Deals done and dusted, good stuff , now....about Browny......
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Everyone here last year was screaming when we only got 28 for Ebert.Think its a bit overs, around 25 a fair price
But when you consider all the compensation picks that might occur in the first round 17 could become pick 20 which is closer to a win/win price
Wrong poster. You're after Phil not Phill.Hello Phil, you like my sig?
You mustn't of seen the thread on the Draft and Trading board.Are you going to throw the words of some Collingwood posters back at all Collingwood posters?
It was Ebert and 45 for 28 and 49Everyone here last year was screaming when we only got 28 for Ebert.
Wellingham is a significant improvement on Ebert
I feel like each time an opposition player wants to come home, we pay at least a fair price, if not over, while other clubs get players who want to leave the eagles/nominate their club, for a bargain ...
Truth is out of Mckinley, Seaby, Staker, Stevens, Spangher, Morrison & White, Haynes, McDougall...etc etc not one of them cost us a premiership or gave the club they went to one. So all in all the lower placed players have done nothing to damage our list over the years.
Conveniently left out Mitch Morton?
Is he though?Everyone here last year was screaming when we only got 28 for Ebert.
Wellingham is a significant improvement on Ebert
Yep, Ebert really lifted Port to lofty heights.Is he though?
If wellingham's impact for us is as good as Ebert has been for port then I will be very happy with the trade
I would have put Wellinghams value fairly similar to Eberts
e.g around 20-25
Yep, Ebert really lifted Port to lofty heights.
At worse you get a good player and Wellingham has played a few A+ games so there is hope for you to come away like bandits. Pick 17 is deep enough in the draft crap shoot to easily yield a dud. Your premiership time is now and I think you traded well, Collingwood would be happy to reverse the trade if Wellingham wanted to stay.
His parents' names are Jarrod and Sharon - That's actually where the name comes from.I must admit, I vomit in my mouth a bit every time I hear the name Sharod. It's like his parents wanted to honour their best friends Jarad and Sharon.
Oh god.His parents' names are Jarrod and Sharon - That's actually where the name comes from.
His parents' names are Jarrod and Sharon - That's actually where the name comes from.
His parents' names are Jarrod and Sharon - That's actually where the name comes from.
His parents' names are Jarrod and Sharon - That's actually where the name comes from.
Thanks for the well thought-out replyI trust the club as always.
Gehrig left which got us Kerr
Judd left which got us Kennedy and Masten
Matera left which got us.... oh wait a minute
Truth is out of Mckinley, Seaby, Staker, Stevens, Spangher, Morrison, White, Haynes, McDougall...etc etc not one of them cost us a premiership or gave the club they went to one. So all in all the lower placed players have done nothing to damage our list over the years.
As for the bigger players to leave, i think they have turned out rather well imo.
I'd prefer to be a club that is easy to deal with as it means clubs don't hesitate to sit down with us and have a chat. We make calculated decisions, just like we did with Sharrod.
Does he offer us something we say we are after...yes
Does he add depth instantly to a position we got flogged in last year.....yes
Does pick 18 offer us something that will instantly improve our list and as a result help our tilt towards another premiership.....no
Do we have anything else to offer Collingwood that we are prepared to lose if we think we are paying slight overs.....no
Seems like a no brainer to me.
The only time we have been majorly screwed was with Port. They had the pre season pressure and we had no choice, yet we got McInnes who i think will be a very good player for us so like the Judd deal give it a few years and we shall see who got the better end of the stick.
Also what goes around, comes around. If we have a reputation of being fair and looking after players this will only help us in the new era of free agency.
Cheers.
I don't mean to get off topic, but Carlton, Gold Coast, Richmond and Melbourne? That's a lot of teams.