Worst 10 Players in the AFL

[bellzy]

chris judd.

Crap

You get my vote for originality...

 

[Oh When the Saints]

Not a fan of big men?

I could go places with that ...

But I'll stay on topic.


Wiggins from Carlton = 8 years on an AFL list at a poorly performing club and only 81 games ... did not have more than 15 disposals in his first 5 years at the club.

Charlie Gardiner = 51 games at CHF and he's never kicked more than 2 goals in a game.

Brad Miller would have to be another nomination.


Saddington had some very good years with the Swans ... he's crap now, but he was a good player.

 

[Mancey]

Dean Solomon is giving it a shake.

 

[Casey]

I'll have a crack at it. No particular order.
6. Rowan Jones

Thats crap... Hes just a bad shot on goal

 

[rocker_oz33]

He's not playing in the AFL this year.

hes not playing AFL at all he hung up he boots last year

 

[wells is god]

1. Mark Bolton
2. Kepler Bradley
3. Cain Ackland
4. Jason Blake
5. Zac Dawson
6. Ben Matthews
7. Dylan McLaren
8. Jason Saddington
9. Jason Laycock
10. Daniel Jackson

Best effort i've seen to date.

 

[juddy_Like]

Best effort i've seen to date.

Thank You. I studied for hours.

But to the bloke who said i dont like Carlton. Well i dont mind Carlton, i think there going places. But there recycling policy is why they are so sh1thouse. Hackland, Saddo, etc, etc = Rubbish

 

[HBK619]

Heres mine, no particular order:

1.Mark Bolton
2.Kepler Bradley
3.Zac Dawson
4.Greg Tivendale
5.Josh Kennedy(Carlton)
6.Chris Egan
7.Charlie Gardiner
8.Ben Dixon
9.Simon Wiggins
10.Jason Blake(Ruckman at 189cm, WTF!!!)

 

[saintsownthedome]

Rowan Jones would like to refer you to his 2006 Premiership Medal and asks you to kindly form a line to suck his balls.

Magic Reply

 

[saintsownthedome]

Stephen Baker
Kane Johnson
Jordan Russell
Rowan Jones
Chris Egan
Michael Doughty
Jared Crouch
Mark Jamar

Steven Baker = most hated for opposition supporters, I'll give you that, but thw worst player ?

Put him in any team, and he's a gun. Week in, week out - does his job. One of the only blokes in the league who can say that over his career he is going 50/50 or better with the best player in the comp (Juddy)

 

[UpForGrabs]

Had you asked me this last year, my answer probably would have been "Leon Davis, 1-10". However, after a few good performances, I'm going out on a limb and say that 'Neon' has slipped to 11th place.

 

[BurnleyBomber]

I can't no one has said Henry Playfair. Dear god when is he supposed to show something? I know he's had a bad run with shoulder injuries but come on, he's as useful as a penis on a steamroller.

I'm not bashing Geelong but two Essendon rejects also come to mind, Joel Reynolds and Sam Hunt. I do admit that Reynolds was played out of position at Essendon, he should played predominately up forward. Still, wasted talent.

Cameron Wight isn't as useless as most people think, he played pretty well against Collingwood. He played as tagger I think. I don't have any fact to back this up so maybe a Doggies fan can help me out here.

 

[kangamike]

1. Shannon Watt
2. Shannon Watt
3. Shannon Watt
4. Shannon Watt
5. Shannon Watt
6. Shannon Watt
7. Shannon Watt
8. Shannon Watt
9. Shannon Watt
10. Shannon Watt

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Stupid thread, how many games have you played?

How many times have you played at the SCG?

 

[ARDENSTREETforever]

#1 on the list: Shannon Watt (Nth Melb)

 

[UpForGrabs]

Suprised Lewis 'Lurch' Roberts-Thompson hasn't gotten a gig yet...

Probably saving him is the fact that his best game was the 2005 GF. Damn Sydney!!

 

[Toshowyouwhy]

Yeh lrt is rubbish. Hansen smashed him last GF

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Dreadful thread.

This should be closed or at least moved to Bay 13.

 

[greenlight]

ben holland
kepler bradley
mark bolton
patrick bowden
robert lewis thompson
jarryd brennan
daniel merrett
courtney johns
sam power
brodie holland(wap)

 

[Austin_McCrabbs]

I can't no one has said Henry Playfair. Dear god when is he supposed to show something? I know he's had a bad run with shoulder injuries but come on, he's as useful as a penis on a steamroller.

I'm not bashing Geelong but two Essendon rejects also come to mind, Joel Reynolds and Sam Hunt. I do admit that Reynolds was played out of position at Essendon, he should played predominately up forward. Still, wasted talent.

Cameron Wight isn't as useless as most people think, he played pretty well against Collingwood. He played as tagger I think. I don't have any fact to back this up so maybe a Doggies fan can help me out here.

Exactly. Charlie Gardiner has been mentioned numerous times but Henry is so poor and obscure he has escaped the attention of most.

 

[notting18]

ben holland
kepler bradley
mark bolton
patrick bowden
robert lewis thompson
jarryd brennan
daniel merrett
courtney johns
sam power
brodie holland(wap)

Merrett is holding down FB in his first season down there quite well! would be in top 100 players IMO

 

[Hobdog]

Roberts-Thompson from Sydney is an absolute shocker. I know someone will fly back at me with bulldogs players names and I don't care because I know there is not a player on the bulldogs list that is even remotely as bad as Roberts-Thompson. Is he related to Paul Roos? How else could you explain him getting a game in a side that has played in the last 2 GF's?? Nothing personal louie, it's not your fault they keep picking you in the side.

 

[footyfan_25]

Richo when he isn't in form is possibly the worst player ever

So you missed the 7 clangers by your boy Lucas last week did you

 

[Bazzar]

Merrett is holding down FB in his first season down there quite well! would be in top 100 players IMO

I agree. He has been one of the biggest improvers in the comp this year. Hard work has paid off. Good on him

 

[chickens_law]

Prestiagiacomo
Watt
Bolton
Dawson
Bizzel
Reynolds
Gardiner
Mclaren