Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood?

[Milanista28]

What a roller-coaster this thread is!

 

[manicpie]

Pies with a tough draw. Will struggle to make the 8

ok, lol

 

[Sector 7G]

And still undefeated in the last 8 weeks regardless of injuries. nice try

Spoke a little too soon. You haven’t had injuries for 8 weeks either.

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Pies were undermanned but geez the sooking at the umpires & playing for frees in the last was just silly.

Funnily enough I think beating them is simple. Tag Daicos, the dude is a cheat code when he’s allowed to do what he wants. I understand ‘team defence’ and all that but surely it’s not that deep to just tag the oppositions best player (when they’re as good as him).

Dogs had no Naughton, Libba, Weightman, Smith, Richards, Johanissen, Coffield.

Pies hanging out for a 36 year old to return.

Worrying signs.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Pies were undermanned but geez the sooking at the umpires & playing for frees in the last was just silly.

Funnily enough I think beating them is simple. Tag Daicos, the dude is a cheat code when he’s allowed to do what he wants. I understand ‘team defence’ and all that but surely it’s not that deep to just tag the oppositions best player (when they’re as good as him).

Yep, clearly coaches don't think Nick is worth tagging yet but really you stick anyone with a tank and some muscle on him and he's practically useless. The rest of the Pies squad is bog ordinary.

 

[manicpie]

Spoke a little too soon. You haven’t had injuries for 8 weeks either.

how do you speak too soon when the 8th week has passed. you campaigners are trying believe that we are no good but deep down, you're shitting yourselves

 

[Madblue]

Totally ageing list and no depth or young talent coming through, the Pies are in trouble

 

[beerbandit]

Dogs had no Naughton, Libba, Weightman, Smith, Richards, Johanissen, Coffield.

Pies hanging out for a 36 year old to return.

Worrying signs.

Who the f is Coffield.

 

[Worm4]

I reckon even you were proud of that effort

Fully expected the reigning champs to knock off a side from outside the top 8 and comfortably. Collingwood should have put the game beyond doubt with 10 goals in the first quarter and thats not an exaggeration.

 

[manicpie]

Fully expected the reigning champs to knock off a side from outside the top 8 and comfortably. Collingwood should have put the game beyond doubt with 10 goals in the first quarter and thats not an exaggeration.

no you didn't, now your just being silly

 

[beerbandit]

Dogs had no Naughton, Libba, Weightman, Smith, Richards, Johanissen, Coffield.

Pies hanging out for a 36 year old to return.

Worrying signs.

And Smith plays for Collingwood, didn’t you know ?

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Who the f is Coffield.

About as relevant as Cox who I'm sure is on your list of players you struggled without.

 

[beerbandit]

Fully expected the reigning champs to knock off a side from outside the top 8 and comfortably. Collingwood should have put the game beyond doubt with 10 goals in the first quarter and thats not an exaggeration.

 

[beerbandit]

About as relevant as Cox who I'm sure is on your list of players you struggled without.

Not sure anyone has mentioned players out apart from you, so please continue.

 

[CarmenSandiego]

Yep, clearly coaches don't think Nick is worth tagging yet but really you stick anyone with a tank and some muscle on him and he's practically useless. The rest of the Pies squad is bog ordinary.

I really hope Vossy thinks he’s worth tagging when we play them next.

He’s basically their entire team.

He gets the clearances, provides the run, rebound from defense, sneaks fwd, accumulates. The pies are absolutely screwed without him.

 

[Worm4]

no you didn't, now your just being silly

Don't think there were any contentious decisions in the game apart from Nick not being penalised for holding the ball early in front of bulldogs goal. Couldn't think of any other reason why the Pies should have lost this match

 

[manicpie]

About as relevant as Cox who I'm sure is on your list of players you struggled without.

gotta love round 12 premieirs

 

[manicpie]

I really hope Vossy thinks he’s worth tagging when we play them next.

He’s basically their entire team.

He gets the clearances, provides the run, rebound from defense, sneaks fwd, accumulates. The pies are absolutely screwed without him.

All things yo0ur midfielders can't do, don't you just love him

 

[Worm4]

I really hope Vossy thinks he’s worth tagging when we play them next.

He’s basically their entire team.

He gets the clearances, provides the run, rebound from defense, sneaks fwd, accumulates. The pies are absolutely screwed without him.

He is hard to tag. Keep him to 30 and we are doing well in my opinion.

 

[Worm4]

All things yo0ur midfielders can't do, don't you just love him

Easy tiger, Cripps goes ok in my opinion

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

gotta love round 12 premieirs

Better than being round 12 out of the 8!

 

[carlton_99]

gotta love round 12 premieirs

A smidge better than Round 11 premiers you would think?

 

[Sector 7G]

how do you speak too soon when the 8th week has passed. you campaigners are trying believe that we are no good but deep down, you're shitting yourselves

By bragging about not losing for 8 weeks ( did have 2 draws) and now you haven’t.
Also 8 weeks hasn’t passed because you played round 4 on a Sunday

 

[manicpie]

By bragging about not losing for 8 weeks ( did have 2 draws) and now you haven’t.
Also 8 weeks hasn’t passed because you played round 4 on a Sunday

nope, doesn't cut it, this week is week 9 but nice try

 

[Aphrodite]

Carringbush could be out the 8 by the end of this round