th amongst many highs, betts, very good and garlett after a slow start, found more confidence and played great in the 2nd half
5 - gibbs, class, composure and skill, a wonderful combination
4 - russell, tore stevie j an absolute new one
3 - judd... enough said, ok, first half, absolute on-field leadership
2 - armfield, best game for the club if you ask me
1 - our new mosquito fleet on the half forward line, yarran, bloody great goal at start of the 4th amongst many highs, betts, very good and garlett after a slow start, found more confidence and played great in the 2nd half
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Moderator
- #39
5. Scotland
4. Russell
3. Gibbs
2. Armfield
1. Judd
Walker was in the votes had he not lost a quarter and a half. Jamo and White were great and the terrific small forward trio were collectively BOG but they shared the load so well, I couldn't pick one out over another.
4. Russell
3. Gibbs
2. Armfield
1. Judd
Walker was in the votes had he not lost a quarter and a half. Jamo and White were great and the terrific small forward trio were collectively BOG but they shared the load so well, I couldn't pick one out over another.
You are a worry - knocking Carlton supporters with incorrect info (nearly said fellow Carlton supporters)
5 Judd - got nod over Gibbsy's superb disposal because of where he plays
4 Gibbs
3 Scotland (still any knockers
)2 JR (but I still don't like him kicking out)
1 Simmo gets the nod narrowly from Army, Jammo, the Blues Brothers, ... because I love the way he throws his flyweight body in
Agree that it's hard to split the team. So, in no particular order:
* Scotland - Juddy buddy who won a lot of hard ball and used it constructively. Brock McLean should watch his tape.
* Russell - He called it. Totally towelled up Johnson and was a composed (despite what others might think) leader in the backline.
* Walker & Armfield - two-pronged half back attack! Their run and defensive pressure breathtaking.
* Gibbs - the third back who nullified attack and provided drive through the centre
* Judd - fluffed it a coupla times in the first quarter, but lifted to usual standard.
* Garlett & Yarran - livewires who hunted down ball-carriers and created scoring opportunities.
* Simpson, Murph, Kreuzer - tireless contributors. Krueze's second efforts and ruckwork were huge.
* Scotland - Juddy buddy who won a lot of hard ball and used it constructively. Brock McLean should watch his tape.
* Russell - He called it. Totally towelled up Johnson and was a composed (despite what others might think) leader in the backline.
* Walker & Armfield - two-pronged half back attack! Their run and defensive pressure breathtaking.
* Gibbs - the third back who nullified attack and provided drive through the centre
* Judd - fluffed it a coupla times in the first quarter, but lifted to usual standard.
* Garlett & Yarran - livewires who hunted down ball-carriers and created scoring opportunities.
* Simpson, Murph, Kreuzer - tireless contributors. Krueze's second efforts and ruckwork were huge.
Mister Carlton
Better than you.
5. Chris Judd.
4. Jordan Russell.
3. Dennis Armfield
2. Jeff Garlett.
1. Bryce Gibbs.
Special mentions: Chris Yarran, Kane Lucas, Heath Scotland, Marc Murphy and Simon White.
Great game. No passengers and young players like Lucas, White, Yarran and Garlett have stepped up and will stay in our 22 for weeks to come.
Go blues!
4. Jordan Russell.
3. Dennis Armfield
2. Jeff Garlett.
1. Bryce Gibbs.
Special mentions: Chris Yarran, Kane Lucas, Heath Scotland, Marc Murphy and Simon White.
Great game. No passengers and young players like Lucas, White, Yarran and Garlett have stepped up and will stay in our 22 for weeks to come.
Go blues!
5. Russell
4. Gibbs
3. Judd
2. Armfield
1. Garlett
4. Gibbs
3. Judd
2. Armfield
1. Garlett
BOG today goes to the Carlton Football Club.
Votes:
5 - 5
4 - 4
3 - 3
2 - 2
1 - 27
Votes:
5 - 5
4 - 4
3 - 3
2 - 2
1 - 27
5. Judd
4. Russell
3. Gibbs
2. Walker
1. Garlett
4. Russell
3. Gibbs
2. Walker
1. Garlett
Blue Bloods
Norm Smith Medallist
5. Judd
4. Russell
3. Scotland
2. Gibbs
1. Armfield/Walker
What a great game, what a great team
4. Russell
3. Scotland
2. Gibbs
1. Armfield/Walker
What a great game, what a great team
grantox
Rookie
5. judd- inspiring
4. gibbs- best game all year
3. garlett- malthouse will be shit*** himself about the 3 of them
2. scotland- continues career best form
1. russell- as all the previous comments said about him
4. gibbs- best game all year
3. garlett- malthouse will be shit*** himself about the 3 of them
2. scotland- continues career best form
1. russell- as all the previous comments said about him
I see what you did there...
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
