![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/carlton.png)
Robertio
Spotswood Guinness Bar manager
Ha ha you're not going to land me with that one.Happens too often, definitely time for a new captain, someone with a killer instinct
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Ha ha you're not going to land me with that one.Happens too often, definitely time for a new captain, someone with a killer instinct
Yep.and you still lose to below bog average sides with your season on the line?
As we've said many times, a flag from 2023 makes a disappointing 2024 a little easier to swallow.When was Collingwoods season on the line stuff ? Like 6 weeks ago ? Lol.
Won't make finals. Horrible follow up from 2023.
I don't see what Saturday night had to do with the 1990 grand finalI know, we had a collingwood v essendon moment and shat the bed. You know exactly what I'm talking about![]()
Incorrect. Both are true. We won and you lost.I told you we lost, you never won it.
'Boarder' v. 'Border' as another example.They do tend to struggle with words with more than one syllable - although even some like “win” seem to be beyond them at the moment.
Oh no.Carlton with 3 bottom 10 sides to finish off the year before finals. Pies will need to make finals to be “better”
Never?Oh no.
When have we heard this before?!?
The siren had gone and a Carlton player decided the game, Colingwood players could only watch on and had no influence on the result whatsoever.Incorrect. Both are true. We won and you lost.
Doesn't seem to sink in with you.Oh no.
When have we heard this before?!?
And you had to go back almost half a century for that one.1970-79-81 levels of pain.
You're the second Pie that didn't read the post i was responding to.And you had to go back almost half a century for that one.
Well done.
Your opinion, not ours - was always Carlton not contending. This time last year we weren't even in the top 8. Now we are. I would say we are improving ever so slightly. Collingwood on the other hand have dropped 9 spots on the ladder. I had them finishing 4th from memory at start of the year. Can't believe I over rated them so much and am miles away from my initial prediction. I feel so embarassedAs we've said many times, a flag from 2023 makes a disappointing 2024 a little easier to swallow.
But for Carlton, this build and rebuild has been 20 years in the making, and you've peaked at mid-table.
Oops.
We'll all live having just won the premiership.When was Collingwoods season on the line stuff ? Like 6 weeks ago ? Lol.
Won't make finals. Horrible follow up from 2023.
There is the real likelihood that the peak of this Carlton team is short of a contender.Your opinion, not ours - was always Carlton not contending. This time last year we weren't even in the top 8. Now we are. I would say we are improving ever so slightly. Collingwood on the other hand have dropped 9 spots on the ladder. I had them finishing 4th from memory at start of the year. Can't believe I over rated them so much and am miles away from my initial prediction. I feel so embarassed
50k posts since 2015.Need a snickers mate
Only one of us are in the 8 and it must be the Pies after you read this garbage.There is the real likelihood that the peak of this Carlton team is short of a contender.
Which is exactly what I have been saying.
Lack of depth.
Lack of speed.
Lack of quality ball users and decision makers.
Too many injury prone players on your list.
Back to the drawing board. Let's hope you get a better result next time and it takes less than 20 years...
You mean 3 flags since the start of the AFL competition. How many legitimate premierships have you won?Pie supporters still referencing non 2024
Someone should tell them that they have only won 3 flags in 6p odd years
Such a powerhouse
50k posts since 2015.
Now it all makes sense.
If you've been having trouble getting a new script since the good Dr Edelston departed, I'm sure someone from your board can assist.
So who got the 4 points? Or were they withheld as only Carlton lost the game and Collingwood didn't win?The siren had gone and a Carlton player decided the game, Colingwood players could only watch on and had no influence on the result whatsoever.
You don't actually know that.We'll all live having just won the premiership.
I'm sure Geelong wasn't too concerned in 2023.
It wont be 20 years, a high number of spoons and number 1 picks, and begging the AFL for more help until we are contending again.
Pie supporters still referencing non 2024
Someone should tell them that they have only won 3 flags in 6p odd years
Such a powerhouse
The siren had gone and a Carlton player decided the game, Colingwood players could only watch on and had no influence on the result whatsoever.
Where did i say Collingwood didn't win? I said they had no influence on who won the game after the siren had sounded.So who got the 4 points? Or were they withheld as only Carlton lost the game and Collingwood didn't win?