data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a5231/a5231939c4f0413c8d184aeb0f34bf4cd20fc4b5" alt=""
- Mar 25, 2019
- 14,917
- 30,320
- AFL Club
- Carlton
3-5 years ago?? Lmao wtf are you on? His 2022 & 2023 were fantastic, had an injury ravaged 2024.LOL
Hardwick is in his prime now.
Saad was in his prime 3-5 years ago.
He's literally never been the form player outside a year where Saad was wiped out by injury for a large chunk of it...Clearly Hardwick the form player heading into 2025
Finishing high in a BnF of a crap team doesn't mean squat. Saad finished 6th in 2022, a year he was put in the AA squad... Are you telling me Hardwick had a better season?Hardwick again clearly consistently better in recent times.
DelusionalOne player dropping off, it happens when you get to 30.
Yeah, Saad used to be good...he ain't been at that level for a couple of years.
Heading into 2025, you either take the bloke in his prime playing the better recent footy (Hardwick) or a 31 year old who was good when at Essendon before COVID.