he's more like a Sean Darcy from Fremantle than a forward.What’s the general thoughts on Broadbent’s ability to split time between ruck and forward? Can he be a goal kicker?
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
he's more like a Sean Darcy from Fremantle than a forward.What’s the general thoughts on Broadbent’s ability to split time between ruck and forward? Can he be a goal kicker?
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Sean is handy resting forward. I know that's not the same thing as being a forward/ruck, especially the mobility and speed issues.he's more like a Sean Darcy from Fremantle than a forward.
Darcy is a very strong mark when he goes up forward, it's one of his strengths.he's more like a Sean Darcy from Fremantle than a forward.
Hey mate who would you compare chase bourne, kane bevan, sam gilbey and christian wilson to AFL players, like who do they have similarities to by the way they play.Saw two games live this weekend, here are the players that stood out for mine:
West Perth vs Claremont
Kane Bevan (WP #9) - I think we all know what Bevan is capable of at this point. His biggest knock is the lack of foot speed, but has a mass of other talents. Fantastic at reading the ball, spread from the contest, has a knack for winning free kicks (already fits into the AFL with the diving forward when tackled or drawing high contact. Not a fan of it, but has proven to work at every level by players in the past), has a decent enough kick - gets penetration and doesn't loop it up.
Jack DeMarte (WP #18) - Simply too good for the colts at this point as an overager. Should be playing in the reserves to push for league footy. He's just bullying kids out there with his 2 years of experience in the system. Cracking goal sense.
Daniel Gathercole (WP #16) - Really composed user of the footy out of the backline. Feel like he's grown an inch or two over the offseason, looks like he's also hit the weight bench. Should slot straight into the WA under 18 team this year, feel like a lack of versatility may hurt his draft chances, not a lot of want for pure backmen who don't break the lines.
Luke Michael (WP #7) - Undersized floating intercept defender. Reads the play exceptionally well, was key to WP hanging on, has magnet like hands. Really impressed how easily he makes everything look.
Noah Vanderwiel (WP #32) - Really crafty forward type, loves pushing up the ground to get the ball in his hands, loves crumbing at ground level inside forward 50. Hopefully the injury he sustained wasn't too serious (didn't look great), and he can keep pushing his case this and next year.
Aiden Riddle (C #40) - just bullied Sprigg off the park in the ruck, couldn't believe he was an underager. Claremont have really found one here, the kid is a gem. Just has that bit of X-factor about him in that he excites with his ruckwork and follow-up efforts. One to watch.
Harry Cole (C #3) - Great offensively, horrible defensively. Just didn't look interested in tracking back to help out without the footy, but found him extremely dynamic when moving the ball forward.
Kai Dehavilland (C #10) - Undersized midfielder, but plays with a lot of heart, something you don't get from every kid out there. Really makes the opposition earn their kicks. Would love to see him get his hands on the footy more.
Sam Gilbey (C #9) - wasn't at all impressed by Sam's game on the weekend but I know he has more to give and he'll be disappointed in himself I feel. Needs to find the footy more and use his pace and kicking ability to cut through opposing teams.
Daniel Curtin (C #21) - first time I've seen him play, and I get it. Just a freakish athletic kid, strong hands, great workrate, kicking is 50/50 whether it's elite or shocking, but if he keeps working on it I don't see any reason why he won't be a first-second rounder next year.
Cooper Childs (C #39) - undersized small forward, but just radiates the same type of energy as a Jason Castagna. High pressure, frantic workrate in the F50, loves a kick for goal.
Subiaco vs South Fremantle
Koltyn Tholstrup (S #23) - wow! Was really impressed by his contested work in the forward line early in the game, and his move into the midfield impressed me more. Moves so well for a kid of his size, cannot fault the effort and follow-up efforts in ground ball contests. Really loved what I saw, this kid will make it to the AFL
Lance Collard (S #10) - just so crafty with his ball movement and delivery inside 50. Just needs to find more open space and get his hands on the footy. Once he builds a little more confidence at this level (just his 5th colts game) he'll be unstoppable with his attributes
Robert Hansen jnr (S #13) - strongly built kid, liked what he brought to the table on debut. Needs some time and seasoning but has some nice ball skills and breakaway speed
Zac Sadowski (S #16) - strong key defender, a little undersized to play that role at higher levels but does his job with aplomb in the colts
Roan O'Hehir (SF #33) - wearing 33 like his younger sister (who is an incredible league footballer at 15 years old), reads the footy well, creates his own space at the contest, finds good options by hand and foot
Chase Bourne (SF #3) - if you told me he was the best player on the team I wouldn't have believed you. Really struggled to get into the game at all. I think the coaches need to find a balance between playing him in the mids and playing him forward. Didn't get near the footy in the first quarter and think that had an impact on the rest of his game. He needs the footy to have confidence, and leaving him stranded in the forward line when his teammates can't get it down to him just isn't the go. Should start the game in the middle, he and the team need him with the ball to have an impact.
