Who is coming to Port Adelaide

[amazingjoshy]

i got a feeling it could be daniel kerr. mark williams said it was one of the elites in the league and that we had plenty of space in our salary cap. i also remember reading after the dreamteam match that kerr loved the way mark williams spoke.

I think it would be krakouer + surjan/cassisi + 2nd rounder > kerr

ur 1st pick would have to included....just surjan and pick 3/4 (whichever it is) or your 1st and 2nd pick would probably do it (could see Seaby being involved somehow also)

if you finish below freo your 1st pick would probably allow us to get Rich and Natainui

 

[Obeanie1]

ur 1st pick would have to included....just surjan and pick 3/4 (whichever it is) or your 1st and 2nd pick would probably do it (could see Seaby being involved somehow also)

if you finish below freo your 1st pick would probably allow us to get Rich and Natainui

OMG I just soiled myself reading that

Rich + Nat plus IMO three 2nd round picks to load up with young talent picks 18, 20 plus another 2nd rounder (21) from either the Kerr deal or another.

Hawks Mk II rebuild here we come.

I quite like Surjan. Pick 3 + 21 + Surjan for Seaby + Kerr. Hell we'll even throw in our third and forth round picks 36 and 52 as well cos we won't be using them.

DEAL

In fact you can have J Graham and Chad Fletcher as well.....

 

[Crazy Tails]

Possibly one A Didak now!

 

[elsler]

i very much doubt choco will trade our first round pick for anyone

 

[Obeanie1]

i very much doubt choco will trade our first round pick for anyone

First round picks should only be traded for elite players.

EG: Judd, J Brown................and yes one D Kerr.

Do you really think Kerr isn't worth a 1st round pick.........be honest!

 

[Lazyboy]

First round picks should only be traded for elite players.

EG: Judd, J Brown................and yes one D Kerr.

Do you really think Kerr isn't worth a 1st round pick.........be honest!

Whats Kerr done since Judd and Benny left.

 

[Obeanie1]

Whats Kerr done since Judd and Benny left.

Apart from being suspended and injured he's been saving himself for his next team.

 

[elsler]

First round picks should only be traded for elite players.

EG: Judd, J Brown................and yes one D Kerr.

Do you really think Kerr isn't worth a 1st round pick.........be honest!

Im not saying there not worth a first round pick and kerr and brown are worth a first round pick. Im saying port wont trade its first round pick

 

[Mego Red]

1. Glass
2. Hunter
3. Lynch
4. Hansen
5. Kennedy
6. Mitch Brown
7. Wilkes
8. Spanger
9. McKenzie
   10. Notte
   11. Graham

White would be on a similar level as Graham.

As to name calling calling your trade suggestion is laughable and is not name calling, if your worried about what I said you need to toughen up and even better don't put hacks up for trade and expect a serious reply.

Wow - good post. White WOULD be about tenth on the WCE depth chart - and the Eagles pretty much suck, so that speaks volumes on Damon's value ...

 

[Asgardian]

First round picks should only be traded for elite players.

EG: Judd, J Brown................and yes one D Kerr.

Do you really think Kerr isn't worth a 1st round pick.........be honest!

No, in my opinion he is not worth Port's 1st round pick which will be probably be selection 3 or 4.

Now if Port's 1st round pick was going to be selection say 12 to 16, then I'd maybe do the deal.

I still believe because of the associated baggage with Kerr, that his value has diminished as of late, well, that is my opinion.

 

[amazingjoshy]

No, in my opinion he is not worth Port's 1st round pick which will be probably be selection 3 or 4.

Now if Port's 1st round pick was going to be selection say 12 to 16, then I'd maybe do the deal.

I still believe because of the associated baggage with Kerr, that his value has diminished as of late, well, that is my opinion.

just out of curiosity...what if say WC got a 1st round pick for Kerr (say 6-10) then on ontraded that pick, our PP and Seaby to Port for your 1st and 2nd picks?

You maintain a relatively high 1st rounder, get a decent ruckman who would slot straight in and upgrade your 2nd round pick. We get the chance at the 2 best young West Australians in the draft.

