Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[beerbandit]

Who on the Pies is level with Cripps, Curnow, Weitering and Nicky?

Genuine star players

Weitering ?

Decent full back, that’s about it.

 

[beerbandit]

Huh? Weitering would walk into the line up at any club.

As would De Goey and J Daics but they weren’t listed as ‘star’ players

Darcy Moore was down last season but is a multiple AA, so it’s laughable to include Weitering and not Moore.

 

[Robertio]

There are quite a few one time All-Australians running around

There are quite a few one time All-Australians running around

What's that got to do with it, you blokes hate talking about the now.

 

[Robertio]

As would De Goey and J Daics but they weren’t listed as ‘star’ players

Darcy Moore was down last season but is a multiple AA, so it’s laughable to include Weitering and not Moore.

Try focusing on 2024 mate, Weitering a class shead of Moore.

 

[Cyclops]

Try focusing on 2024 mate, Weitering a class shead of Moore.

Try focussing on 2025, where Moore goes in with superior exposed form to everyone but Cripps on your list.

Hate to admit it but Cripps has Moore covered for strength, leadership, one on one, maybe not aerial contests and intercepts, but frankly you could make a case he's close.

Beautiful specimen.

 

[Robertio]

Try focussing on 2025, where Moore goes in with superior exposed form to everyone but Cripps on your list.

Hate to admit it but Cripps has Moore covered for strength, leadership, one on one, maybe not aerial contests and intercepts, but frankly you could make a case he's close.

Beautiful specimen.

Superior exposed form from when? Moore is a good intercept defender but very average at defending.

 

[Cyclops]

Superior exposed form from when? Moore is a good intercept defender but very average at defending.

He's a better defender over his career than any current Blue. He's a better leader than any current Blue aside from Cripps.

Weitering has had one great season, and you rightly signed him up because those blokes are hard to find and Tassie will come knocking for everybody's stars, but also because your defensive stocks are so low.

Your best players are mid paced attacking mids and tall forwards. Weitering and Saad need help. We could use another tall defender, everyone could, but you need more defenders.

 

[JustaBattler]

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/massive-profit-loss-of-afl-funds-marks-carlton-s-return-as-an-afl-powerhouse-20241029-p5km8u.html

 

[Robertio]

He's a better defender over his career than any current Blue. He's a better leader than any current Blue aside from Cripps.

Weitering has had one great season, and you rightly signed him up because those blokes are hard to find and Tassie will come knocking for everybody's stars, but also because your defensive stocks are so low.

Your best players are mid paced attacking mids and tall forwards. Weitering and Saad need help. We could use another tall defender, everyone could, but you need more defenders.

Boyd, Cowan and Billy Wilson are good and young running backs, Young was our best player in our last game I'm sure they'll do something in the draft and other sources before next season.

 

[Cyclops]

Boyd, Cowan and Billy Wilson are good and young running backs, Young was our best player in our last game I'm sure they'll do something in the draft and other sources before next season.

It's good you're addressing this.

Pies traditionally start with an ironclad defence and try to add mids and forwards. This has been true from Matthews to MM to Bucks.

 

[Robertio]

It's good you're addressing this.

Pies traditionally start with an ironclad defence and try to add mids and forwards. This has been true from Matthews to MM to Bucks.

Murphy a big loss for you guys during the season.

 

[Fadge]

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/massive-profit-loss-of-afl-funds-marks-carlton-s-return-as-an-afl-powerhouse-20241029-p5km8u.html

Interesting flex that you're announcing a 'return' to being an off-field powerhouse as a result of now being bracketed with 4 other clubs (including Collingwood of course) as teams who receive the minimum additional funding from the AFL.

But to be a real powerhouse, like Collingwood, you need the on-field results to match...

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Interesting flex that you're announcing a 'return' to being an off-field powerhouse as a result of now being bracketed with 4 other clubs (including Collingwood of course) as teams who receive the minimum additional funding from the AFL.

But to be a real powerhouse, like Collingwood, you need the on-field results to match...

Only thing the Pies are a powerhouse at is losing Grand Finals

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Only thing the Pies are a powerhouse at is losing Grand Finals

Only thing the Blues are a powerhouse at is being disgracefully mediocre

 

[Bale Dup]

Interesting flex that you're announcing a 'return' to being an off-field powerhouse as a result of now being bracketed with 4 other clubs (including Collingwood of course) as teams who receive the minimum additional funding from the AFL.

But to be a real powerhouse, like Collingwood, you need the on-field results to match...

You finished 9th. Good on field result

On SM-G980F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Fadge]

You finished 9th. Good on field result...

Whilst your team won two games and finished 18th.

Yes, it is disappointing as a Collingwood supporter when our team doesn't contend for a premiership.

I guess whilst we do it most years, we can't expect to do it EVERY year.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

I guess whilst we do it most years, we can't expect to do it EVERY year.

I expect it every year, no excuses!!

 

[carlton_99]

The biggest thing I've learnt from this thread is how strong Collingwood fans obsession is with AA.

 

[carlton_99]

He's a better defender over his career than any current Blue.

Please stop. Murphy was literally a better defender than Moore.

 

[carlton_99]

Weitering has had one great season, and you rightly signed him up because those blokes are hard to find and Tassie will come knocking for everybody's stars, but also because your defensive stocks are so low.

Weitering one great season? Please you are frying my brain. The lack of awareness of other teams is astonishing

 

[Robertio]

Whilst your team won two games and finished 18th.

Yes, it is disappointing as a Collingwood supporter when our team doesn't contend for a premiership.

I guess whilst we do it most years, we can't expect to do it EVERY year.

What has 2018 got to do with it? You finished 9th in 2024.

 

[Fadge]

What has 2018 got to do with it?

I was referring to 2024.

Get with the program and look at who I was responding to.