Christian Wilson (SF #7) - love him. Such a smart kid, knows how to win the footy and where to be to receive it and keep the ball going forward. Unfortunately just too small to be considered at the next level.
Seth Connor (SF #15) - overager, can find the footy, smart positioning, but wouldn't be surprised if more than half of his kicks were turnovers. Souths need to find a better outlet, because he shouldn't be the one trying to hit targets.
Not a senior SENIOR player but would love any more info on 20 year old Wade Derksen from Northern Territory who came down late to Peel Thunder last year.
Has returned recently and the 197cm forward kicked 4 goals today and 8 in his 3 games in 2022.
Cheers for that, is friends of friends so keen to see what the more educated thought of him.My brief take based on last weeks game against West Perth(I didn't see today's game against West Coast where he kicked four goals).
My initial impressions was that he was noticeable and useful but I have some concerns on the athletics side that I would want to see some stats on first and competition against some more dangerous opponents before suggesting that he is in range for a drafting this year.
- On face value he has a reasonable level of mobility for a big guy (WAFL says 197cm), although (to compare to others out on the field) not as athletic as Treacy or Amiss - not sure there was any good speed, but didn't look too slow and lumbering. Seems to have a good leap.
- Played as both a leading third forward and as a ruck and impacted as the forward taking some good marks and kicking a couple of useful goals. I did note though that he was playing more as the third forward behind Amiss (kicked 5 goals and looked dangerous as a target all game) and Treacy (kicked four goals, also looked much more dangerous that Dersken) and as such got probably lesser opponents, but on the flip side had to play further away from goal which would have lessened his opportunities.
- I thought he had really good hands in contested marking situations;
- I thought his rucking was serviceable, with the main attribute being able to get his hands on the ball a bit and generally tends to kick it well (ended up with 17 possessions).
Leader Board Games Votes Ave Goals
Seth Connor+ (SF) 2 22 11.00 2
Mitchell Keene** (P) 1 11 11.00 -
Connor Carbone (PT) 1 9 9.00 -
Connor McDonald (P) 1 9 9.00 -
Darcy Jones (SD) 3 23 7.67 -
Jedd Busslinger (EP) 3 22 7.33 1
Kane Bevan (WP) 3 22 7.33 2
Angus Laurisson+ (SD) 3 22 7.33 -
Koltyn Tholstrup** (S) 3 20 6.67 9
Jack Demarte+ (WP) 3 18 6.00 9
Jed Hagan (EF) 3 18 6.00 1
Lance Collard** (S) 1 6 6.00 2
Fletcher Netherway (CL) 2 12 6.00 2
Kai Holmes+ (SF) 1 6 6.00 -
Michael Durack (SD) 2 11 5.50 1
Jack Gouge (S) 2 11 5.50 1
Jack Cleaver (EF) 3 16 5.33 -
Chase Bourne (SF) 2 10 5.00 3
Riley Hardeman** (SD) 3 15 5.00 1
Cameron Hall (P) 2 10 5.00 -
Joel Rush (PT) 2 10 5.00 1
James Spadanuda (EF) 3 15 5.00 2
Hugh Davies (CL) 2 9 4.50 -
Baxter Phillip (P) 2 9 4.50 4
Coen Livingstone** (P) 2 9 4.50 1
Reece Torrent** (PT) 2 9 4.50 -
Sokaa Soka+ (EP) 3 12 4.00 -
Corey Tregenza-Cashell+ (PT) 1 4 4.00 3
Luke Yeo (EF) 3 11 3.67 3
Noah Farrow (WP) 3 11 3.67 2
Christian Wilson (SF) 2 7 3.50 -
Jasper Scaife (WP) 2 7 3.50 5
Conrad Williams (CL) 2 7 3.50 -
Ethan Logan** (PT) 2 7 3.50 -
Daniel Gathercole (WP) 3 10 3.33 -
Jacob Evitt (S) 3 10 3.33 2
Mitch Lonnie (WP) 3 9 3.00 3
Jordyn Baker (EP) 3 9 3.00 -
Michael Sellwood+ (PT) 2 6 3.00 -
Rohan O'Hehir (SF) 2 6 3.00 -
Edward Graham (SF) 2 6 3.00 3
Rudy Webster** (SF) 1 3 3.00 -
Darcy Clarke** (PT) 1 3 3.00 -
Dylan O'Dea** (S) 3 9 3.00 -
Ben Weymouth+ (P) 2 6 3.00 -
Tyler Messina** (EF) 1 3 3.00 2
Joe Matthews** (CL) 1 3 3.00 2
Ethan Barbieri (S) 3 8 2.67 -
Will Bailey (CL) 3 8 2.67 1
Josh Sukuroski (CL) 3 8 2.67 -
Max Willson** (CL) 3 8 2.67 2
Jackson Broadbent (PT) 2 5 2.50 -
Robert Hansen Jr (S) 3 7 2.33 4
Xavier Milner (EP) 3 7 2.33 -
Awesome write up and thanks for the work you put in. Noticed you have Seth Connor with another BOG or close to it… I thought his skills were 1st class, what are your thoughts on his prospects?Awesome ... thanks
Yeah a few very unlucky. Some that spring to mind.