 

[Asgardian]

No, getting Seaby is no way worth dropping from 3 or 4 down to 6 to 10 plus an upgrade of our 2nd round pick by only a couple of spots

No, not in this year's draft

To be frank, unless it was Buddy Franklin, or of that caliber, there is no way in hell I'd trade our 1st round pick for anyone, despite any mixture of other draft picks involved

 

[swannies]

Honestly, people need to stop dreaming about upgrading first round draft picks. As Asgardian said, they're not going to downgrade vital first round draft picks, unless you gave Cox, then they'd give the Eagles 3, possibly.

 

[Crow-mo]

White >>>> Seaby

if that were true, why do you want seaby?

Krakouer is a rare talent, as good as Pearce

not an endorsement.

Ebert is just your average typical midfielder, but he is an Ebert, that's the soul reason he is talked about.

which makes it a dumb trade from your point of view if you believe that.

 

[Crow-mo]

If Brad Ebert is worth pick 3 in THIS year's draft, boy, did the Crows royally screw up passing over him for Dangerfield.

Yawn. if, if, if... if Brad Ebert is worth Jonathan Brown then we did **** up didn't we. if that is?

We'll learn about Brad during the 2009 Trade week

you'll learn nothing at all. won't be discussed, won't be moving.

 

[Asgardian]

Just like people learn nothing from anything you post Crow-mo, you're Bigfooty's black hole.

No-one yawns after reading one of your posts, they've already gone to sleep just seeing your name.

Here's a clue, try value adding, I know, it's something you've never previously considered, let alone attempted, but I guarantee it'll improve your Bigfooty experience, and prove far less tedious for the rest of us, well those of us that try to remain awake.

 

[Obeanie1]

No, in my opinion he is not worth Port's 1st round pick which will be probably be selection 3 or 4.

Now if Port's 1st round pick was going to be selection say 12 to 16, then I'd maybe do the deal.

I still believe because of the associated baggage with Kerr, that his value has diminished as of late, well, that is my opinion.

Fair enough you entitled to your opinion but last year Kerr and Judd were not far apart in many critics eyes and Judd went for 3, 20 + a 21 yr old CHF.

Kerr is worth a first rounder + a second rounder or a player, and the Eagle would get that from quite a few teams. Richmond, Collingwood, Essendon and Carlton would put their hands up in a flash IMO.

 

[Dookey901]

Kerr is a gun and i would love to have him at Port Adelaide. Judd also has a much bigger influence on a game, can break a game open on his own and inspires his teammates with some of his plays. Judd is definetely worth alot more that what Kerr is.
I agree Port will need to give up a first rounder + a second rounder/player to get him.

 

[Ebert80]

Kerr is a gun and i would love to have him at Port Adelaide. Judd also has a much bigger influence on a game, can break a game open on his own and inspires his teammates with some of his plays. Judd is definetely worth alot more that what Kerr is.
I agree Port will need to give up a first rounder + a second rounder/player to get him.

At his best, Kerr's influence on a game, was virtually as high as Judd's.

As for giving up a first and second pick, if thats what the Eagles would want, well it won't happen.

 

[Dookey901]

At his best, Kerr's influence on a game, was virtually as high as Judd's.
quote]

Virtually as high being the key word. He is a gun no doubt but when at full flight there is not many if any players in the league with Judds class and abilities.

 

[Ebert80]

At his best, Kerr's influence on a game, was virtually as high as Judd's.
quote]

Virtually as high being the key word. He is a gun no doubt but when at full flight there is not many if any players in the league with Judds class and abilities.

Virtually is a fair bit different than saying a "much bigger influence"

 

[Dookey901]

Virtually is a fair bit different than saying a "much bigger influence"

That is true. If i got to choose between Judd and Kerr there would be no second thoughts who i'd want in my team.

 

[ytpme]

Seaby is a dud. You only have to watch WAFL football coverage (west perth) to know he is going nowhere. Any injury issues to Cox and WCE are in worse strife than we are.

Oporto, we already are!!!