Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[carlton_99]

Adelaide and West Coast.

Unfortunately Collingwood can't beat Collingwood, and just in case you haven't realised, Carlton have lost to Collingwood twice in 2024.

What round did Carlton lose to West Coast?

 

[Robertio]

What are you talking about? The question was find a list where Collingwood wasn't number 1 - has nothing to do with Carlton. Those columns they aren't number 1.

I personally think this whole topic is stupid given we are in a 2024 thread. Could not care less about what was happening in 1897.

Anyway back to 2024 and on the topic of "lists". Did you find that list of teams Pies have beaten that we have lost to?

Something tells me you won't get an answer mate.

 

[Fadge]

What round did Carlton lose to West Coast?

Round 23.

 

[Robertio]

Adelaide and West Coast.

Unfortunately Collingwood can't beat Collingwood, and just in case you haven't realised, Carlton have lost to Collingwood twice in 2024.

Got nothing to do with this thread.

 

[Fadge]

Something tells me you won't get an answer mate.

Oh look, wrong again.

 

[Worm4]

Hawthorn is the only side outside the top 8 than can make it. They have games against Nth and Richmond.
Carlton win next week and the top 8 is done in my opinion.
Pies left it too late in my opinion. Ordinary premiership defence in my books.

 

[carlton_99]

Round 23.

I would prefer to stick to games that have already happened. We don't all have your "inner eye".

 

[Fadge]

Got nothing to do with this thread.

What hasn't got anything to do with this thread?

My response to a question that you predicted I wouldn't answer, or Collingwood beating Carlton twice in a thread where the thread topic is 'Who will be better - Carlton or Collingwood?'

As I said earlier - these Carlton posters don't know whether they are Arthur or Martha.

 

[JustaBattler]

Oh get a grip, that was our GF last night

Time to schedule the surgeries and reload for next year

Collingwood can still finish above Carlton for the year.

 

[Fadge]

Hawthorn is the only side outside the top 8 than can make it. They have games against Nth and Richmond.

Interesting you say this...

 

[10571z]

Our 44 points currently this season surpasses Geelongs 42 points of last season.

So we have now at least put the “worst premiership defence in history” to bed.

Couldn’t care if we win the next 5 wooden spoons as our premiership defence.

We experienced such an amazing year Carlton fans hadn’t felt for a long long long time.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

And, the evidence I provided is 3 sides on 16 flags, that's what sides play for right?

That's a statement of personal opinion, not proof

Found that list yet?

 

[carlton_99]

That's a statement of personal opinion, not proof

Found that list yet?

There were literally three lists in the table you posted where you aren't number 1...

• Premierships/finals
• Premierships/season
• Finals/season

 

[Arr0w]

That's a statement of personal opinion, not proof

Found that list yet?

Opinion? Oh my

 

[JustaBattler]

What hasn't got anything to do with this thread?

My response to a question that you predicted I wouldn't answer, or Collingwood beating Carlton twice in a thread where the thread topic is 'Who will be better - Carlton or Collingwood?'

As I said earlier - these Carlton posters don't know whether they are Arthur or Martha.

Why not start the thread with that simple question instead of your usual weazle wording allowing for weazle twists and turns and changes to definitions?


#stoptheweazlingdirtybirds

 

[Robertio]

What hasn't got anything to do with this thread?

My response to a question that you predicted I wouldn't answer, or Collingwood beating Carlton twice in a thread where the thread topic is 'Who will be better - Carlton or Collingwood?'

As I said earlier - these Carlton posters don't know whether they are Arthur or Martha.

Why didn't you reply to his post directly? Making a statement on it's own just confuses the issue.

 

[Fadge]

There were literally three lists in the table you posted where you aren't number 1...

• Premierships/finals
• Premierships/season
• Finals/season based

'Literally' three lists in a single list.

Gee, the loss last night really has knocked you around, hasn't it?

 

[carlton_99]

Why didn't you reply to his post directly? Making a statement on it's own just confuses the issue.

And it was also an inaccurate answer based on the games that have been played so far.

 

[carlton_99]

'Literally' three lists in a single list.

Gee, the loss last night really has knocked you around, hasn't it?

Every column in that table is a different metric which can be ranked as its own list - not really that difficult.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Opinion? Oh my

Yes a baseless opinion provided with zero evidence, I'll give you another 30 mins to find that list

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Every column in that table is a different metric which can be ranked as its own list - not really that difficult.

Cool then show us an all time list where Collingwood are not on top before any columns are sorted

 

[PP34]

Carlton are a pathetic spineless bunch of weak campaigners

Not sure how any Blues fan could continue lipping off when we continue to be such an embarrassment

 

[carlton_99]

Cool then show us an all time list where Collingwood are not on top before any columns are sorted

What do you mean "before columns are sorted"? That is how you rank teams - you sort them from highest to lowest in the given metric.

 

[Arr0w]

Yes a baseless opinion provided with zero evidence, I'll give you another 30 mins to find that list

Let's do it another way

Are you disputing that 3 sides have won 16 flags?

And the Pies were the last of the 3 sides to win a 16th flag?

 

[Fadge]

What do you mean "before columns are sorted"? That is how you rank teams - you sort them from highest to lowest in the given metric.

You overlooked a fourth and equally (ir)relevant 'list'- Alphabetical order.