The point being he would have been someone who sometimes struggled to find the ball playing in a dysfunctional team that struggled to win the ball. Would have been a polarising player too, I imagine
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 10
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round 9 Winner: philreich
List Mgmt. Welcome Campbell Chesser (Pick 14, 2021 National Draft)
- Thread starter Truckosaurus
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I'm not sure we can put together a best 22 at the moment with AFL level players even if everyone is fully fit....Is CC definitely our new whipping boy now?
Anyway, I think it is fair to ask whether he would be in our first 22 if we had a fully fit line-up. I think it is also fair to say he hasn't yet had a breakout game that made the competition take notice. And - logically - fair to debate that given the body of evidence so far, whether this could be a bust especially given at the time there were plenty of other options at pick 14 we all were clamouring for and are now showing signs at their respective clubs.
I hope he shuts us all up with a BOG next weekend against Melbourne - but I'm not holding my breath.
Chesser gets way too much negative attention on this board. He’s a 20yr old kid who is finding his way in an all time horrible WCE team. It’s not easy.
It’s impossible to hit on every draft pick and there’s every chance that he goes the way of Brander, but personally I’m pleased to see the match committee back him in and help develop his game.
He’s also being Reid’s best mate and helping him settle in WA.
Basically jubilant Campbell is the new jubilant Masto etc etc
It’s impossible to hit on every draft pick and there’s every chance that he goes the way of Brander, but personally I’m pleased to see the match committee back him in and help develop his game.
He’s also being Reid’s best mate and helping him settle in WA.
Basically jubilant Campbell is the new jubilant Masto etc etc
Let the haters hate.
Hes playing a tough role and has played 20 odd games. He was always gonna be a slow burn, some posters on here have zero patience.
And for those saying shep wasnt similiar, thats bs, because he was copping similiar abuse on here for years.
Hes playing a tough role and has played 20 odd games. He was always gonna be a slow burn, some posters on here have zero patience.
And for those saying shep wasnt similiar, thats bs, because he was copping similiar abuse on here for years.
What on earth are those ranking points haha. AFL player ratings are posted on Wheelo. Pretty easy to find once you know where.
I mean the stats disagree with you. AFL player ratings has Chesser ahead of both.
Dom sheed pocket
Club Legend
- Aug 15, 2023
- 1,060
- 2,142
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Sep 21, 2004
- 37,551
- 26,630
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Norwood & Liverpool.
IIRC Shep copped it coz he was picked over Jetta who at the time looked like a gun.
But we got him anyway and weirdly he played in a flag and not Shep despite doing all the heavy lifting for years
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
But we got him anyway and weirdly he played in a flag and not Shep despite doing all the heavy lifting for years
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
Dom sheed pocket
Club Legend
- Aug 15, 2023
- 1,060
- 2,142
- AFL Club
- West Coast
A good question on wing role from Keys
Simmo talks about the specifics of wing role and how it is structurally important and can lead to low possession count.
Talks very specifically about the game being “straighter” ie teams not switching as much and wings running up and back for not much reward.
Simmo also spoke about this last week in his presser btw as it related to chesser.
6:08
Simmo talks about the specifics of wing role and how it is structurally important and can lead to low possession count.
Talks very specifically about the game being “straighter” ie teams not switching as much and wings running up and back for not much reward.
Simmo also spoke about this last week in his presser btw as it related to chesser.
6:08
Dom sheed pocket
Club Legend
- Aug 15, 2023
- 1,060
- 2,142
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Both AFL.com and wheelo use the same Champion Data AFL player rating system. Both platforms support what i have said here over and over again. Chesser is actually performing better than both Johnson and Hobbs.
Here’s screen shots from AfL.com for 2024 season from 3 players in question.
Chesser 6.9
Johnson 5.1
Hobbs 5.2
Once he hits thats 50+ games i can see him really blossoming.
There are some really odd and harsh takes in here.
There are some really odd and harsh takes in here.
Dom sheed pocket
Club Legend
- Aug 15, 2023
- 1,060
- 2,142
- AFL Club
- West Coast
If he can stay fit and healthy I reckon he will take a big step forward in the second half of this year.
He’s starting to show a few signs of a player who could break out.
