Universal Love Welcome to Freo- Josh Treacy

Remove this Banner Ad

I think comparisons miss the point. They're complimentary forwards. Treacy's major point of difference is, for a crash and bash CHF, he has masses of finesse and is highly accurate. Amiss will get stronger, and is already one of the better leading forwards in the game. His field game is also hugely underrated - he's got elite agility, a great mark and neat field kick. This gives us one of the most fluid forward pairings in the league (currently). Give them a couple of years and forget about salivating over Curnow/McKay, these guys potentially are a generational #1/#2 punch.

On SM-G988U1 using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Mr Cheese said:
I think comparisons miss the point. They're complimentary forwards. Treacy's major point of difference is, for a crash and bash CHF, he has masses of finesse and is highly accurate. Amiss will get stronger, and is already one of the better leading forwards in the game. His field game is also hugely underrated - he's got elite agility, a great mark and neat field kick. This gives us one of the most fluid forward pairings in the league (currently). Give them a couple of years and forget about salivating over Curnow/McKay, these guys potentially are a generational #1/#2 punch.

On SM-G988U1 using BigFooty.com mobile app
Click to expand...
I've said for ages that I think Amiss is set to join the podium with Pav and Fyfe, the fact that Treacy might be in that race is frankly outrageous given our history.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Purpletown said:
No, I didn't walk around Cohuna in my Freo gear, it was a balmy 10°c with a stiff breeze 🥶 Just quickly out of the ute for a snap and back into the heated cab. So soft 😢
Click to expand...
Should have called in for a cuppa
 
Mr Cheese said:
I think comparisons miss the point. They're complimentary forwards. Treacy's major point of difference is, for a crash and bash CHF, he has masses of finesse and is highly accurate. Amiss will get stronger, and is already one of the better leading forwards in the game. His field game is also hugely underrated - he's got elite agility, a great mark and neat field kick. This gives us one of the most fluid forward pairings in the league (currently). Give them a couple of years and forget about salivating over Curnow/McKay, these guys potentially are a generational #1/#2 punch.

On SM-G988U1 using BigFooty.com mobile app
Click to expand...
You're not often wrong cheesy , but you're right on about this!
TREAMISS!
YOKAI!
 
Did a little research, my muchachos. And yes 2020 hindsight and all that but stilllllllll....

Players taken in the 2021 draft process ahead of our mate Cyclone:

2021 national draft
1 Jamarra Ugle-Hagan, Western Bulldogs
2 Riley Thilthorpe, Adelaide
3 Will Phillips, North Melbourne
4 Logan McDonald, Sydney
5 Braeden Campbell, Sydney
6 Denver Grainger-Barras, Hawthorn
7 Elijah Hollands, Gold Coast
8 Nik Cox, Essendon
9 Archie Perkins, Essendon
10 Zach Reid, Essendon
11 Luke Pedlar, Adelaide
12 Tanner Bruhn, GWS
13 Tom Powell, North Melbourne
14 Heath Chapman, Fremantle
15 Conor Stone, GWS
16 Lachie Jones, Port
17 Oliver Henry, Collingwood
18 Ryan Angwin, GWS
19 Finlay Macrae, Collingwood
20 Max Holmes, Geelong
21 Jake Bowey, Melbourne
22 Bailey Laurie, Melbourne
23 Reef McInnes, Collingwood
24 Blake Coleman, Brisbane
25 Brayden Cook, Adelaide
26 Matthew McLeod-Allison, St Kilda
27 Nathan O'Driscoll, Fremantle
28 Sam Berry, Adelaide
29 Seamus Mitchell, Hawthorn
30 Caleb Poulter, Collingwood
31 Liam McMahon, Collingwood
32 Errol Gulden, Sydney
33 Shannon Neale, Geelong
34 Fraser Rosman, Melbourne
35 Connor Downie, Hawthorn
36 Charlie Lazzaro, North Melbourne
37 Corey Durdin, Carlton
38 James Rowe, Adelaide
39 Josh Eyre, Essendon
40 Samson Ryan, Richmond
41 Jack Carroll, Carlton
42 Phoenix Spicer, North Melbourne
43 Harry Sharp, Brisbane
44 Beau McCreery, Collingwood
45 Tom Highmore, St Kilda
46 Tyler Brockman, Hawthorn
47 Nick Stevens, Geelong
48 Henry Smith, Brisbane
49 Ollie Lord, Port
50 Brandon Walker, Fremantle
51 Maurice Rioli Jr, Richmond
52 Luke Edwards, West Coast
53 Cody Brand, Essendon
54 Joel Western, Fremantle
55 Dominic Bedendo, Western Bulldogs
56 Eddie Ford, North Melbourne
57 Isiah Winder, West Coast
58 Cameron Fleeton, GWS
59 Jacob Wehr, GWS

