Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Arr0w]

personal attack, classy

Not a personal attack, no name calling, he was only being factual as to your posting history

Unless troll posting on our board after a Bombers win, was purely a complete accident

 

[Robertio]

Not a personal attack, no name calling, he was only being factual as to your posting history

Unless troll posting on our board after a Bombers win, was purely a complete accident

He's trolling now, one day he'll grow up.

 

[King Tut]

Haven't the pies lost to the Eagles in recent times? Bwahwahwahwah

In 2022. Yet you couldn’t beat us that year (in fact we ended your season and booted you on your arse out of finals in that great final round humiliation of you) in two tries.

West Coast >>>Carlton clearly.

 

[Fadge]

Yet somehow, Collingwood lost to West Coast during this time line, a game West Coast played away as well. Oh dear....

And yet still, in that season (2022), Collingwood finished higher and got closer to a premiership than Carlton have since the turn of the century.

But happy to focus the discussion on head to head matches if that's where you want to take it...

 

[Corn Cobbers]

And yet still, in that season (2022), Collingwood finished higher and got closer to a premiership than Carlton have since the turn of the century.

But happy to focus the discussion on head to head matches if that's where you want to take it...

Imagine bringing up 2022, why would they do that?

Look at poor Woof in the background, gutted



On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Fadge]

8 wins & 62 losses the past 3 years?

Yeah, nah we've never been that bad.

Try again.

Oh no.

When you've referenced 70 games in total across 3 seasons for West Coast, it clearly needs a fact check.

West Coast over the past 3 years have won 10 games, and lost 58. 14.7% win rate.

Carlton between 2002 and 2003 - 7 wins, 37 losses at a win rate of 15.9%

Carlton between 2005 and 2007 - 11 wins, 2 draws, 53 losses at a win rate of 17.2%

Carlton between 2014 and 2021 - 48 wins, 108 losses at a win rate of 30.7%

So Carlton's win rate for given years has been marginally higher, but Carlton have done it for much longer.

Carlton supporters trying to punch down on West Coast for their performances over the past 3 seasons = deluded.

 

[Arr0w]

And in that same season

 

[Fadge]

And in that same season

View attachment 2186292View attachment 2186293

We don't see pictures like that of Carlton players because those types of reactions are borne from the expectation of going better than they did.

Carlton avoid expectation.

 

[Forward Press]

How about 2024 ? We've been shit, but not West Coke shit. Run along chappy

"At least we're not as shit as West Coast 2024" is not the flex you think it is.

 

[Robertio]

isn't this what narcissist do?

rile people up then complain when they get called out for it...

lets stick to the topic at hand, yeah?


Carlton should be better than Collingwood, the top end talent is probably better than Carlton but the depth the Pies have is better than

I beg to differ, Carlton does have some decent young talent while the Pies have tried theirs and none of them have come, Daicos aside.

 

[Yoda_]

I beg to differ, Carlton does have some decent young talent while the Pies have tried theirs and none of them have come, Daicos aside.

talent wasn't the issue, it was the depth the Blues lacked.

 

[CarmenSandiego]

Oh no.

When you've referenced 70 games in total across 3 seasons for West Coast, it clearly needs a fact check.

West Coast over the past 3 years have won 10 games, and lost 58. 14.7% win rate.

Carlton between 2002 and 2003 - 7 wins, 37 losses at a win rate of 15.9%

Carlton between 2005 and 2007 - 11 wins, 2 draws, 53 losses at a win rate of 17.2%

Carlton between 2014 and 2021 - 48 wins, 108 losses at a win rate of 30.7%

So Carlton's win rate for given years has been marginally higher, but Carlton have done it for much longer.

Carlton supporters trying to punch down on West Coast for their performances over the past 3 seasons = deluded.

So, West Coasts 14.7% win rate the past 3 years is worse than anything Carlton has produced since the turn of the century?

Thanks for proving my point.

Scary thing is they haven't even hit their bottom yet. Top 10 of their BnF has an average and median age of 28.

