Coach Who Should Our Next Coach Be (Poll Updated)

[domus]

Can't believe there isn't more support for Pyke, literally the most proven candidate in very recent history, camp aside.

He lost his players and turned the club into a rabble with his terribly ill advised preseason camp. No thanks.

 

[Jafo]

Are you that desperate to rule Ross Lyon out of contention?

Haven’t ruled anyone in or out. Just think Luke Ball is a good operator/football mind.

 

[swoop42]

‘I begged him not to do it’: How Licuria tried to stop McGuire’s exit

Club football director Paul Licuria will consult Mick Malthouse about the type of coach the Pies will pursue, and reveals he “virtually begged” former president Eddie McGuire not to leave.

www.theage.com.au

Collingwood will not necessarily target a big-name replacement for Nathan Buckley and are open to a first-timer being put in charge as the club embarks on their first in-depth process to find a new coach in decades.

Magpies football director Paul Licuria said the club did not have a preconceived idea of the type of coach it needed, whether that was an experienced hand or someone lower-profiled.

 

[No SPIN]

'No young coach could go in there and do it': Malthouse calls on Collingwood to replace Nathan Buckley with an older coach

Former Magpies coach Mick Malthouse says Collingwood should be targeting an older candidate, rather than an up-and-comer like Sam Mitchell, to replace Nathan Buckley as AFL coach.

www.abc.net.au

MM is 100% right - a Newbie would be completely overwhelmed especially when the media dogs start circling during a stretch of losses.
They give little respect to Newbies as we are currently seeing with Teague.
Only a seasoned Coach can effectively deal with that pressure and manage ( ie. intimidate ) the media.

 

[No SPIN]

He lost his players and turned the club into a rabble with his terribly ill advised preseason camp. No thanks.

People learn -
Swans are a highly professional organization and would not have appointed Pyke without extensive DD.

 

[piepark]

Interesting video. Honestly I think his personality while coaching comes across as slightly unlikable and not genuine. Couldn't quite out my finger in it while watching but it didn't resonate with me at all.

Thought the moment where he was on the phone directing the player to play on the other side of the ground and said thank you at the end felt passive aggressive and weird.

Honestly that video could have been 20 different coaches and they all sound the same. We have to leave this process to the experts. Whilst the head coach will be critical in how our players move on, the assistants will be vital in the chain of command.

In my mind Mitchell hasn't done a thing to warrant a senior coaching gig. It would be a bold experiment. If there is 3-5 year plan to win a flag, then surely a senior coach must be frontrunners in this process. Only a hand full meet that criteria.

I'm not sold on anyone, but I trust the club's judgement on this one.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

The Mitch's 3 qrt time speach.. end of game.. he's backing his players to go out there and make the right choices.. leadership.. hardness.. collective aggressive mindset.. praising and not overly aggressive towards his players.. not overbearing.

Keeps everything simple really.. he's always been like that though.. in the media as a player.. not overly complicated..

One thing I got from watching that vid.. if I had the choice of the Hodge or the Mitch for the role.. I'd go the Mitch. What surprises me about the Hodge.. how critical he is of the players. Not good.

I'll back the GW the Lic and the Ando.. pretty sure they'll have a good idea if he can deal with the pressure of coaching at a big club.

MM is 100% right - a Newbie would be completely overwhelmed especially when the media dogs start circling during a stretch of losses.
They give little respect to Newbies as we are currently seeing with Teague.
Only a seasoned Coach can effectively deal with that pressure and manage ( ie. intimidate ) the media.

 

[10571z]

Should get Craig Bellamy in some sort of role at the club. Absolute coaching god. I don’t care what sport he gets the best out of people

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Should get Craig Bellamy in some sort of role at the club. Absolute coaching god. I don’t care what sport he gets the best out of people

I care what sort of sport hes an expert in and so should the club.

 

[Quicky]

'No young coach could go in there and do it': Malthouse calls on Collingwood to replace Nathan Buckley with an older coach

Former Magpies coach Mick Malthouse says Collingwood should be targeting an older candidate, rather than an up-and-comer like Sam Mitchell, to replace Nathan Buckley as AFL coach.

www.abc.net.au

That dinosaur thinks woman can't play AFL because of their body shape. Look up antiquated opinion in the dictionary and I'm pretty sure there's a picture of an old dude with a white moustache.

 

[10571z]

I care what sort of sport hes an expert in and so should the club.

I’m not saying head coach, but maybe a development role. One of the best coach’s in any sport world wide

 

[The Royal Sampler]

That dinosaur thinks woman can't play AFL because of their body shape. Look up antiquated opinion in the dictionary and I'm pretty sure there's a picture of an old dude with a white moustache.

Also if you look up antiquated opinion at a KFC franchise.

 

[Matt_352]

I've seen enough sign him up

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

I’m not saying head coach, but maybe a development role. One of the best coach’s in any sport world wide

I dont think the soft cap allows wriggle room for cheerleaders who dont know anything about the game

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Can’t be verified but a poster on the Hawks board is adamant we interviewed Mitchell yesterday.

 

[10571z]

Can’t be verified but a poster on the Hawks board is adamant we interviewed Mitchell yesterday.

I’d say we would interview everyone available with the correct credentials

 

[The Royal Sampler]

It’s more that the process seems to have started in earnest already.

 

[PonsfordMagpie]

Instead of a Mitchell-Choco combination, what about Kingsley-Choco?

Kingsley played under Williams and has been an assistant coach for about 15 years with three clubs. Very highly rated in the industry.

 

[Matt_352]

Instead of a Mitchell-Choco combination, what about Kingsley-Choco?

Kingsley played under Williams and has been an assistant coach for about 15 years with three clubs. Very highly rated in the industry.

Any of Yze, Mitchell or Kingsley with Choco as a mentor figure is my ideal outcome

 

[Carringbush2010]

He lost his players and turned the club into a rabble with his terribly ill advised preseason camp. No thanks.

I don't think that was a Pyke call, if I am correct it was a director move, think it was Rutten.

 

[Matt_352]

I don't think that was a Pyke call, if I am correct it was a director move, think it was Rutten.

Yeah Rutten was main instigator

 

[PonsfordMagpie]

Any of Yze, Mitchell or Kingsley with Choco as a mentor figure is my ideal outcome

Worth a listen, particularly towards the end of the interview where he's asked about his coaching aspirations.

Richmond Assistant Coach Adam Kingsley chats ahead of clash with West Coast

Richmond Assistant Coach Adam Kingsley chats to the 6PR Football team ahead of the Tigers’ blockbuster clash with West Coast Listen below:

www.6pr.com.au

 

[LuckyLee]

Mark Williams has the best coaching pedigree other than Clarkson. He has done it all at multiple clubs and surely has a soft spot to finish his AFL career at the same club that it started.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Matt_352]

Worth a listen, particularly towards the end of the interview where he's asked about his coaching aspirations.

Richmond Assistant Coach Adam Kingsley chats ahead of clash with West Coast

Richmond Assistant Coach Adam Kingsley chats to the 6PR Football team ahead of the Tigers’ blockbuster clash with West Coast Listen below:

www.6pr.com.au

Yep very happy with what I heard

 

[Hardas]

‘I begged him not to do it’: How Licuria tried to stop McGuire’s exit

Club football director Paul Licuria will consult Mick Malthouse about the type of coach the Pies will pursue, and reveals he “virtually begged” former president Eddie McGuire not to leave.

www.theage.com.au

I certainly hope they're not locked into thinking it has to be a big name with previous AFL head coaching experience - that could make for a fairly short list.