2021 pre rookie draft rookie elevations
Tom Fullarton, Brisbane
Michael Gibbons, Carlton
Jack Madgen, Collingwood
Brody Mihocek, Collingwood
Connor Budarick, Gold Coast
Nick Holman, Gold Coast
Malcolm Rosas, Gold Coast
Jack Buckley, Greater Western Sydney
Changkuoth Jiath, Hawthorn
Jay Lockhart, Melbourne
Liam Baker, Richmond
Mabior Chol, Richmond
Joel Amartey, Sydney
Harry Edwards, West Coast

2021 pre season draft
Jackson Hately, GWS

2021 rookie draft
Bryce Gibbs, Adelaide (Gibbs retired in 2020 but had to be drafted and retained as an inactive player on Adelaide's Rookie List due to Adelaide's obligations under his contract settlement)
Patrick Walker, North Melbourne
Malachy Carruthers, Sydney
Jack Saunders, Hawthorn
Jacob Townsend, Gold Coast
Martin Gleeson, Essendon

So all 18 clubs selected a grand total of 80 different players (79 if one excludes the Bryce Gibbs re-rookie pick) before we nabbed Cyclone. And he's not yet 22...

BONUS POINTS - anyone want to guess at how many of the 80 players taken ahead of Josh are already out of AFL?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

BeinPurplenGreen said:
Did a little research, my muchachos. And yes 2020 hindsight and all that but stilllllllll....

Players taken in the 2021 draft process ahead of our mate Cyclone:

2021 national draft
1 Jamarra Ugle-Hagan, Western Bulldogs
2 Riley Thilthorpe, Adelaide
3 Will Phillips, North Melbourne
4 Logan McDonald, Sydney
5 Braeden Campbell, Sydney
6 Denver Grainger-Barras, Hawthorn
7 Elijah Hollands, Gold Coast
8 Nik Cox, Essendon
9 Archie Perkins, Essendon
10 Zach Reid, Essendon
11 Luke Pedlar, Adelaide
12 Tanner Bruhn, GWS
13 Tom Powell, North Melbourne
14 Heath Chapman, Fremantle
15 Conor Stone, GWS
16 Lachie Jones, Port
17 Oliver Henry, Collingwood
18 Ryan Angwin, GWS
19 Finlay Macrae, Collingwood
20 Max Holmes, Geelong
21 Jake Bowey, Melbourne
22 Bailey Laurie, Melbourne
23 Reef McInnes, Collingwood
24 Blake Coleman, Brisbane
25 Brayden Cook, Adelaide
26 Matthew McLeod-Allison, St Kilda
27 Nathan O'Driscoll, Fremantle
28 Sam Berry, Adelaide
29 Seamus Mitchell, Hawthorn
30 Caleb Poulter, Collingwood
31 Liam McMahon, Collingwood
32 Errol Gulden, Sydney
33 Shannon Neale, Geelong
34 Fraser Rosman, Melbourne
35 Connor Downie, Hawthorn
36 Charlie Lazzaro, North Melbourne
37 Corey Durdin, Carlton
38 James Rowe, Adelaide
39 Josh Eyre, Essendon
40 Samson Ryan, Richmond
41 Jack Carroll, Carlton
42 Phoenix Spicer, North Melbourne
43 Harry Sharp, Brisbane
44 Beau McCreery, Collingwood
45 Tom Highmore, St Kilda
46 Tyler Brockman, Hawthorn
47 Nick Stevens, Geelong
48 Henry Smith, Brisbane
49 Ollie Lord, Port
50 Brandon Walker, Fremantle
51 Maurice Rioli Jr, Richmond
52 Luke Edwards, West Coast
53 Cody Brand, Essendon
54 Joel Western, Fremantle
55 Dominic Bedendo, Western Bulldogs
56 Eddie Ford, North Melbourne
57 Isiah Winder, West Coast
58 Cameron Fleeton, GWS
59 Jacob Wehr, GWS

2021 pre rookie draft rookie elevations
Tom Fullarton, Brisbane
Michael Gibbons, Carlton
Jack Madgen, Collingwood
Brody Mihocek, Collingwood
Connor Budarick, Gold Coast
Nick Holman, Gold Coast
Malcolm Rosas, Gold Coast
Jack Buckley, Greater Western Sydney
Changkuoth Jiath, Hawthorn
Jay Lockhart, Melbourne
Liam Baker, Richmond
Mabior Chol, Richmond
Joel Amartey, Sydney
Harry Edwards, West Coast

2021 pre season draft
Jackson Hately, GWS

2021 rookie draft
Bryce Gibbs, Adelaide (Gibbs retired in 2020 but had to be drafted and retained as an inactive player on Adelaide's Rookie List due to Adelaide's obligations under his contract settlement)
Patrick Walker, North Melbourne
Malachy Carruthers, Sydney
Jack Saunders, Hawthorn
Jacob Townsend, Gold Coast
Martin Gleeson, Essendon

So all 18 clubs selected a grand total of 80 different players (79 if one excludes the Bryce Gibbs re-rookie pick) before we nabbed Cyclone. And he's not yet 22...

