Re: Western Region Football League team
I would have to say from the outset that you make your own luck when playing footy, so to blame umpiring solely for our loss is a little lame. The topic of the "standard of umpiring" has been done and dusted many times. We will always interupt decisions differenty depending on where we sit. This has and always will be a debatable topic. There is no doubt the level of umpring could and should be improved but in saying that there is improvment in all of us isn't there? I dont think there are many out there that are firing on all cyclinders. Whilst I am sure there are measures put into place in relation to improving the above, there can also be no doubt that no matter how good or bad one's form is, whether it be a player, coach or even an umpire no one is bigger than the game. Unfortunatly one of the blokes in white and some players continue to think the oppisite. Whislt this is the case contraversy will always follow.
All the talk of the Umpires at the Spotty Colts Game is off the mark. In the reserves the one umpire who knew what he was doing took no crap from the colts players who as usual were undisciplined. They led at quarter time 5.5 to 0.2 and should have gone on and won the game. Both Brannan and Winters were below par and needed the game. In the Seniors Spotty had 2 players off for blood rule in the first 10 minutes from behind the play incidents perpetrated by Numbers 8 and 22 (you work out who they are). As usual 18 was undisciplined carrying on a conversation with the crowd. He also kicked a Spotty player behind the play. The umpires, as usual were scared. They paid numerous free kick to Spotty down the ground because of PMC's late head high tackles. No Reports but they obviously saw it because they paid the free. The tribunal is weak as piss so maybe the umpires have lost faith and don't bother any more. The only report was Number 22 Spotty for trying to stop 28 PMC stomping on his leg whilst he was on the ground. I believe that he took the week offerrred as you can't trust the tribunal to get it right.
As Rock says, the umpires did not cost them the game it was the lack of discipline displayed by some of his team mates, much so that although Rock participates in a bit of push and shove even he hung his head seeing and listening to his own players.
I would have to say from the outset that you make your own luck when playing footy, so to blame umpiring solely for our loss is a little lame. The topic of the "standard of umpiring" has been done and dusted many times. We will always interupt decisions differenty depending on where we sit. This has and always will be a debatable topic. There is no doubt the level of umpring could and should be improved but in saying that there is improvment in all of us isn't there? I dont think there are many out there that are firing on all cyclinders. Whilst I am sure there are measures put into place in relation to improving the above, there can also be no doubt that no matter how good or bad one's form is, whether it be a player, coach or even an umpire no one is bigger than the game. Unfortunatly one of the blokes in white and some players continue to think the oppisite. Whislt this is the case contraversy will always follow.