Preferably as a senior assistant to lure in Dean Cox.If West Coast sack Adam Simpson would you take him as a senior coach replacing Nicks?
Alternatively as a senior assistant?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Preferably as a senior assistant to lure in Dean Cox.If West Coast sack Adam Simpson would you take him as a senior coach replacing Nicks?
Alternatively as a senior assistant?
No current season stats available
Adam Simpson now available
Because to do so will admit they got it wrongCan't wait for the day when the club posts its Statement on Matthew Nicks Sacking, take me back only 10 years ago when we weren't afraid of Sacking the Coach for putting up mediocre results. Sadly this club has turned even more vanilla and soft since..
True but they've done it before with Sanderson.Because to do so will admit they got it wrong
The scuttlebutt at the time and hinted at since suggests it was non-football relatedTrue but they've done it before with Sanderson.
He’s won less games than Nicks over the past half a decade and looked defeated, negative and devoid of any solutions the entire time. Let some other club confirm his early success was based on a fantastic list.Adam Simpson now available
If West Coast sack Adam Simpson would you take him as a senior coach replacing Nicks?
He’s won less games than Nicks over the past half a decade and looked defeated, negative and devoid of any solutions the entire time. Let some other club confirm his early success was based on a fantastic list.
He’s won less games than Nicks over the past half a decade and looked defeated, negative and devoid of any solutions the entire time. Let some other club confirm his early success was based on a fantastic list.
Sanderson's sacking was initiated by Roo who was bagging him in the media. Roo just followed through on his promise when he got in the hot seat. Roo needed Pavlich and Dunstall to tell him to sack Burton.True but they've done it before with Sanderson.
Doubt Nicks will either but not sure how we can trash Nicks and then want someone with a worse record than him since he’s been coaching. Is winning a flag outside Victoria that much of a task or have the disproportionate amount of Victorian teams just been better for a while? Remember there was a 10 year period when interstate clubs won 8 flags. Don’t think travel has got harder since.Huh?
Simpson has done something that I don’t think Nicks will ever do … win a premiership from outside of Victoria.
Simpson might not be the solution for us, but let’s not tar him with the Nicks brush!!
Doubt Nicks will either but not sure how we can trash Nicks and then want someone with a worse record than him since he’s been coaching.
By this logic you’d have Nicks over ClarksonDoubt Nicks will either but not sure how we can trash Nicks and then want someone with a worse record than him since he’s been coaching. Is winning a flag outside Victoria that much of a task or have the disproportionate amount of Victorian teams just been better for a while? Remember there was a 10 year period when interstate clubs won 8 flags. Don’t think travel has got harder since.
The point seems very elusive for some. Maybe just forget the Nicks bit and ask would we want a coach who’s record over a significant period of time is terrible and his demeanour and attitude over that period are also extremely questionable.By this logic you’d have Nicks over Clarkson
The point seems very elusive for some. Maybe just forget the Nicks bit and ask would we want a coach who’s record over a significant period of time is terrible and his demeanour and attitude over that period are also extremely questionable.
You think WCE shouldn’t have sacked him?Yes.
114 out of his first 178The point seems very elusive for some. Maybe just forget the Nicks bit and ask would we want a coach who’s record over a significant period of time is terrible and his demeanour and attitude over that period are also extremely questionable.
How many coaches in their 2nd job have won a flag in the past 2 decades? Zero.114 out of his first 178
8 out of the next 64
I'd suggest his demeanour is due to those last 3 years than the 1st 6
I think we need to focus on his first 180 rather than the last 50
I dont think he comes here anyway - he may want a year off to recharge but he does become interesting for 2026
This isnt a reason not to tryHow many coaches in their 2nd job have won a flag in the past 2 decades? Zero.
You think WCE shouldn’t have sacked him?