Who Do I Start On The Field 2016

[Didstar]

Need 2 of

Kennedy, Tippa, McCarthy & Papley.

Thinking McCarthy & Paps..

I think Papley should definitely be chosen against brisbane and looked in good form last week. Toss up between Mccarthy and BenKen for the second one imo, WOuld go Mccarthy just.

 

[keithrichards]

Need 2 of

Kennedy, Tippa, McCarthy & Papley.

Thinking McCarthy & Paps..

I'm in the same boat and currently have Kennedy and Papley.

Would love some advice as well!

 

[Boris the Contradiction]

Dea or the Tip Rat?

Paps or McCarthy?

I'm thinking Dea and Papley. Thoughts?

 

[Sir Skid]

Dea or the Tip Rat?

Paps or McCarthy?

I'm thinking Dea and Papley. Thoughts?

Tippa and Paps imo.

Linc McCarthy, BurnKen or Menaspew on field?

 

[MightyMark]

Dea or the Tip Rat?

Paps or McCarthy?

I'm thinking Dea and Papley. Thoughts?

Tip rat and Paps for me.

 

[KenTucker]

You mean like if you're tossing up between, let's say, Rookie A and Rookie B up forward, and you have another non-playing Rookie C. Rookie A plays on Friday night, Rookies B and C on Saturday.

You could put the E on Rookie A on the bench on Friday and see how he goes.

If he does well, you make sure Rookie C is on-field instead of Rookie B before lockout for those games, ensuring that you get Rookie A's score.

If Rookie A scores poorly, you put Rookie B on field and Rookie C on the bench before their lockouts and get a second bite of the cherry with Rookie B's score.

Or do you mean something else?

Good to see people have no hesitation in helping newbies, good on ya Gutsroy!

 

[KenTucker]

Tippa and Paps imo.

Linc McCarthy, BurnKen or Menaspew on field?

Tough one, my thoughts are:
McCarthy against GC at home.
Or Menasupd against a poor PA team.
Probably McCarthy. could bag a few goals and get plenty of the ball this game.

So maybe you should go BurnKen

 

[Sir Skid]

Tough one, my thoughts are:
McCarthy against GC at home.
Or Menasupd against a poor PA team.
Probably McCarthy. could bag a few goals and get plenty of the ball this game.

So maybe you should go BurnKen

Yeah, I'll go Link and loophole BurnKen with Robbie Gray in mids I think.
Agree Menaspud could get a decent score too against POOrt.

 

[Boris the Contradiction]

Tippa and Paps imo.

Linc McCarthy, BurnKen or Menaspew on field?

Sorry it's late but I would've picked Kennedy. I traded Menadue to Matty Boyd this week. Very happy.

 

[Satan]

Tippa or papley on field?

 

[SC fish]

Tippa or papley on field?

Tough but I'd go Papley

 

[SC fish]

Hartley or Byrne?

 

[pulpdriver]

Hartley or Byrne?

Got the exact sam problem. Had Hartley all week but with a wet, windy day at the MCG I can see him posting a 30.

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

Went Kennedy and Papley over McCarthy so as long as Papley does alright that looks to be a good move. I also had Adams as emergency and decided to risk playing Hartley instead of taking the 64. Hartley could score anything from 30-90 I reckon but his average was just over 64 so in my mind I had to back him in

 

[SC fish]

Got the exact sam problem. Had Hartley all week but with a wet, windy day at the MCG I can see him posting a 30.

Went Hartley got 8 extra points!

 

[P_Cripps]

Start Hartley or Papley on field?

 

[jumpin_jack]

Now that Laird is crook. Need to start 3 of Tippa, Hartley, Brown, Dbj? GO

 

[Longbombswans]

Now that Laird is crook. Need to start 3 of Tippa, Hartley, Brown, Dbj? GO

I could be wrong but I don't think Essendon will get as much ball down in their forward line this week.

 

[Judd_Magic]

I could be wrong but I don't think Essendon will get as much ball down in their forward line this week.

I'm in the same predicament.

Have Laird out and Tippa and Brown on the bench.

Guess I'm playing Tippa as Brown will be up forward and will hardly get a touch as the ball wont be down Essendons forward line hardly at all.

 

[Kadog]

I'm in the same predicament.

Have Laird out and Tippa and Brown on the bench.

Guess I'm playing Tippa as Brown will be up forward and will hardly get a touch as the ball wont be down Essendons forward line hardly at all.

It's the SCG. Ball will be up there plenty.

 

[Judd_Magic]

It's the SCG. Ball will be up there plenty.

Not if Swans mids dominate though.

I think Tippa is the better choice than Brown.

Having said that I'm not confident in either. LOL!

 

[MightyMark]

Not if Swans mids dominate though.

I think Tippa is the better choice than Brown.

Having said that I'm not confident in either. LOL!

Tippa is averaging more, so go with him.

As good a method of choice as any.

 

[toxic]

Not if Swans mids dominate though.

I think Tippa is the better choice than Brown.

Having said that I'm not confident in either. LOL!

Tippa to be rested

 

[juddola]

Tippa to be rested

Do you know this or just guessing this?

 

[Sir Skid]

Tippa to be rested