Hugh Davies (CL)
Joel Rush (PT)
Jacob Evitt (S)
Will Bailey (CL)
Michael Durack (SD)
Ethan Barbieri (S)
Connor McDonald (P)
Angus Laurisson (SD) # 2003 DOB
I really like the skills and pace of Christian Wilson (SF) but I guess he's considered to be too small. Would have added Sokaa Soka (EP) # as a project back up ruck/key defender just in case
Awesome write up and thanks for the work you put in. Noticed you have Seth Connor with another BOG or close to it… I thought his skills were 1st class, what are your thoughts on his prospects?
According to the list above, very low chance if he didn’t make the state 18’s. Dont no how many 19 year olds are in it though. He is a 19 yo playing against younger kids- it’s always a mismatch. Will he play league - thats the requirement most likely.Awesome write up and thanks for the work you put in. Noticed you have Seth Connor with another BOG or close to it… I thought his skills were 1st class, what are your thoughts on his prospects?
Agreed, needs to make the 18’s and play league at some point. He is 18 and missed last year with an ACL so hasn’t played for 18 months. First 2 games back not too bad.According to the list above, very low chance if he didn’t make the state 18’s. Dont no how many 19 year olds are in it though. He is a 19 yo playing against younger kids- it’s always a mismatch. Will he play league - thats the requirement most likely.
I'm interested that you think he's less athletic than Treacy, given his size, he looks more athletic and mobile to me, definitely not as athletic as Amiss thoughMy brief take based on last weeks game against West Perth(I didn't see today's game against West Coast where he kicked four goals).
My initial impressions was that he was noticeable and useful but I have some concerns on the athletics side that I would want to see some stats on first and competition against some more dangerous opponents before suggesting that he is in range for a drafting this year.
- On face value he has a reasonable level of mobility for a big guy (WAFL says 197cm), although (to compare to others out on the field) not as athletic as Treacy or Amiss - not sure there was any good speed, but didn't look too slow and lumbering. Seems to have a good leap.
- Played as both a leading third forward and as a ruck and impacted as the forward taking some good marks and kicking a couple of useful goals. I did note though that he was playing more as the third forward behind Amiss (kicked 5 goals and looked dangerous as a target all game) and Treacy (kicked four goals, also looked much more dangerous that Dersken) and as such got probably lesser opponents, but on the flip side had to play further away from goal which would have lessened his opportunities.
- I thought he had really good hands in contested marking situations;
- I thought his rucking was serviceable, with the main attribute being able to get his hands on the ball a bit and generally tends to kick it well (ended up with 17 possessions).
