Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Scritchyscroony]

There's a chance we retain TDK and get SDK

Love your optimism Worm. But. Why would any player want to go from a powerhouse successful club like Geelong to loserville? It's not like Carlton can match the cheap land deals down Geelong way.
Also, With what currency and cap space? You traded out next year's first.

 

[Worm4]

Awesome.

We've heard of Pies supporters on this thread who have seen 11.

But the facts are, nearly half the population of Australia haven't been alive for a Carlton Premiership, and that number is increasing by the year....

And it's been glorious.

There are supporters in this thread who have seen 11 ? Bullshit

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Why exactly would TDK, who grew up supporting the Blues and has never had a bad thing to say about the club 'no longer want to be there'?

Because he wants the chance to win a premiership.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Love your optimism Worm. But. Why would any player want to go from a powerhouse successful club like Geelong to loserville? It's not like Carlton can match the cheap land deals down Geelong way.
Also, With what currency and cap space? You traded out next year's first.

We'd have the cap space, highly doubt we'd have the draft picks though.

 

[Worm4]

Love your optimism Worm. But. Why would any player want to go from a powerhouse successful club like Geelong to loserville? It's not like Carlton can match the cheap land deals down Geelong way.
Also, With what currency and cap space? You traded out next year's first.

Collingwood have traded out their first as well, but for some reason you guys think that Petracca will land on your doorstep. We don't need a first rounders next year - we have a father son hopping on board..
BTW- owning property in Geelong 45 monster down the road from Melbourne is not that big a deal

 

[Worm4]

What?

Walsh wouldn't be expected to go with Daicos when the ball's in Collingwood's forward line and he's accountable for him?

Long live that Carlton game plan!

Collingwoods game plan didn't get them too far last season did it ?

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Collingwood have traded out their first as well, but for some reason you guys think that Petracca will land on your doorstep. We don't need a first rounders next year - we have a father son hopping on board..
BTW- owning property in Geelong 45 monster down the road from Melbourne is not that big a deal

Prime farmland and beachfront properties on the surf coast obviously has its appeal though Wormy.

 

[Robertio]

What's the 'current status'?

That we were both a fair way off it in 2024, but with Collingwood finishing the season stronger than Carlton, and winning both games against Carlton.

On the back of Collingwood contending for the flag in the prior two seasons, compared to Carlton who didn't.

And finally, Collingwood have objectively improved their list in the off season, compared to Carlton who didn't.

THAT 'current status'?

Most Carlton supporters will be unhappy with our form this year and this century, we are a well balanced supporter base, we don't need to be told 30 times a day by a bunch of immature high schoolers.

 

[Worm4]

Prime farmland and beachfront properties on the surf coast obviously has its appeal though Wormy.

Cripps owns property in WA - doesn't mean he is leaving to play there.
A close friend of mine, who played AFL at essendon owns 4 properties - 2 on the coast, 2 in Melbourne- he never left. Owning property in the bellarine isn't the carrot that you think it is

 

[Robertio]

Because he wants the chance to win a premiership.

No chance TDK leaves Carlton, more chance of Daicos joining Carlton once the pensioners retire claiming he once supported the Blues.

 

[Worm4]

What's the 'current status'?

That we were both a fair way off it in 2024, but with Collingwood finishing the season stronger than Carlton, and winning both games against Carlton.

Collingwood were 3rd on the ladder round 14 and finished 9th .
Hardly a position of strength
You can't make this shit up

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Prime farmland and beachfront properties on the surf coast obviously has its appeal though Wormy.

I'm tipping our coterie groups can offer him better if it comes down to property deals.

He already goes surfing every other day because unlike pea heart Ollie Henry, he isn't fussed driving an hour down the highway.

Will be on big coin on his next contract playing for the team he grew up supporting.

 

[JustaBattler]

When people are on the back foot on a sticky turning wicket - they tend to fumble around loose wristed and come up with floppy attempts to make contact with the reality of the ball.

The reality is Collingwood collpased in 2024 with less exciuse than Carlton.

Fudgee sticks to hsi line of Carlton list having gone bacckwards- because no Owies - which has ot be one of the greatest reaches ever posted - and suggesting that walking away from Houston whop was begging to come to Carlton was a big miss - exrends the reach to Mr gadget proportions.

very funny reading.

One thing is sfor sure- I'd liek to be on the other side of ANY trade with Fudgey - that would be an easy pension.

