Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[Madblue]

To the contrary, you're delusional if you think Collingwood aren't a Powerhouse club.

What is your definition of a powerhouse club, and who are they, if Collingwood aren't?

You have won 3 flags in 66 years
Ageing list
No depth or youth coming through
No draft picks to help this year
Dont look like making finals this year
Crowds dropping off

Yep you are a powerhouse club

 

[Fadge]

You have won 3 flags in 66 years
Ageing list
No depth or youth coming through
No draft picks to help this year
Dont look like making finals this year
Crowds dropping off

Yep you are a powerhouse club

Answer the question...

What is your definition of a powerhouse club, if the following criteria isn't aligned with your definition:
Most premierships
Most Grand Final appearances
Most finals appearances
Most games won
Most attended club in the history of the game (by a long way)
Biggest supporter group worldwide

Is your idea of a powerhouse club the team with the most promising youth and best hand at the draft table?

 

[Fadge]

What are collingwoods dreams for this year ?

Following up our 2023 premiership with the 2024 premiership.

 

[Arr0w]

So for the record, this fellow is stating that if Gold Coast win the first Grand Final they play in, they become a powerhouse club.

Nice try at another cherry pick, but essentially they would have a better strike rate than the Pies

 

[Arr0w]

Fadge try and stay on topic

Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood, do you have an answer?

 

[Madblue]

Answer the question...

What is your definition of a powerhouse club, if the following criteria isn't aligned with your definition:
Most premierships
Most Grand Final appearances
Most finals appearances
Most games won
Most attended club in the history of the game (by a long way)
Biggest supporter group worldwide

Is your idea of a powerhouse club the team with the most promising youth and best hand at the draft table?

Powerhouse club as of now....certainly not

 

[Fadge]

Powerhouse club as of now....certainly not

Oh. So the powerhouse clubs change on a week by week basis?

Who are the powerhouse clubs currently?

 

[Madblue]

Oh. So the powerhouse clubs change on a week by week basis?

Who are the powerhouse clubs currently?

Certainly not Collingwood thats for sure.

For who is, dont really care. Was just responding to your delusional statement that Collingwood are

 

[Fadge]

Certainly not Collingwood thats for sure.

For who is, dont really care. Was just responding to your delusional statement that Collingwood are

Come on.

If you're saying Collingwood aren't, you must have something upon which to form that conclusion.

So who are the powerhouse clubs of that AFL, as we sit here on July 24, 2024?

 

[RPCB]

Come on.

If you're saying Collingwood aren't, you must have something upon which to form that conclusion.

So who are the powerhouse clubs of that AFL, as we sit here on July 24, 2024?

The amount of times I’ve read you say that Collingwood supporters don’t need acknowledgement from Carlton supporters, only to follow up with a post where seeking acknowledgement from Carlton supporters is astonishing.

 

[Aphrodite]

Collingwood have won the most Premierships

Took them 28 years to catch up to Carlton and equal us 16.

FACT!






#Imfadgening

 

[Arr0w]

Poor pie supporters, still deflecting from the OP, thinking they are a powerhouse

Boy oh boy wowee

 

[Aphrodite]

Poor pie supporters, still deflecting from the OP, thinking they are a powerhouse

Boy oh boy wowee

But they have won the most Premierships!

 

[Arr0w]

Collingwood have won the most Premierships

Took them 28 years to catch up to Carlton on 16.

FACT!






#Imfadgening

4 decades ffs

 

[RPCB]

Collingwood have won the most Premierships

Took them 28 years to catch up to Carlton on 16.

FACT!






#Imfadgening

Imagine Collingwood having 27 chances to win a 17th flag and they choke every single time. This is a club that probably should be sitting on 25 flags right now, if we are being honest.

 

[SpiritOfCarlton]

Imagine liking powerhouses more than premierships.

 

[Thrawn]

Come on.

 

[Fadge]

The amount of times I’ve read you say that Collingwood supporters don’t need acknowledgement from Carlton supporters, only to follow up with a post where seeking acknowledgement from Carlton supporters is astonishing.

Who is seeking acknowledgement?

I'm just interested in his perspective on who the powerhouse clubs are, if (in his assessment) Collingwood aren't.

 

[Fadge]

Imagine liking powerhouses more than premierships.

Imagine being both the reigning premier AND the powerhouse club of the competition.

 

[RPCB]

Who is seeking acknowledgement?

I'm just interested in his perspective on who the powerhouse clubs are, if (in his assessment) Collingwood aren't.

Carry on then.

 

[Robertio]

Imagine being both the reigning premier AND the powerhouse club of the competition.

You haven't realised yet that your powerhouse club is down the bottom end of the ladder.

 

[Arr0w]

You haven't realised yet that your powerhouse club is down the bottom end of the ladder.

Even if they were in the 8, they aren't a Powerhouse

 

[Fadge]

So multiple posters saying Collingwood aren't a Powerhouse, though declining you provide their rationale as to what constitutes a powerhouse and who those powerhouses are.

Just standard behaviour from this supporter group.

Who do they think they're kidding?

Trying to say 'Collingwood aren't a powerhouse' would be like me saying 'Carlton don't have navy blue in their traditional jumper, so there!'

 

[bradfisher14]

So multiple posters saying Collingwood aren't a Powerhouse, though declining you provide their rationale as to what constitutes a powerhouse and who those powerhouses are.

Just standard behaviour from this supporter group.

Who do they think they're kidding?

Trying to say 'Collingwood aren't a powerhouse' would be like me saying 'Carlton don't have navy blue in their traditional jumper, so there!'

This is a new low for you pal. Might be time to log off I reckon.

 

[Gw2_James]

This is a new low for you pal. Might be time to log off I reckon.

Yeah it's pretty sad. He's just finding anything he possibly can to argue against. I guess it was bound to happen. Can't wait to see next week when we beat his team, cement our top 4 spot and guarantee his team finishing outside the 8.