List Mgmt. Welcome to Geelong Nakia Cockatoo - National Draft selection no. 10

Remove this Banner Ad

Did we really need pick 10 for him?

Raised this a few hours ago... Tend to agree... not sure we needed to lose 12 picks late on for this...

Go Catters
 

Log in to remove this ad.

It's just completely lacking in logic to select a injury prone midfielder over a KPP when we are going to be very very thin in the KPD area in the next two to three years.

Even more so to give up a 2nd round pick to do so when he would have been there at our original pick.

The off season has seemed to be very reactionary instead of being a well thought out process.

He had a stress fracture in his foot in one season and that means that he is "injury prone".

That is a gross exaggeration of of Nakia Cockatoo's career.
 
The only query I have: doesn't all the mail suggest that he would have still been there at #14?
All the mail said we wouldn't be picking him until suddenly it was saying we would pick him. Draw your own conclusion on the value of 'mail'.
 
Re the pick 10 thing - Cockatoo may not have been the target for 10. Maybe it was De Goey or Marchbank or Wright? Once they're gone you just have to go with the next on your list.

IWWT.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Re the pick 10 thing - Cockatoo may not have been the target for 10. Maybe it was De Goey or Marchbank or Wright? Once they're gone you just have to go with the next on your list.

IWWT.

You have to have the ammo first to try and get your outright #1. Maybe Cocky was it - who knows - but if he was up there and those above him had gone already.. then he was it...

GO Catters
 
It's just completely lacking in logic to select a injury prone midfielder over a KPP when we are going to be very very thin in the KPD area in the next two to three years.

Even more so to give up a 2nd round pick to do so when he would have been there at our original pick.

The off season has seemed to be very reactionary instead of being a well thought out process.
This season has shown nothing other than this board posseses negative, entitled supporters. I'd even go as far as saying half weren't even members before 07.

I'm appalled at some of the shit sprouted on this board this year...absolutely appalled.
 
Raised this a few hours ago... Tend to agree... not sure we needed to lose 12 picks late on for this...

Go Catters
Get around him Daz. Heard him linked to west coast at one point. If Cockatoo was their man then I think moving 12 places down with our 2nd pick in an even draft to make sure we get him is a OK move.
 
Looks very balanced, quick, confident and skilful. Could be a match-winning player in years to come.

Looks pretty good in the air, too, which is a great bonus for that type of player.

Perfect winger?
 
All the mail said we wouldn't be picking him until suddenly it was saying we would pick him. Draw your own conclusion on the value of 'mail'.

Just seems to me that the club had to have moved up in the order with a specific player in mind. And going by what was written in the phantom drafts (specifically that West Coast - as a '...much longer shot...' at #11 was the only team that was linked to Cockatoo by Quayle before pick #15), I'm surprised that player was Cockatoo.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. Welcome to Geelong Nakia Cockatoo - National Draft selection no. 10

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top