Universal Love Who is the best player who has played for the Melbourne Football Club since and including 2000? WINNER: Max Gawn

[Headless]

Will just let this one run until there's a clear winner.

 

[Dory_77]

Will just let this one run until there's a clear winner.

Might be a while

 

[jhong]

 

[Topkent]

This would have been a fun experiment if it was who did you like more, not who was better.

I think Whelan would push Viney for sure.

 

[Bluelegs]

 

[Headless]

Jack Viney (2013-present)
Debut: Round 1, 2013
196* games, 56* goals

• Premiership player
• Club captain
• Club B&F

Jack Viney | Demonwiki

Demonwiki.org is the ultimate resource for Melbourne Demons fans. Explore team history, player profiles, match results, and more. Stay updated with the latest news on the Demons.

demonwiki.org

Matthew Whelan (2000-2009)
Debut: Round 4, 2000
150 games, 15 goals

Matthew Whelan | Demonwiki

Demonwiki.org is the ultimate resource for Melbourne Demons fans. Explore team history, player profiles, match results, and more. Stay updated with the latest news on the Demons.

demonwiki.org

EDIT (04/11/23): Results:

• Jack Viney: 19 (95%)
• Matthew Whelan: 1 (5%)

Jack Viney advances to the next round. Matthew Whelan has been eliminated.

 

[Headless]

Max Gawn (2010-present)
Debut: Round 11, 2011
203* games, 98* goals

• Premiership player
• Club captain
• 2x B&F
• 6x All-Australian
• ALFCA POTY

Max Gawn | Demonwiki

Demonwiki.org is the ultimate resource for Melbourne Demons fans. Explore team history, player profiles, match results, and more. Stay updated with the latest news on the Demons.

demonwiki.org

Jared Rivers (2003-2012)
Debut: Round 19, 2003
150 games, 18 goals

• Rising Star

Demonwiki | Jared Rivers

Demonwiki

www.demonwiki.org

EDIT (04/11/23): Results:

• Max Gawn: 10 (100%)
• Jared Rivers: 0 (0%)

 

[Topkent]

Man rivers and Miller's first 2 seasons it looked like we might have the best CHB/CHF combo for the next decade.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Another thriller incoming, could be weeks before a winner is determined

 

[Headless]

Man rivers and Miller's first 2 seasons it looked like we might have the best CHB/CHF combo for the next decade.

I remember thinking at one point if we could just get Rivers on the park, we'd be set.

 

[Headless]

Another thriller incoming, could be weeks before a winner is determined

Gawn was our first premiership captain in many decades. Could be closer than you think.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Once Brad started dating Pia he lost his manhood and anger. His anger made him as good as he was early.

 

[Topkent]

Once Brad started dating Pia he lost his manhood and anger. His anger made him as good as he was early.

Yeah I think it was that 2004 season where it seemed like Daniher was still pissed about what Essendon did to us an we played like absolute campaigners for the year. Miller, Carroll, Reid, Moloney, Neitz, Whelan etc they were extra angry that year.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Yeah I think it was that 2004 season where it seemed like Daniher was still pissed about what Essendon did to us an we played like absolute campaigners for the year. Miller, Carroll, Reid, Moloney, Neitz, Whelan etc they were extra angry that year.

Miller was genuinely feared, got suspended a fair bit but he was 10x the player he was when he was getting suspended than he was for the rest of his career. Made teammates walk taller and the opposition shit themselves.

 

[Bluelegs]

Man rivers and Miller's first 2 seasons it looked like we might have the best CHB/CHF combo for the next decade.

Similar could be said for so many players during that decade.

 

[Headless]

Max Gawn
Debut: Round 11, 2011
203* games, 98* goals

• Premiership player
• Club captain
• 2x B&F
• 6x All-Australian
• ALFCA POTY

Max Gawn | Demonwiki

Demonwiki.org is the ultimate resource for Melbourne Demons fans. Explore team history, player profiles, match results, and more. Stay updated with the latest news on the Demons.

demonwiki.org

Jared Rivers
Debut: Round 19, 2003
150 games, 18 goals

• Rising Star

Demonwiki | Jared Rivers

Demonwiki

www.demonwiki.org

EDIT (04/11/23): Results:

• Max Gawn: 10 (100%)
• Jared Rivers: 0 (0%)

Max Gawn advances to the next round. Jared Rivers has been eliminated.

 

[Headless]

Tom McDonald (2011-present)
Debut: Round 23, 2011
210* games, 166* goals

• Premiership player
• Leading goal-kicker

Tom McDonald | Demonwiki

Demonwiki.org is the ultimate resource for Melbourne Demons fans. Explore team history, player profiles, match results, and more. Stay updated with the latest news on the Demons.

demonwiki.org

James Frawley (2007-2014)
Debut: Round 9, 2007
139 games, 18 goals

• All-Australian

James Frawley | Demonwiki

Demonwiki.org is the ultimate resource for Melbourne Demons fans. Explore team history, player profiles, match results, and more. Stay updated with the latest news on the Demons.

demonwiki.org

EDIT (06/11/23): Results:

• Tom McDonald: 11 (46%)
• James Frawley: 13 (54%)

 

[Headless]

One of the tougher ones so far IMO. Might need to think for a bit.

 

[Scythe94]

Voted Chip, though I'm almost certain it's due to how much I've detested watching McDonald lumber around over the past two and a half years.

Bar McDonald's 2018 season, Frawley was the better player though, imo.

 

[Topkent]

This one is tough. Frawley was a gun for a couple seasons. McDonald was a good defender who turned shit, then a good forward who turned shit.

 

[jhong]

I will suck it up if he proves me wrong and has a good season next year , but he lost it in a close call for me by hanging on . Chip by a nose .

 

[Young Redleg]

This has probably been the toughest one so far. Tmac's career has been a real roller-coaster. He has a history of slotting into a position nicely for a couple of years and then losing his mojo.

Frawley wasn't quite the same player after 2010 but I don't think he ever reached the lows of Tmac's 2019/20.

I'd say Frawley, just.

 

[Toump Ass]

Not for me, this one's easy as piss, I f%ckin' hate that Macdonald campaigner.

 

[Bluelegs]

One of the tougher ones so far IMO. Might need to think for a bit.

Still hasn't voted. The air is thick with anticipation.

 

[Johnny Karate]

Hate them both but will hold my nose and vote Frawley.