 

[JustaBattler]

Prime farmland and beachfront properties on the surf coast obviously has its appeal though Wormy.

Have a look at yyourself hoping for a player from Carlton to leave - to elevate your bunch of no hopers - that is hwo far you have already fallen - long way to go before you bottomn out - that will be fun to watch for years to come.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Have a look at yyourself hoping for a player from Carlton to leave - to elevate your bunch of no hopers - that is hwo far you have already fallen - long way to go before you bottomn out - that will be fun to watch for years to come.

TDK going to Geelong ain't gonna elevate Collingwood any.
It will however produce an abundance of priceless melts from Carlton posters .

Geelong are way more of a flag threat than Carlton and I hate to see them get even better, but it'd still be worth it for the Carlton melts.

 

[Worm4]

When people are on the back foot on a sticky turning wicket - they tend to fumble around loose wristed and come up with floppy attempts to make contact with the reality of the ball.

The reality is Collingwood collpased in 2024 with less exciuse than Carlton.

Fudgee sticks to hsi line of Carlton list having gone bacckwards- because no Owies - which has ot be one of the greatest reaches ever posted - and suggesting that walking away from Houston whop was begging to come to Carlton was a big miss - exrends the reach to Mr gadget proportions.

very funny reading.

One thing is sfor sure- I'd liek to be on the other side of ANY trade with Fudgey - that would be an easy pension.

He has McStay higher rated than Curnow not to mention Mckay outside top 100 .

 

[Worm4]

TDK going to Geelong ain't gonna elevate Collingwood any.
It will however produce an abundance of priceless melts from Carlton posters .

Geelong are way more of a flag threat than Carlton and I hate to see them get even better, but it'd still be worth it for the Carlton melts.

We beat them by 11 goals during the year. Lol

 

[Scritchyscroony]

We beat them by 11 goals during the year. Lol

Wow... Congratulations. We will add that to the best of Carlton in the 21st Century highlights VHS tape.
Shame that subsequently Geelong made a prelim while Carlton went Owen 60.

 

[JustaBattler]

TDK going to Geelong ain't gonna elevate Collingwood any.
It will however produce an abundance of priceless melts from Carlton posters .

Geelong are way more of a flag threat than Carlton and I hate to see them get even better, but it'd still be worth it for the Carlton melts.

Look if you want Mr Pussy Willow to come in and gie you a needed reach around- just flash the pussy lights up into the sky.

Here listen up - Carlton supproters actually DONT CARE who Collingwood sign - it wont make any differene to the balance - keep avoiding investng in the draft please - throw the palace in richmond at Petracca- PLEASE..

as for TDK do you ctualy have a clue where he grew up and who he has grown up playing with 0 including his younger brother ?

Good luck Geelong is all I am gunna say - keep bringiung in the fancy pantsers wif nice long hair and instagram influence with powdwry nose fetishes - that their future - back to the past - same as yours.

 

[Worm4]

Wow... Congratulations. We will add that to the best of Carlton in the 21st Century highlights VHS tape.
Shame that subsequently Geelong made a prelim while Carlton went Owen 60.

Meanwhile, 15000 kms away in mexico.....

 

[Arr0w]

The difference between the 2 sides this year wasn't the double up games

It was the Pies inability to get the W against the Dockers, Bombers and Suns

All sides we beat, all lower on the ladder

Oh well

 

[Fadge]

Why exactly would TDK, who grew up supporting the Blues and has never had a bad thing to say about the club 'no longer want to be there'?

Maybe he might head elsewhere in search of team success in his peak years?

 

[Arr0w]

Maybe he might head elsewhere in search of team success in his peak years?

Rules out the Pies then

 

[Fadge]

If the games level with a minute to go and ur team is about to take possession of the ball, you're sagging off ur man and getting into position to be an outlet. That's footy 101 Fudge.

Not going to try explaining it any further to someone who's clearly never played higher than division 8 ressies football.

Not when the ball's in your backline, and you're accountable for the most dangerous player in the game.

But as I said, if Carlton are happy with that decision, I'm all for it as a Collingwood supporter...

 

[Fadge]

Most Carlton supporters will be unhappy with our form this year and this century, we are a well balanced supporter base, we don't need to be told 30 times a day by a bunch of immature high schoolers.

You're the one who asked about 'current status', I simply answered your question...