-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Votes Carlton def Geelong
- Thread starter blue gunslinger
- Start date
- Tagged users None
OldBlueFan
Premiership Player
- Sep 23, 2009
- 3,032
- 3,164
- AFL Club
- Carlton
5. Bryce Gibbs - As someone else said, the perfect balance of attack and defence today.
4. Chris Judd - Started it all, and yes, Ling slowed him up a bit in the second half, but taking a great contested mark in defence during the last 1/4 was just one of the vital touches he still got in the 2nd half.
3. Heath Scotland - Another great game, he's having his best season for the Blues so far.
2. Jordan Russell - Walker should have got his votes, but alas ...
1. Jeff Garlett - I was astounded by how far he was prepared to run today, just shaded Eddie as the best of of the 3 Amigos. Contested marks from a toothpick ... amazing.
Special mention to the entire rest of the team (except maybe Hendo, but only because he couldn't hold his grabs)
4. Chris Judd - Started it all, and yes, Ling slowed him up a bit in the second half, but taking a great contested mark in defence during the last 1/4 was just one of the vital touches he still got in the 2nd half.
3. Heath Scotland - Another great game, he's having his best season for the Blues so far.
2. Jordan Russell - Walker should have got his votes, but alas ...
1. Jeff Garlett - I was astounded by how far he was prepared to run today, just shaded Eddie as the best of of the 3 Amigos. Contested marks from a toothpick ... amazing.
Special mention to the entire rest of the team (except maybe Hendo, but only because he couldn't hold his grabs)
5 - Jordan Russell - Had a task to do and accomplished it perfectly.
4 - Chris Judd - His speed and work-rate were second to none.
3 - Heath Scotland - Was all over the place, working hard and always making the right decisions.
2 - Jeff Garlett - Outmarked bigger opponents, was very dangerous up front.
1 - Andrew Walker - Before injury, was relishing his role in the team. Disposal has improved 50000000%.
4 - Chris Judd - His speed and work-rate were second to none.
3 - Heath Scotland - Was all over the place, working hard and always making the right decisions.
2 - Jeff Garlett - Outmarked bigger opponents, was very dangerous up front.
1 - Andrew Walker - Before injury, was relishing his role in the team. Disposal has improved 50000000%.
Hayashi_62
Team Captain
5. Russell
4. Judd
3. Gibbs
2. Scotland
1. Garlett
4. Judd
3. Gibbs
2. Scotland
1. Garlett
5. Jordan Russell
4. Bryce Gibbs
3. Andrew Walker (was the catalyst in the first quarter along with Judd.)
2. Chris Judd
1. Heath Scotland.
4. Bryce Gibbs
3. Andrew Walker (was the catalyst in the first quarter along with Judd.)
2. Chris Judd
1. Heath Scotland.
NAUGHT5
Club Legend
- Sep 29, 2008
- 2,875
- 81
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Phillies, Bulls
5- Russell - Dominated Stevie J. I knew our backs would do the job on the 3 talls. I was only concerned about Johnson. Untill he got Russelled.
4- Judd - Set the game up. Faded but drew plenty of attention.
3- Armfield - I thought he was sensational.
2- Gibbs - Stiff to only get 2. Was very good.
1- Walker - still turns it over but was brilliant. Runs hard and quick and dominated Hawkins. Takes risks.
Garlett, Scotland stiff.
4- Judd - Set the game up. Faded but drew plenty of attention.
3- Armfield - I thought he was sensational.
2- Gibbs - Stiff to only get 2. Was very good.
1- Walker - still turns it over but was brilliant. Runs hard and quick and dominated Hawkins. Takes risks.
Garlett, Scotland stiff.
Blue and Silver
Brownlow Medallist
5- C Judd- got it all started and despite fading had the biggest impact on the outcome
4- H Scotland- Created opportunities well
3- B Gibbs- Him and Scotland worked very well off of half-back, was on Chapman who barely did anything
2- J Russell- Held Stevie J to perfection
1- J Gartlett- Loved seeing him come up the ground, then running back to create opportunities
4- H Scotland- Created opportunities well
3- B Gibbs- Him and Scotland worked very well off of half-back, was on Chapman who barely did anything
2- J Russell- Held Stevie J to perfection
1- J Gartlett- Loved seeing him come up the ground, then running back to create opportunities
5. Scotland - Has stepped it up this year, on field leader.
4. Gibbs - killed it off half back, precision kicking.
3. Russell - Body on body work was superb and beat a gun, hands down.
2. Judd - Top of his game when it mattered most.
1. Jamison - Beat everybody who came near him, not since SOS have I felt comfortable when the opposition kicks it long to a one-out in the square. Great one on one ability.
4. Gibbs - killed it off half back, precision kicking.
3. Russell - Body on body work was superb and beat a gun, hands down.
2. Judd - Top of his game when it mattered most.
1. Jamison - Beat everybody who came near him, not since SOS have I felt comfortable when the opposition kicks it long to a one-out in the square. Great one on one ability.
5: C.Judd
4: B.Gibbs
3: J.Garlett
2: H.Scotland
1: J.Russell
4: B.Gibbs
3: J.Garlett
2: H.Scotland
1: J.Russell
^Ablett had a better game than that. Bomber Thompson is a prick
Agreed. Also a prick for putting Ablett on the spot in one of their dinners. Makes one suspect that he already knows the answer to the GC17 Question...
Well yeah, it made me think that Bomber really needs to treat him 'nicer' if he wants to keep him. Unless of course, Bomber allready knows something.
HBF
Flying Scotsman
- Sep 24, 2002
- 156,223
- 101,324
- AFL Club
- Carlton
A bit late, but here it goes:
5. Judd
4. Gibbs
3. JR
2. Scotland
1. Garlett
5. Judd
4. Gibbs
3. JR
2. Scotland
1. Garlett
ESKIE
Keeping it Cool.
