Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Arr0w]

Oh, that's right.

Because 'everything will be different next year'...

Yes, yes, each team will finish where they did last year and every single player will have the exact same output

 

[Worm4]

Yes, yes, each team will finish where they did last year and every single player will have the exact same output

Don't think he understands that output changes constantly thus results will differ. Do they have remedial classes for that ?

 

[OnceWeWereKings]

Absolutely nothing in the post was new information to me, hence there was no need for me to do anything other than:

A) Correct the omission of Lipinski's 6th place finish in the 2022 Copeland, and
B) Repeat my conclusion that they are both C Graders going into 2025.

Quite simply, maybe I'm a harsher marker than many others. Players I consider B Graders are:
Josh Daicos (pushing into A Grader status)
Brayden Maynard (perennial top 5 Copeland finisher and proven finals performer)
Jack Crisp (dual best and fairest and proven finals player)

They are behind Collingwood's A Graders - N. Daicos, D. Moore (though was down from this level in 2024), D. Houston, J. De Goey.

You rate them harsher?
Then state JDG is an A grader…….
You’re taking the piss surely?
When?
When has he ever produced a season that would have him considered an A grader?
2018? Coming up for 7 seasons ago……
He’s the Kyrgios of the AFL, talented yet consistently underperformed. As a commentator stated years ago, all sizzle no sausage.
JDG isn’t an A graders cornhole.

 

[JustaBattler]

Oh, that's right.

Because 'everything will be different next year'...

abcd efg

bragging now about having learned some of the alphabet?