 

[Worm4]

And yet still, in that season (2022), Collingwood finished higher and got closer to a premiership than Carlton have since the turn of the century.

But happy to focus the discussion on head to head matches if that's where you want to take it...

I was actually in conversation with another poster until you decided to derail the said conversation

 

[Robertio]

talent wasn't the issue, it was the depth the Blues lacked.

We won a lot of games last season without our best 22 so i beg to differ again.

 

[Pistol Night]

So the Blues have finished arguing with Pies supporters and are taking down every other campaigner in the comp now too. Inspirational

 

[Worm4]

"At least we're not as shit as West Coast 2024" is not the flex you think it is.

What is your point of being in this thread exactly?

 

[Worm4]

Oh no.

When you've referenced 70 games in total across 3 seasons for West Coast, it clearly needs a fact check.

West Coast over the past 3 years have won 10 games, and lost 58. 14.7% win rate.

Carlton between 2002 and 2003 - 7 wins, 37 losses at a win rate of 15.9%

Carlton between 2005 and 2007 - 11 wins, 2 draws, 53 losses at a win rate of 17.2%

Carlton between 2014 and 2021 - 48 wins, 108 losses at a win rate of 30.7%

So Carlton's win rate for given years has been marginally higher, but Carlton have done it for much longer.

Carlton supporters trying to punch down on West Coast for their performances over the past 3 seasons = deluded.

Ummm, West Coast poster punching down on Carlton initially Fadge. I guess you need more allies in here given your train wreck 2024 season

 

[Yoda_]

We won a lot of games last season without our best 22 so i beg to differ again.

think the stats have been posted in one version of this thread but the majority of your top end played the majority of this year.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Oh no.

When you've referenced 70 games in total across 3 seasons for West Coast, it clearly needs a fact check.

West Coast over the past 3 years have won 10 games, and lost 58. 14.7% win rate.

Carlton between 2002 and 2003 - 7 wins, 37 losses at a win rate of 15.9%

Carlton between 2005 and 2007 - 11 wins, 2 draws, 53 losses at a win rate of 17.2%

Carlton between 2014 and 2021 - 48 wins, 108 losses at a win rate of 30.7%

So Carlton's win rate for given years has been marginally higher, but Carlton have done it for much longer.

Carlton supporters trying to punch down on West Coast for their performances over the past 3 seasons = deluded.

It's irrelevant anyway. It's all about the spoons.
Carlton are the spoon champions.
End of...

 

[Fadge]

What is your point of being in this thread exactly?

It is a thread on the Main Board.

All supporters are very welcome.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Ummm, West Coast poster punching down on Carlton initially Fadge. I guess you need more allies in here given your train wreck 2024 season

Everyone punches down on Carlton these days Worm. Even StKilda fans.

 

[Robertio]

think the stats have been posted in one version of this thread but the majority of your top end played the majority of this year.

Have you seen the official injury stats mate, only Richmond had more but you keep taking notice of these Pie supporters mate and you'll do well in life.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Everyone punches down on Carlton these days Worm. Even StKilda fans.

Yep the worm has turned, the punchers are now the punchees

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[CarmenSandiego]

think the stats have been posted in one version of this thread but the majority of your top end played the majority of this year.

Lol, skewed stats from Fadge who does mental gymnastics to try and prove that our 'top 15' (chosen by him) were always available.

Of our top 10 BnF from 2023 & games missed in 2024.

Weitering - Missed R0 against the eventual Premiers
Newman - played every game
Curnow - played hurt since the GWS game & missed end of year + EF vs eventual Premiers
Cerra - missed 10 games
Cripps - played every game
Acres - played every game, plenty under duress
Dochery - missed all season
Saad - missed 5 games
Walsh - missed 3 games & was a cripple for most of the year
McGovern - missed 5 games

Given the evenness of 2024 & how important every game was, how the **** does the above equate to our top end being available for the majority of the year?

 

[Robertio]

Everyone punches down on Carlton these days Worm. Even StKilda fans.

Saints haven't won a flag since 1966 or something and have 15 less premierships than us, any other dumb statements for us mate.