Who are the top 10 midfielders in the league?

Remove this Banner Ad

Coaches award had Bont number 1. Brownlow vote for Bont was split with Macrae and Dunkley.

59 Brownlow votes between them. I would take the coaches vote over the Brownlow which is an umpire fan boi award.
 
wayniac said:
Coaches award had Bont number 1. Brownlow vote for Bont was split with Macrae and Dunkley.

59 Brownlow votes between them. I would take the coaches vote over the Brownlow which is an umpire fan boi award.
Click to expand...
Coaches have demonstrated their own biases in their voting as well. It's just whose biases you prefer.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
 

Log in to remove this ad.

eaglespremiers said:
Coaches have demonstrated their own biases in their voting as well. It's just whose biases you prefer.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Bont scored 22 Brownlow votes and the coaches award. I prefer no bias. Next?
 
wayniac said:
Bont scored 22 Brownlow votes and the coaches award. I prefer no bias. Next?
Click to expand...

You know where Fyfe finished in those awards right. There was also a little two game buffer he gave Bontempelli and also when he gave up an almost certain 10 votes in R3 when he decided to get himself knocked out halfway through the 3rd quarter.

And just because there were others at the Dogs score well, it doesn't mean they "stole" votes from Bontempelli. Acting as if he was certain to win the vote/s if his teammate didn't is clutching...
 
catscollector said:
People underrate Josh Kelly in my opinion.
A brilliant footballer. Very similar to Simon Black.
Can play around stoppages and instantly give you plenty of clearances or play as the designated ball carrier.
He'll dominate on Saturday.

Mitchell I tend to feel is more like a Patrick Cripps. Absolute beast around the contests. Literally unstoppable in getting the footy but not the most damaging footballer given a lack of goal prowess and disposal use.
Click to expand...

After his GF performance I have pushed Josh Kelly out of my original top ten. Simply didn’t step up on the big stage. Doesn’t seem like a big game player. Can see your comparison to Blacky, but Simon played his best ever game (according to the man himself) on grand final day. Kelly has a LONG way to go if he is to be ever talked about in the same conversation as Black.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
Daniels Riches said:
After his GF performance I have pushed Josh Kelly out of my original top ten. Simply didn’t step up on the big stage. Doesn’t seem like a big game player. Can see your comparison to Blacky, but Simon played his best ever game (according to the man himself) on grand final day. Kelly has a LONG way to go if he is to be ever talked about in the same conversation as Black.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Click to expand...

How did he go in the previous two and the one following the Norm Smith?
 
Captivating said:
Before the finals, there was some good arguments as to who the best mid was.

After the finals it's easy

1. D Martin
Click to expand...

If anything it confirmed to me that he isn’t.

Spending/spent a fair bit of time up forward and was used as a link man at HFF for a lot of the finals series. Isn’t doing the full time midfield minutes that Danger/Cripps/Neale/Fyfe pump out week in week out.

Certainly a top 3 player in the competition and as it stands form has him at 1.
 
The Joker said:
You know where Fyfe finished in those awards right. There was also a little two game buffer he gave Bontempelli and also when he gave up an almost certain 10 votes in R3 when he decided to get himself knocked out halfway through the 3rd quarter.

And just because there were others at the Dogs score well, it doesn't mean they "stole" votes from Bontempelli. Acting as if he was certain to win the vote/s if his teammate didn't is clutching...
Click to expand...

I'm sure you understand that your coach has very few players to give votes to. Bont is 23. Has a premiership medal at age 20. He spends less time in the midfield than Fyfe and it's a midfelders medal. "Almoset certain 10 votes in round 3". Now that's clutching.
 
wayniac said:
I'm sure you understand that your coach has very few players to give votes to. Bont is 23. Has a premiership medal at age 20. He spends less time in the midfield than Fyfe and it's a midfelders medal. "Almoset certain 10 votes in round 3". Now that's clutching.
Click to expand...