- Feb 28, 2009
- 33,129
- 57,334
- AFL Club
- Carlton
5. Judd
4. Gibbs
3. Armfield
2. Russell
1. Murphy
Really wanted to squeeze Walker and Garlett in there....next week hopefully
4. Gibbs
3. Armfield
2. Russell
1. Murphy
Really wanted to squeeze Walker and Garlett in there....next week hopefully
5. Judd
4. Gibbs
3. Scotland
2. Russell
1. Garlett
4. Gibbs
3. Scotland
2. Russell
1. Garlett
5. Russell (Who would have thought only 12 months ago)
4. Judd.
3. Gibbs
2. Armfield
1. Jamison
Must follow on with Russell here. His burst of pace to get to a contest still has me shaking my head.
A very powerful runner and with his self belief now, may just exceed all our expectations in time to come.
Power to the Jack.
4. Judd.
3. Gibbs
2. Armfield
1. Jamison
Must follow on with Russell here. His burst of pace to get to a contest still has me shaking my head.
A very powerful runner and with his self belief now, may just exceed all our expectations in time to come.
Power to the Jack.
blue gunslinger
Hall of Famer
- Thread starter
- #95
5 Judd: this week yes!
4 Gibbs : this week I am happier
3 Army: good work kid
2 JR: whipping boy holds the whip
1 Scotland: solid
close - 3 Amigos
WOG- Hendo: I know he needs time etc but some of those missed opps
4 Gibbs : this week I am happier
3 Army: good work kid
2 JR: whipping boy holds the whip
1 Scotland: solid
close - 3 Amigos
WOG- Hendo: I know he needs time etc but some of those missed opps
OldBlueFan
Premiership Player
- Sep 23, 2009
- 3,032
- 3,164
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Do you think this is the way they would have done it?
Coach 1:
5 Gibbs (Carl)
4 Garlett (Carl)
3 Russell (Carl)
2 Ablett (Geel)
1 Simpson (Carl)
Coach 2:
5 Gibbs (Carl)
4 Judd (Carl)
3 Carrazzo (Carl)
2 Scotland (Carl)
1 Garlett (Carl)
If it is, then both coaches were pretty hard on their champs
(I'm assuming that Thompson didn't give Ablett any based on his comment)
- May 29, 2009
- 29,823
- 14,883
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- LA Lakers
Carrazzo was brilliant.
Coaches Votes:
Carlton vs Geelong
10 Gibbs (Carl)
5 Garlett (Carl)
4 Judd (Carl)
3 Carrazzo (Carl)
3 Russell (Carl)
2 Scotland (Carl)
2 Ablett (Geel)
1 Simpson (Carl)
Carlton 4.3 10.8 12.13 15.14 (104)
Geelong 3.4 5.7 7.10 9.14 (68)
GOALS
Carlton: Garlett 3, Betts 2, Murphy 2, Houlihan 2, Yarran 2, Judd, Kreuzer, O'hAilpin, Scotland
Geelong: Ablett 2, Johnson, Kelly, Hogan, Milburn, Mooney, Selwood, Taylor
BEST
Carlton: Judd, Gibbs, Russell, Carrazzo, Jamison, Armfield, Scotland
Geelong: Ablett, Chapman, Bartel, Milburn, Wojcinski, Mackie.
PatrickBateman
Norm Smith Medallist
Carrazzo was brilliant.
Coaches Votes:
Carlton vs Geelong
10 Gibbs (Carl)
5 Garlett (Carl)
4 Judd (Carl)
3 Carrazzo (Carl)
3 Russell (Carl)
2 Scotland (Carl)
2 Ablett (Geel)
1 Simpson (Carl)
Carlton 4.3 10.8 12.13 15.14 (104)
Geelong 3.4 5.7 7.10 9.14 (68)
GOALS
Carlton: Garlett 3, Betts 2, Murphy 2, Houlihan 2, Yarran 2, Judd, Kreuzer, O'hAilpin, Scotland
Geelong: Ablett 2, Johnson, Kelly, Hogan, Milburn, Mooney, Selwood, Taylor
BEST
Carlton: Judd, Gibbs, Russell, Carrazzo, Jamison, Armfield, Scotland
Geelong: Ablett, Chapman, Bartel, Milburn, Wojcinski, Mackie.
So Thompson obviously gave all his votes to Carlton players, Ratten gave 2 to Ablett.. God dam, what a dummy spit by Thompson. For mine, Judd was Carlton's best. I'm not down with players who spend the entire game running around defense by themselves(Carrazzo/Gibbs). These votes are warped. Judd 4?? Gibbs 10... Look at it this way... swap Judd(loose in defence)/Gibbs(on the ball and tagged)... Judd would destroy Geelong, Gibbs wouldn't get a touch. Judd/Ablett seriously underrated here.
Hows those sour grapes going champ ?
I'm tipping we could have swapped Gibbs and Judd around and still have won the game ..with Gibbs getting plenty of damaging possessions ..you really do overrate your players ...hence all the sour grapes you are sucking on right now .
PatrickBateman
Norm Smith Medallist
Hows those sour grapes going champ ?
I'm tipping we could have swapped Gibbs and Judd around and still have won the game ..with Gibbs getting plenty of damaging possessions ..you really do overrate your players ...hence all the sour grapes you are sucking on right now .
Nice one. Not that I was even having a stab at Carlton in particular, just don't agree with the votes or Gibbs ability to play in the midfield w/tag. Trust me, the sweetness of witnessing 2 Premierships in person overpowers any 2010 round 5 sourness. Only 3 days of this week to go. Enjoy it.
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
