Collingwood lose big time here.
As a min the Eagles would need to throw in pick 36 for the Pies to help balance this up, pick 52 as well possibly.
Pies still look a tad short changed though.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 7 - Pride Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
WCE/Rich/Coll/Port trade for the experts to dissect!
- Thread starter Deepthroat
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Collingwood lose big time here.
As a min the Eagles would need to throw in pick 36 for the Pies to help balance this up, pick 52 as well possibly.
Pies still look a tad short changed though.
it's been stated publicly that we wont part with kerr for less than a top 5 pick AND a top 10 pick, so no.
west coast hold all the power in these negotiations
pick 4 + 11 is as close as we'r gonna get, pick 22 for Seaby is a pretty good deal so that evens out the pick 11.People need to remember what happened last year with Judd. Pick 1 or no deal.....>>>>> ok we'll take pick 3.
And please don't menetion Kerr is under contract, we sure don't want to negotiate a Kerr trade next year with a compromised draft, it's now or never.
ronnie wearmouth
Senior List
Why would you trade pick 11 it just doesnt make sense, pick 11 will get you a very talented kid.
People need to remember what happened last year with Judd. Pick 1 or no deal.....>>>>> ok we'll take pick 3.
And please don't menetion Kerr is under contract, we sure don't want to negotiate a Kerr trade next year with a compromised draft, it's now or never.
that's like saying "here's my point but dont point out why it's wrong".
yes, last year we demanded pick 1 and settled for pick 3 for judd. and yes, he was out of contract so we had less bargaining power than we do this year as kerr is contracted.
less than a top 5 and top 10 pick for kerr (as has been stated) and our members are entitled to feel outraged.
it simply wont happen, when will it sink in for you idiots?
sydney eagle
Norm Smith Medallist
The Judd situation was unusual in that Carlton (the team which he nominated as his "preferred destination") had pick 2 in the PSD so there was a danger of Judd walking for nothing to them if the Eagles didn't do the deal that they did. Next season, unless Kerr's "preferred destination" is the Gold Coast, that situation will not arise. If he wants to go to a Melbourne club the Eagles will still be able to demand a fair trade for him.
Similar threads