Simmo's response to an avid fan's question on the Schodown yesterday(thanks Keys) explains the low possession count for wingers in the side.
Basically said it's a league-wide trend at the moment, where the wings will run up and down up to 15kms a game, yet only get 10-14 possessions, as most teams are going far more direct than previous years. Reckons the days of high-possession wingers are dead for the time being.
Basically said it's a league-wide trend at the moment, where the wings will run up and down up to 15kms a game, yet only get 10-14 possessions, as most teams are going far more direct than previous years. Reckons the days of high-possession wingers are dead for the time being.
MrsBlueSky
Senior List
- Apr 5, 2024
- 187
- 204
- AFL Club
- Tasmania
Harley Reid also has a below average disposals and below average kicks per game - are the people who want Chesser out of the side also wanting to get rid of Reid.
I did say that our new gameplan won't be the same for wingers, it would be nice if they can get them involved a bit more in transition.
I personally wouldn't have Hunt as a winger because I feel we're better off with him getting the ball more and taking the game on.
I think Chesser can elevate himself in the f50 if he can generate shots for himself pushing forward he can really impact the game.
He did just that on the weekend, although he missed.
I do recall Brad Hill having a massive purple patch with the Saints this year (could still be in it), but I am unsure what their style of play is to compare the two teams.
I personally wouldn't have Hunt as a winger because I feel we're better off with him getting the ball more and taking the game on.
I think Chesser can elevate himself in the f50 if he can generate shots for himself pushing forward he can really impact the game.
He did just that on the weekend, although he missed.
I do recall Brad Hill having a massive purple patch with the Saints this year (could still be in it), but I am unsure what their style of play is to compare the two teams.
Trade bait at this stage of his career.
Has over 300 games experience from under 12's onwards so he should be getting 30+2 as a minimum.
MrsBlueSky
Senior List
- Apr 5, 2024
- 187
- 204
- AFL Club
- Tasmania
People say the modern game of footy has changed a lot.
I say it hasn't.
If I was a coach at WCE I'd tell the boys to get it out of centre and take the shortest route to the goals.
Reid, Hall, Yeo and Hunt would be as good at getting it out of the centre quickly as any midfield.
Seeing Hunt on a wing doing nothing, Reid in the goal square twiddling his thumbs and Dom Sheed and Gaff trying to get a touch in the centre is not worth watching.
Meanwhile all the WCE Eagles coaches are happy for players like Gov to kick the ball out from goal into a pocket. A long kick to out of bounds on the wing. If lucky they get another kick forward to Waterman who takes a mark from 55m out and doesn't even think about turning around to see if someone's alone closer to the goal.
That's been happening for three years and it's woeful to say the least.
Hunt could still be on a wing because you can't have 12 players in the centre bouncdown, but he can help with that transition, as you say wce4premiership
But they don't. Both wingers just stand there waiting to see which way the ball will go.
I know which way it's going to go out of the centre unless the Eagles change their gameplan - straight to the opposition's goal!
ToastieBoy18
Senior List
- Dec 5, 2022
- 165
- 566
- AFL Club
- West Coast
I am far worse off as a person for reading this.
What I’d really like to know though, is what Jezbunchonumbers thinks about Chesser.
Have they always had it on afl website? I swear it wasn’t for awhile so switched to wheelo. Good to know they aren’t hiding the data.Both AFL.com and wheelo use the same Champion Data AFL player rating system. Both platforms support what i have said here over and over again. Chesser is actually performing better than both Johnson and Hobbs.
Here’s screen shots from AfL.com for 2024 season from 3 players in question.
Chesser 6.9
Johnson 5.1
Hobbs 5.2
Yeah so when you sort it like that all you are doing is taking all their scores from their last 40 games added up. Not corrected for how many games played. So Chesser has played less than Hobbs so has way lower score. On average is higher this season tho.
Dom sheed pocket
Club Legend
- Aug 15, 2023
- 1,060
- 2,142
- AFL Club
- West Coast
It’s honestly so hard to find. It seems be appear on the desktop version, but not the app and it is very hard to find from afl homepage.
Best way to get it is to go to a players profile, click full stats then “key stats” and “season 2024”.
Similar threads
