whats bryce gibbs worth?

[PepperFace]

Looking on the Carlton board and about 50% want to get rid of Gibbs. Wanting to know what people think hes worth on the open market. Blues fans seem to think 1st round pick but my guess would be something between 20-30.

 

[SizeMatters]

1st round pick.

 

[Ashton Agar]

Probably a pick between 15-30 I'd say.

 

[askdotcom]

easily first round pick, probably about 8-14

 

[Sprout]

Late first round.

 

[DAWESOME!!]

There would be a club or two that would pay a late first rounder for him. I wouldn't want Collingwood to do so however.

 

[Banker]

Whats his attitude like? Can he rise to match expectations of playing a full game?

 

[Allikat]

A packet of cheese twisties.


He's really not that good, but some clubs will probably be stupid enough to throw a late first/2nd rounder for him because they're desperate. The rest of the clubs probably wouldn't touch him

 

[PepperFace]

He would be handy in a team that wants to add midfield depth. But not a match winner. Id be disappointed if we gave higher than pick 25 for him

 

[STFU Donnie]

I'll give you a packet of Pringles. Mind you, some are missing. Still a good trade.

 

[Stifler's mom]

Def worth a late 1st rounder, and only top 6 clubs would want him logically anyway.

 

[Testekill]

Late first rounder.

 

[dragonsblues]

Considering that a Club was prepared to pay $700k+ for Frawley (which he isn't worth) I'd say a first round draft pick and a big salary.

Might thrive in a new environment, or still might be soft. Who know's.

 

[Bardo State]

Mid first round pick. Around 7-12.

 

[gillo94]

Beams & 4th rd was worth 5, 25 & Crisp

Gibbs I think 1st Rd (b/w 8-13) pick and mid-late second round pick. But I'd be more in favour of keeping than trading

 

[nobbyiscool]

Beams & 4th rd was worth 5, 25 & Crisp

Gibbs I think 1st Rd (b/w 8-13) pick and mid-late second round pick. But I'd be more in favour of keeping than trading

I can only imagine you didnt watch last night?

I wouldn't give a first rounder. Someone might, but I'd be disappointed if it were my team. Pea-hearted waste of talent. Time to see if Adelaide can get something out of him.

 

[Kram]

Beams & 4th rd was worth 5, 25 & Crisp

Gibbs I think 1st Rd (b/w 8-13) pick and mid-late second round pick. But I'd be more in favour of keeping than trading

lol.

 

[Kram]

I can only imagine you didnt watch last night?

I wouldn't give a first rounder. Someone might, but I'd be disappointed if it were my team. Pea-hearted waste of talent. Time to see if Adelaide can get something out of him.

Well West Coast did give up a first rounder for Sharon Wellingham..

 

[nobbyiscool]

Well West Coast did give up a first rounder for Sharon Wellingham..

You and I could play this game for a while though... Remember Trent Croad?

In any case, we're heaping shit on Gibbs atm

 

[JA27]

put him on the half back flank in a top 4-6 team and we would be a star.

worth pick 5-10 imo.

 

[BobHawk]

put him on the half back flank in a top 4-6 team and we would be a star.

worth pick 5-10 imo.

Agree. he would kill it playing the sweeper role in a good team. I don't reckon Carlton would trade him though.

 

[gillo94]

I can only imagine you didnt watch last night?

I wouldn't give a first rounder. Someone might, but I'd be disappointed if it were my team. Pea-hearted waste of talent. Time to see if Adelaide can get something out of him.

I'm being dead serious I was actually thinking of this scenario, similar to what Eagles and Pies did in 2013

* Crows get pick 10 in the draft, 1st rd for example and Dangerfield leaves. Crows get pick 11 compensation

* Crows would have roughly pick 35 in the second round

Adelaide, Trade pick 11 & 35 for Gibbs, still have pick 10 in the draft. Crows winners; while Blues end up with example
Picks 5 & 11 in first rd & two 2nd rd picks

 

[JA27]

Agree. he would kill it playing the sweeper role in a good team. I don't reckon Carlton would trade him though.

I hope they don't trade him, he could have gone anywhere last year and chose to stay loyal to the club.

 

[slashin_velvet]

I'm being dead serious I was actually thinking of this scenario, similar to what Eagles and Pies did in 2013

* Crows get pick 10 in the draft, 1st rd for example and Dangerfield leaves. Crows get pick 11 compensation

* Crows would have roughly pick 35 in the second round

Adelaide, Trade pick 11 & 35 for Gibbs, still have pick 10 in the draft. Crows winners; while Blues end up with example
Picks 5 & 11 in first rd & two 2nd rd picks

So they effectively trade Danger + their second for Gibbs?

 

[gillo94]

I hope they don't trade him, he could have gone anywhere last year and chose to stay loyal to the club.

Blues won't trade him, I'd hate for Bryce to leave. Had a bad night but skilful player