Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[doppleganger]

If the Blues arent better in 2025 it will be another epic failure of a season.

Pretty much this.

They have been building since SOS took over with the rebuild they had to have.

2025 will be Weitering, Curnow, McKay's 10th season for the Blues. They will be 27/28 in 2025. If they are ever going to have a top 4 finish surely 2025 is the season.

Even the "young stars" Cerra, TDK and Walsh, they are 25/26 next year.

 

[Robertio]

Pretty much this.

They have been building since SOS took over with the rebuild they had to have.

2025 will be Weitering, Curnow, McKay's 10th season for the Blues. They will be 27/28 in 2025. If they are ever going to have a top 4 finish surely 2025 is the season.

Even the "young stars" Cerra, TDK and Walsh, they are 25/26 next year.

A Pie supporter talking about age, must be cod season again.

 

[doppleganger]

A Pie supporter talking about age, must be cod season again.

Yeah not much point trying to talk about 2025 lists in this thread.

Just let the boring Bagger fans continue to blab on posting about lifetime flags and vivid memories.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Pretty much this.

They have been building since SOS took over with the rebuild they had to have.

2025 will be Weitering, Curnow, McKay's 10th season for the Blues. They will be 27/28 in 2025. If they are ever going to have a top 4 finish surely 2025 is the season.

Even the "young stars" Cerra, TDK and Walsh, they are 25/26 next year.

Bloos are the 6th oldest list. Anything but top 4 and prelim would be a big failure in 2025. Pressure will be huge for them to perform and we know they don't like pressure.
If they miss the 8 then Voss is gone.

 

[Fadge]

Yeah not much point trying to talk about 2025 lists in this thread.

Just let the boring Bagger fans continue to blab on posting about lifetime flags and vivid memories.

All you can do is try, mate....

 

[Arr0w]

Yeah not much point trying to talk about 2025 lists in this thread.

Just let the boring Bagger fans continue to blab on posting about lifetime flags and vivid memories.

Another deflection, fancy thinking the likes of Weitering, Charlie, Harry need to capitalise on a flag, given the age of recent premiers

Then cutting and pasting your 2022 "analysis" regarding SOS's list management and why we won't play finals

 

[Fadge]

Just let the boring Bagger fans continue to blab on LYING about lifetime flags and vivid memories.

EFA

 

[Arr0w]

8 to 3, Carlton better in 2024, better since WWII

Then the lying about who placed what wager, a real face plant, thinking it was a gotcha moment

Oh boy

 

[Fadge]

Another deflection, fancy thinking the likes of Weitering, Charlie, Harry need to capitalise on a flag, given the age of recent premiers

Yeah, let's not do everything we can to build a premiership contending list when Cripps is 30, and Weitering, Charlie and Harry are 27.

Let's target for 3 years down the track when their respective ages are 33, 30, 30 and 30 respectively...

 

[Arr0w]

Yeah, let's not do everything we can to build a premiership contending list when Cripps is 30, and Weitering, Charlie and Harry are 27.

Let's target for 3 years down the track when their respective ages are 33, 30, 30 and 30 respectively...

You really a fantasy script writer

 

[Fadge]

better since WWII

What's everyone's favourite period of Carlton being better than Collingwood since World War 2?

Mine is the 24 year period since the turn of the century, when we've seen:
Premierships: Pies 2, Blues 0
Grand Finals: Pies 6, Blues 0
Top 4 finishes: Pies 10, Blues 0
Wooden Spoons: Pies 0, Blues 5

 

[Fadge]

Then the lying about who placed what wager, a real face plant, thinking it was a gotcha moment

Not my problem that your comprehension skills are non-existent.

 

[Arr0w]

What's everyone's favourite period of Carlton being better than Collingwood since World War 2?

Mine is the 24 year period since the turn of the century, when we've seen:
Premierships: Pies 2, Blues 0
Grand Finals: Pies 6, Blues 0
Top 4 finishes: Pies 10, Blues 0
Wooden Spoons: Pies 0, Blues 5

10 to 5, the whole period

Oh well

 

[Arr0w]

Not my problem that your comprehension skills are non-existent.

And now the lying back tracking, and questioning someone's comprehension

Get help

 

[Fadge]

10 to 5, the whole period

Oh well

Tell us more about how much you've enjoyed the 21st century - which is a pretty significant subset of that 'whole period'. What have been your top 5 highlights as a Carlton supporter?

 

[Fadge]

And now the lying back tracking, and questioning someone's comprehension

Get help

The biggest liar on the forum desperately deflecting in an attempt to call someone else a liar, when the back and forth is there for all to see...

 

[Fadge]

Nominations for Carlton's highlights of the 21st century?

Their backs to the wall win as underdogs against 16th placed West Coast (who were playing a dead rubber) in round 23, 2024, to secure their second consecutive finals position.

Their Elimination Final win against Richmond in 2013, from 9th...

 

[Worm4]

Nah... After this year we will be going the draft route heavily for the next 2-3 years.

Not if Petracca nominates

 

[doppleganger]

Bloos are the 6th oldest list. Anything but top 4 and prelim would be a big failure in 2025. Pressure will be huge for them to perform and we know they don't like pressure.
If they miss the 8 then Voss is gone.

Agree.

Pies in same boat, would have top 4 as the pass mark for 2025.

If we don't make it, think Fly is safe as he already has a flag and a couple of top 4 finishes to give him a bit of security.

 

[Morro]

Pretty much this.

They have been building since SOS took over with the rebuild they had to have.

2025 will be Weitering, Curnow, McKay's 10th season for the Blues. They will be 27/28 in 2025. If they are ever going to have a top 4 finish surely 2025 is the season.

Even the "young stars" Cerra, TDK and Walsh, they are 25/26 next year.

If there was a reasonable Blues fan on gods green earth, they would not argue with this one bit.

 

[Arr0w]

Tell us more about how much you've enjoyed the 21st century - which is a pretty significant subset of that 'whole period'. What have been your top 5 highlights as a Carlton supporter?

10 to 5 since WWII, 8 to 3 last 60 odd years, glorious

 

[Arr0w]

The biggest liar on the forum desperately deflecting in an attempt to call someone else a liar, when the back and forth is there for all to see...

Banter - Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Pie supporters bring up the past, that little tiny window, yet sook if people take it back further Some say that would be hypothetical Pretty sure you meant hypocritical. Anyway.. now you're posting about posts posting about the past. If Fadge is our actuarial numbers genius. You are our...

www.bigfooty.com

Facts

Ouch, another failed gotcha moment

 

[Fadge]

Banter - Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Pie supporters bring up the past, that little tiny window, yet sook if people take it back further Some say that would be hypothetical Pretty sure you meant hypocritical. Anyway.. now you're posting about posts posting about the past. If Fadge is our actuarial numbers genius. You are our...

www.bigfooty.com

Facts

Ouch, another failed gotcha moment

I repeat...

Not my fault your comprehension skills are non existent, and my comment was not literal but instead using a hypothetical scenario to reference your lack of knowledge re: lay bets...

But do keep displaying your stupidity by doubling, tripling and quadrupling down on it.

Take note of the first paragraph - that is the correct usage of the word 'hypothetical'...

 

[Arr0w]

I repeat...

Not my fault your comprehension skills are non existent, and my comment was not literal but instead using a hypothetical scenario to reference your lack of knowledge re: lay bets...

But do keep displaying your stupidity by doubling, tripling and quadrupling down on it.

Lying lightweight, I placed the bet?

Then you will sook up that you are bring stalked, after you falsify the facts and challenged

Get help

 

[Arr0w]

Okay, back to more facts, Carlton better in 2024 and over 80 years