Put it away mate
 
wayniac said:
I'm sure you understand that your coach has very few players to give votes to. Bont is 23. Has a premiership medal at age 20. He spends less time in the midfield than Fyfe and it's a midfelders medal. "Almoset certain 10 votes in round 3". Now that's clutching.
Click to expand...

Im sure you understand that he has 22 opposition players he can give them to also!

I bet you can tell me all about that round 3 game vs the saints too...
 
The Joker said:
How did he go in the previous two and the one following the Norm Smith?
Click to expand...
Not sure what you mean by the one following the Norm Smith mate?

BTW - love your avatar, seeing that little fella and his old mans reaction brought a tear to my eye. Hope he is doing well
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

The Joker said:
The one where he got 3 weeks off to start 2005!
Click to expand...

Ahh.. been a long day, thought you were referring to Kelly - my bad! 🤪

In 2001 he had the 2nd highest tackle count for the game and number 2 for pressure acts. Big impact.

In 2002 he had the 4th highest possession count in the game and kicked a goal. Big impact.

In 2003 he played the best game of his career.

In 2004 like many lions players, he had a below par game for his high standards.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
Daniels Riches said:
Ahh.. been a long day, thought you were referring to Kelly - my bad! 🤪

In 2001 he had the 2nd highest tackle count for the game and number 2 for pressure acts. Big impact.

In 2002 he had the 4th highest possession count in the game and kicked a goal. Big impact.

In 2003 he played the best game of his career.

In 2004 like many lions players, he had a below par game for his high standards.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Click to expand...


So basically, Black was sh*t in his first grand final appearance, satisfactory in his 2nd and then dominated in one after that.

lol, you idiot!
 
catscollector said:
So basically, Black was sh*t in his first grand final appearance, satisfactory in his 2nd and then dominated in one after that.

lol, you idiot!
Click to expand...

Lol he was FAR from sh*t in his first GF appearance. As I said, he had a big impact. Do yourself a favour and watch the replay. Then see who the ‘idiot’ is.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
Sweet Jesus said:
Now who?
Click to expand...

I think the top 5 is pretty set, you can change the order however you see fit. Could see any of the top 5 being rated #1 but they all have issues, e.g. Bonts goal kicking, Dustys consistency in the H&A season, Fyfes injuries etc. Then you have a bunch of midfielders from 5-15 who are all very even (e.g. Oliver, Macrae, Coniglio etc). As well as young guns who will be pushing for top 15 soon, e.g. Tarranto and McCluggage. I have omitted guys like Pendles (who had an amazing year) and Selwood as they are will be 32 in 2020.

1. Fyfe (2019 Brownlow medal)
2. Cripps (2019 AFL MVP)
3. Bontempelli (2019 AFLCA champion player)
4. Dusty
5. Dangerfield
-------------------------------------------------------
6. Tom Mitchell
7. Lachie Neale
8. Tim Kelly
9. Elliot Yeo
10. Josh Kelly
 
Last edited:

Remove this Banner Ad

Who are the top 10 midfielders in the league?

Similar threads

Robroy22
Who are your teams Top Eight players
2 3
Replies
67
Views
2K
Robroy22
Robroy22
Lingsface
Opinion My top 10- Positions-2024
2
Replies
34
Views
1K
kaiserchief13
K
Toump Ass
Who will be the best player in the league in five years from now?
2 3 4
Replies
75
Views
4K
Always Ballin
Always Ballin
outabounds
Who exactly is going to end up the best Port midfielder?
2 3
Replies
51
Views
2K
adammania9
adammania9
J
Who are the S-Tier Under-23 talents of the competition?
Replies
21
Views
820
thistimeforsure
thistimeforsure
G
  • Poll
Does Geelong have the worst midfield in the AFL?
6 7 8 9 10
Replies
243
Views
8K
Cleansweep17
Cleansweep17
Lunchtime
Top 10 Players Since 2000
7 8 9 10 11
Replies
259
Views
8K
Fadge
F

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top