Prediction Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Hawthorn

Who will be better in 2025

  • Hawthorn

    Votes: 102 68.9%
  • Carlton

    Votes: 46 31.1%

  • Total voters
    148

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Everyone’s had a good look at Hawthorns best now.
Don’t think they’ll jump teams as easily as they did this season.

Carlton if they stay reasonably healthy

Jump is a very ambiguous description. Is it the reason carlton hasn’t kicked on?

Or why you gave yourself an injury ‘out’?

In the narrow er loss hawks were missing Day Mackenzie - two of their most creative mids, and Blanck, Lewis, KPD and KPF first choice of fit
 
Jump is a very ambiguous description. Is it the reason carlton hasn’t kicked on?

Or why you gave yourself an injury ‘out’?

In the narrow er loss hawks were missing Day Mackenzie - two of their most creative mids, and Blanck, Lewis, KPD and KPF first choice of fit
Hasn't kicked on... Didn't we play off in a prelim a little over a year ago?

More than the Hawks have done lately
 
Is that the best thing Carlton’s done in 3 decades? Wow 👏
Well atm this great Hawks team is remembered mostly for their ability to post TikToks...

Not sure I'd be hedging my bets on a team who's head coach had a melt over Ken Hinkley telling Ginnivan to get on a plane home either. Arrogance and a victim mentality can often lead to a teams downfall.
 
Well atm this great Hawks team is remembered mostly for their ability to post TikToks...

Not sure I'd be hedging my bets on a team who's head coach had a melt over Ken Hinkley telling Ginnivan to get on a plane home either. Arrogance and a victim mentality can often lead to a teams downfall.
You mean the highest social engagement out of any sporting organisation in Australia

Seems like a good result and a winning final last year, what has Carlton achieved in the last 2 Decades?

Can't pay bills with 8th place finishes

Il take our recent history to achieve more than Carlton
 
You mean the highest social engagement out of any sporting organisation in Australia

Seems like a good result and a winning final last year, what has Carlton achieved in the last 2 Decades?

Can't pay bills with 8th place finishes

Il take our recent history to achieve more than Carlton
Tobey Maguire Lol GIF


Are we meant to give a stuff about this???
 
Yes... I'm sure the competition is living in fear of the 0 time All Australian midfield superstar that is Duke Newcombe.

I think a more terrifying prospect is that Clarence Oliver looks like he's finally off the cheeseburgers and gear, a player far better than Newcombe has ever been.

Thank Christ he didn't end up at Geelong.

I mean... I was speaking purely from a physical perspective (and with my tongue firmly in my cheek), but that's okay.
 
Tobey Maguire Lol GIF


Are we meant to give a stuff about this???

The kids love it.

The next generation of footy supporters.

From a financial perspective, it's actually fantastic news that the club could realistically envision a whole generation of kids growing up to be Hawthorn members.

Strictly talking business here.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Well atm this great Hawks team is remembered mostly for their ability to post TikToks...

Not sure I'd be hedging my bets on a team who's head coach had a melt over Ken Hinkley telling Ginnivan to get on a plane home either. Arrogance and a victim mentality can often lead to a teams downfall.
If stating that he wouldn’t be talking to Ken about his post game shenanigans is a melt then you’re the wicked witch of the west.
 
Well atm this great Hawks team is remembered mostly for their ability to post TikToks...

Not sure I'd be hedging my bets on a team who's head coach had a melt over Ken Hinkley telling Ginnivan to get on a plane home either. Arrogance and a victim mentality can often lead to a teams downfall.

Not this shit again. Come 2026 it will be a memory just like Kenny
 
Carlton's last 25 years in a nutshell
Absolutely agree. We are pretty well experts on the matter and thus I feel qualified as a fan to tell others when they're doing the same.

Hawks arrogance both as a team and from supporters far surpassed what they achieved on field last year. Sam Mitchell demanding Ken Hinkley 'act his age' and that it was 'very disappointing' was the epitome of irony.

This is the same bloke who pretended to jab up his arm against Essendon as a player :tearsofjoy:

I don't think that mentality will bode well for the Hawks, getting ahead of themselves as its colloquially phrased. Will result in them missing the 8 imo.
 
You know as well as I do that is not all he said.
What else did he say that constitutes a melt?
That a senior couch should know better than to goad a 21 year old after the siren?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Prediction Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Hawthorn

Back
Top