BONUS POINTS - anyone want to guess at how many of the 80 players taken ahead of Josh are already out of AFL?
Click to expand...
11?
 
Just compared him to all players ahead of him in Coleman ladder

He must be coming into contention for all Australian squad

He is such a well rounded forward

Pressure acts, tackles, rucks when needed, quality disposal and accurate in front of goals from anywhere
 
332docker said:
Just compared him to all players ahead of him in Coleman ladder

He must be coming into contention for all Australian squad

He is such a well rounded forward

Pressure acts, tackles, rucks when needed, quality disposal and accurate in front of goals from anywhere
Click to expand...

Goals and assists round 19:

1. Charlie Curnow 67 (53/14)
2. Jesse Hogan 59 (49/10)
3. Toby Greene 53 (30/23)
4. Josh Treacy 51 (39/12)/Jeremy Cameron (37/14)
6. Harry McKay 50 (44/6)
7. Joe Daniher 49 (37/12)/Kyle Langford (37/12)
9. Tyson Stengle 48 (34/14)
10. Ben King 47 (45/2)/Dylan Moore (27/20)

It'll be hard to go past Curnow and Hogan for AA. But I think he's next in line and should be in the 40 man squad as long as he finishes the season well.
 
Fat Nyfe said:
Goals and assists round 19:

1. Charlie Curnow 67 (53/14)
2. Jesse Hogan 59 (49/10)
3. Toby Greene 53 (30/23)
4. Josh Treacy 51 (39/12)/Jeremy Cameron (37/14)
6. Harry McKay 50 (44/6)
7. Joe Daniher 49 (37/12)/Kyle Langford (37/12)
9. Tyson Stengle 48 (34/14)
10. Ben King 47 (45/2)/Dylan Moore (27/20)

It'll be hard to go past Curnow and Hogan for AA. But I think he's next in line and should be in the 40 man squad as long as he finishes the season well.
Click to expand...
I think Treacy has more score assists than 12..
 
malpaso said:
I think Treacy has more score assists than 12..
Click to expand...

Score assists yes but these are goal assist stats

2024 AFL League Total Goal Assists Leaders

2024 AFL League Total Goal Assists Leaders.
www.footywire.com

edit: 107 score involvements for Treacy, ranked 30th. 4th at the club behind Brayshaw (highest ranked for us at 6th in the AFL), Young and Serong.

2024 AFL League Total Score Involvements Leaders

2024 AFL League Total Score Involvements Leaders.
www.footywire.com
 
Last edited:
Mr Cheese said:
I think comparisons miss the point. They're complimentary forwards. Treacy's major point of difference is, for a crash and bash CHF, he has masses of finesse and is highly accurate. Amiss will get stronger, and is already one of the better leading forwards in the game. His field game is also hugely underrated - he's got elite agility, a great mark and neat field kick. This gives us one of the most fluid forward pairings in the league (currently). Give them a couple of years and forget about salivating over Curnow/McKay, these guys potentially are a generational #1/#2 punch.

On SM-G988U1 using BigFooty.com mobile app
Click to expand...

Don’t forget the balance between having a left and right footed key forward. Sturt, Walters, Banfield as lefties makes defending us a full inside 50m arc. We aren’t full of right footers who you can hem to the right sided boundary.

Mind you, you can hem Jackson to the pocket, but he’ll banana it straight though.
 
332docker said:
Treacy would have to be only player to have kicked a goal in every game this year. His accuracy is so impressive
Click to expand...


For Freo, yes.

League wise, nope.

Hogan and Curnow haven't missed either.
 

Universal Love Welcome to Freo- Josh Treacy

Similar threads

Tonga Bob
Toast Welcome to Freo Jeremy Sharp - SSP Selection 2023
15 16 17 18 19
Replies
456
Views
31K
Wray27
Wray27
Tonga Bob
Toast Welcome To Freo Jack Delean (pick 60 2023 AFL Draft)
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
125
Views
13K
DragoDelph
DragoDelph
Tonga Bob
Toast Welcome To Freo Ollie Murphy (pick 41 2023 AFL Draft)
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
129
Views
9K
ubiquitous226
ubiquitous226
Tonga Bob
Toast Welcome To Freo Cooper Simpson (pick 35 2023 AFL Draft)
19 20 21 22 23
Replies
565
Views
41K
FreoGirl
FreoGirl
Snuffaluphagus
Toast Welcome to Freo Odin Jones (Pick 5 in 2023 Rookie Draft)
2 3 4
Replies
82
Views
9K
Lach72
Lach72
C
Freo’s record vs top 8 teams this season
2
Replies
36
Views
975
Joao
J
C
Freo in close games
Replies
12
Views
569
arsesmart
arsesmart

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top