Just my impression watching all three in the same Peel vs West Perth game; Treacy is a smaller player (by 3-4cm?) but I felt (in that game) that he was getting up around the same height in aerial contests as Dersken (there were a couple where both were going for the same ball), I also felt faster around the field. I definitely think that Amiss is in the next category of speed (which I think agrees with your perception too), but as I said, my points were only on the sample of one, so happy to acknowledge that I could be wrong.I'm interested that you think he's less athletic than Treacy, given his size, he looks more athletic and mobile to me, definitely not as athletic as Amiss though
Leader Board Games Votes Ave Goals
Seth Connor+ (SF) 3 33 11.00 2
Koltyn Tholstrup** (S) 4 32 8.00 14
Angus Laurisson+ (SD) 4 29 7.25 -
Darcy Jones (SD) 4 27 6.75 3
Riley Hardeman** (SD) 4 27 6.75 1
Jedd Busslinger (EP) 4 26 6.50 1
Kane Bevan (WP) 4 25 6.25 2
Jack Demarte+ (WP) 3 18 6.00 9
Jed Hagan (EF) 3 18 6.00 1
Michael Sellwood+ (PT) 3 18 6.00 4
Lance Collard** (S) 1 6 6.00 2
Kai Holmes+ (SF) 1 6 6.00 -
Reece Torrent** (PT) 3 17 5.67 -
Mitchell Keene** (P) 2 11 5.50 -
Jack Cleaver (EF) 3 16 5.33 -
Fletcher Netherway (CL) 3 16 5.33 3
James Spadanuda (EF) 3 15 5.00 2
Jordyn Baker (EP) 4 19 4.75 2
Cameron Hall (P) 3 14 4.67 -
Connor McDonald (P) 2 9 4.50 -
Hugh Davies (CL) 2 9 4.50 -
Coen Livingstone** (P) 2 9 4.50 1
Connor Carbone (PT) 2 9 4.50 -
Joel Rush (PT) 3 14 4.33 2
Mitch Barron (CL) 4 16 4.00 1
Baxter Phillip (P) 3 12 4.00 5
Sokaa Soka+ (EP) 3 12 4.00 -
Luke Yeo (EF) 3 11 3.67 3
Michael Durack (SD) 3 11 3.67 1
Jack Gouge (S) 3 11 3.67 2
Luke Michael (WP) 4 14 3.50 -
Conrad Williams (CL) 2 7 3.50 -
Chase Bourne (SF) 3 10 3.33 3
Lachlan Turley+ (SF) 3 10 3.33 -
Mitchell Williams** (EP) 4 13 3.25 9
Daniel Gathercole (WP) 4 12 3.00 -
Tyler Messina** (EF) 1 3 3.00 2
Cooper Osborne (PT) 3 9 3.00 -
Edward Graham (SF) 2 6 3.00 3
Rudy Webster** (SF) 1 3 3.00 -
Noah Farrow (WP) 4 12 3.00 4
Tyrone Virgo (EP) 2 6 3.00 2
Darcy Clarke** (PT) 1 3 3.00 -
Joe Matthews** (CL) 1 3 3.00 2
Josh Sukuroski (CL) 4 11 2.75 -
Ethan Barbieri (S) 4 11 2.75 -
Aiden Nelson+ (WP) 4 11 2.75 -
Ben Fairbank (P) 3 8 2.67 -
Jacob Evitt (S) 4 10 2.50 2
Ethan Logan** (PT) 3 7 2.33 -
Christian Wilson (SF) 3 7 2.33 -
Rohan O'Hehir (SF) 3 7 2.33 -
Jasper Scaife (WP) 3 7 2.33 6
This take not aging well. 3 games 3 best on ground or close to it… disposal as good as anyone in the team and showing up a number of state selected players each game. Was checked closely against West Perth, played 57% game time and still got 28 touches.Was probably told he wouldn't get a gig as an overager/wouldn't get a lot of mid time and requested to switch. Kids move colts clubs for opportunities all the time, he's not someone you should be worried about losing.
A number of WC NGA players there. Be interesting to see what the whole NGA joke looks like in two years. Should just **** it off.My appolgies
Swan Districts have the most players in the squad with eight, including five aligned with the South West Academy, while Subiaco and Peel Thunder have six apiece.
WA under-16s squad
Claremont: Austin van der Struyf, Hugh Boxshall, Jaxon Douglas, Lucas Ravenhill, Will Thomas
East Fremantle: Jacob Calabrese
East Perth: William Akec, Tyler Lindberg, Xavier Walsh
Peel Thunder: Albert Esterhuysen, Bo Allan, Darcy Peterson, Deian Roberts, Harry Case, Lukas Jakovich
Perth: Ali Al-Shuweli, Cooper Moore
Subiaco: Caylon Seelander, Koopa Walsh, Malakai Champion, Mitch Bell, Thomas MacGillivray, Xavier Hickey
Swan Districts: Anthony Hansen, Chayse Martinson, Cody Ryan, Colby McDonald, Harrison Chreighton, Harry Jones, Otis Harvey, Thomas Cathcart
West Perth: Baylee Payne, Kayde Sherwood, Kayle Gerreyn, Trent Hiscock