Banter Who will be better in 2025, Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[Robertio]

Cripps has a 3-13 career record vs Collingwood

I don't want to hear any facts mate.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

De Goey has burst power and pace, eats pies full of protein. Cripps has a real sweet tooth hence he’s fat and slow and gets exposed by the Collingwood midfield his entire career

Cripps with 6 pack abs vs Degoey who's weightloss program is a 10 day coke bender in bali... Interesting hill to die on

 

[Corn Cobbers]

De Goey has burst power and pace, eats pies full of protein. Cripps has a real sweet tooth hence he’s fat and slow and gets exposed by the Collingwood midfield his entire career

Fatty Cripps v Collingwood

 

[Ctracks]

70 years is a better data set to talk about than 20 - but I guess the typical Collingwood supporter is either embarrassed about their own history of miserable failure and not able to count past 20 anyway..

Oh yes, the old "data set" defence, also known as; don't talk about this time period please, only talk about that time period!
It's interesting that bluebagger flogs keep bringing up the 12-15 team era.
Perhaps, Carlolton should examine the years 1945-95 more closely to rediscover the winning formula.
The blues haven't done any winning for close to 30 years...
Will the premiership drought continue with the introduction of the 19th and 20th teams???

 

[Ctracks]

Carlton #1 crowd attendance in AFL at the MCG
Carlton #1 crowd attendance at Marvel

now THAT is a powerhouse Club

Are you going up to Brisbane next weekend???

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Fat

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Fat View attachment 2096488

Mate that's Cripps when he was 19. He's smashed a gazillion cheeseburgers since then.

 

[smit_is]

Mate that's Cripps when he was 19. He's smashed a gazillion cheeseburgers since then.

Yet he’s the favourite to win the Brownlow this year. What does that say about the Mags’ team list?

 

[nahnah]

Yet he’s the favourite to win the Brownlow this year. What does that say about the Mags’ team list?

Absolutely nothing considering the 3-13 career record from Fatty Crippa

 

[smit_is]

Absolutely nothing considering the 3-13 career record from Fatty Crippa

I suspect that record will start to shift in the other direction over the coming years, as some of your greats reach their twilight years, and there’s more of a reliance on DeBlowey etc. The poor Daicos boys can’t do it all.

 

[nahnah]

I suspect that record will start to shift in the other direction over the coming years, as some of your greats reach their twilight years, and there’s more of a reliance on DeBlowey etc. The poor Daicos boys can’t do it all.

I suspect not especially when you consider he is almost 30 and 11 years into his career its 3-13

 

[Chief]

Change the title already? Soft

Fixed it.

 

[smit_is]

I suspect not especially when you consider he is almost 30 and 11 years into his career its 3-13

I don't think you've fully understood what I've written. I didn't say the end result would be even; instead, I suspect it will start to sway in the other direction over the coming years.

As the Mags and the younger Daicos will likely find out soon enough, it takes more than one gun player to succeed in a team sport.

 

[nahnah]

I don't think you've fully understood what I've written. I didn't say the end result would be even; instead, I suspect it will start to sway in the other direction over the coming years.

As the Mags and the younger Daicos will likely find out soon enough, it takes more than one gun player to succeed in a team sport.

I've understood what you've written, even in a rare year where you finish above collingwood it was still 0-2 for Fatty. Nick will continue to run rings around the blues for many years to come and Fatty will continue to be left in the dust

 

[CarmenSandiego]

Collingwood's list management approach has worked pretty well for them in recent times, having played Preliminary Finals or better in 11 of the past 23 seasons.

How can you possibly compare Collingwood with 'Carlton arrogance of the 90's'?

Deluded.

Yep, worked for us too... until it didn't.

Ignoring the unofficial rules of equalization always catches up (except Geelong who are different due to having a monopoly on their location).

23 years is an odd timeline, I would say it's best to look at your strategy since the introduction of FA (start of 2013).

The only reason you bounced back up in 2022-2023 was due to some F/S & academy selections falling in your lap. If you didn't have access to them, you would've been stuck in mediocrity like you were in 2013-2017 (then again in 2020-2021).

Now, what? You're going to continue ignoring the draft & pray that superstars nominate you as their preferred club despite you having no currency or picks to play with and no guarantee of success with an ageing list? and the reason you have no currency or picks to play with is, well.. due to ignoring the draft.

You are absolutely deluded if you think Collingwood don't have serious list management issues on your hands.

 

[Worm4]

I suspect not especially when you consider he is almost 30 and 11 years into his career its 3-13

He would be the one of the youngest if on collingwoods list. Plenty of time left

 

[smit_is]

I've understood what you've written, even in a rare year where you finish above collingwood it was still 0-2 for Fatty. Nick will continue to run rings around the blues for many years to come and Fatty will continue to be left in the dust

Of course he’s running circles around Cripps. Cripps is in there winning the hard ball.

Two different players.

 

[nahnah]

He would be the one of the youngest if on collingwoods list. Plenty of time left

Actually Carlton have quiet a few key members in that 29-31 age, hopefully for blues fans sake they have the longevity of the Collingwood champions but not always the case

 

[nahnah]

Of course he’s running circles around Cripps. Cripps is in there winning the hard ball.

Two different players.

Nick is an extractor, he goes in wins it and bursts out. Cripps is a feeder goes in wins it but doesnt have the burst relies on the feed

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Fat View attachment 2096488

Abs don't align, looks like a photoshop

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Suck Collingwood.

 

[Worm4]

Nick is an extractor, he goes in wins it and bursts out. Cripps is a feeder goes in wins it but doesnt have the burst relies on the feed

Thats a strange take. He is fat and relies on the feed and has no burst. Just one remark for you -

 

[nahnah]

Thats a strange take. He is fat and relies on the feed and has no burst. Just one remark for you -

Fatty likes a feed whats hard to understand

 

[Thrawn]

Serious question for Blues fans. Where does Cripps sit amongst the Carlton greats? Top 10? Top 5? Top 3? Could he end up the greatest Blue?

If he wins a flag with this team, then top 5.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

I've understood what you've written, even in a rare year where you finish above collingwood it was still 0-2 for Fatty. Nick will continue to run rings around the blues for many years to come and Fatty will continue to be left in the dust

He's hardly going to be staying put at a Pies team, that will be midtable at best in the coming years now is he?