Wizard
Brownlow Medallist
Number 2 1961 said:
Oh for ******** sake you can't really rate Kosi, Deledio, Wilson, Scott and Pickett above Haselby can you?
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 7 - Pride Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
worst player to win the rising star?
- Thread starter ndot
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Oh for ******** sake you can't really rate Kosi, Deledio, Wilson, Scott and Pickett above Haselby can you?
Bartram_Class
Brownlow Medallist
I do.wizard_9 said:
Jared Rivers
Wizard
Brownlow Medallist
Yze_Class said:
Well you do not have much idea about the game than do you.
- Thread starter
- #32
how about best and worst to be nominated since 2002
2005
Rd 1 - Kepler Bradley (Essendon)
Rd 2 - Shannon Byrnes (Geelong)
Rd 3 - Brock McLean (Melbourne)
Rd 4 - Lance Franklin (Hawthorn)
Rd 5 - Jason Laycock (Essendon)
Rd 6 - Justin Sherman (Brisbane Lions)
Rd 7 - Will Minson (Western Bulldogs)
Rd 8 - Brett Deledio(Richmond)
Rd 9 - Colin Sylvia (Melbourne)
Rd 10 - Travis Cloke (Collingwood)
Rd 11 - Jordan Lewis (Hawthorn)
Rd 12 - Jed Adcock (Brisbane Lions)
Rd 13 - Ryan Griffen (Western Bulldogs)
Rd 14 - David Mundy (Fremantle)
Rd 15 - Troy Selwood (Brisbane Lions)
Rd 16 - Adam Selwood (West Coast Eagles)
Rd 17 - Anthony Corrie (Brisbane Lions)
Rd 18 - Kade Simpson (Carlton)
Rd 19 - Jarryd Roughead (Hawthorn)
Rd 20 - Adam Bentick (Carlton)
Rd 21 - Nathan Ablett (Geelong)
Rd 22 - Raphael Clarke (St Kilda)
2004
Jared Rivers (Melbourne)
Brent Hartigan (Richmond)
Adam Cooney(Western Bulldogs)
Brent Stanton (Essendon)
Daniel Cross (Western Bulldogs)
Beau Walters (West Coast Eagles)
Sam Butler (West Coast Eagles)
Brent Reilly (Adelaide)
Mark Seaby (West Coast)
Jay Schulz (Richmond)
Karl Norman (Carlton)
Richard Hadley (Brisbane Lions)
Brett Ebert (Port Adelaide)
Brent Moloney (Geelong)
Guy Richards (Collingwood)
Andrew Mackie (Geelong)
Brent Staker (West Coast Eagles)
Kane Tenace (Geelong)
Andrew Walker (Carlton)
Paul Bevan (Sydney)
Jared Rivers (Melbourne)
Michael Firrito (Kangaroos)
Aaron Davey (Melbourne)
2003
Ashley McGrath (Brisbane) / Matthew Lokan (Collingwood)
Andrew McDougall (West Coast Eagles)
Leigh Montagna (St Kilda)
Marc Bullen (Essendon)
Lewis Roberts-Thomson (Sydney)
Richard Cole (Collingwood)
Daniel Motlop (Kangaroos)
Ted Richards (Essendon)
Aaron Sandilands (Fremantle)
Byron Schammer (Fremantle)
Brad Fisher (Carlton)
Daniel Wells (Kangaroos)
Jarrad Waite (Carlton)
Graham Polak (Fremantle)
Ashley Sampi (West Coast Eages)
Brendon Goddard (St Kilda)
Michael Osborne (Hawthorn)
Adam Schneider (Sydney)
Jared Brennan (Brisbane Lions)
Trent Sporn (Carlton)
Luke Ball (St Kilda)
Sam Mitchell (Hawthorn)
2002
Paul Medhurst (Fremantle)
Chris Judd (West Coast Eagles)
Steven Armstrong (Melbourne)
James Bartel (Geelong)
Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda)
Jason Cloke (Collingwood)
Xavier Clarke (St Kilda)
David Rodan (Richmond)
Shane Birss (Western Bulldogs)
Mark McGough (Collingwood)
Ryan Hargrave (Western Bulldogs)
James Kelly (Geelong)
Shaun Burgoyne (Port Adelaide)
Mark Coughlan (Richmond)
Luke Hodge (Hawthorn)
Alan Didak (Collingwood)
Nick Ries (Hawthorn)
Jordan McMahon (Western Bulldogs)
Tadhg Kennelly (Sydney)
Ty Zantuck (Richmond)
Jamie Charman (Brisbane Lions)
Campbell Brown (Hawthorn)
best: chris judd
worst: mark mcgough (lol)
2005
Rd 1 - Kepler Bradley (Essendon)
Rd 2 - Shannon Byrnes (Geelong)
Rd 3 - Brock McLean (Melbourne)
Rd 4 - Lance Franklin (Hawthorn)
Rd 5 - Jason Laycock (Essendon)
Rd 6 - Justin Sherman (Brisbane Lions)
Rd 7 - Will Minson (Western Bulldogs)
Rd 8 - Brett Deledio(Richmond)
Rd 9 - Colin Sylvia (Melbourne)
Rd 10 - Travis Cloke (Collingwood)
Rd 11 - Jordan Lewis (Hawthorn)
Rd 12 - Jed Adcock (Brisbane Lions)
Rd 13 - Ryan Griffen (Western Bulldogs)
Rd 14 - David Mundy (Fremantle)
Rd 15 - Troy Selwood (Brisbane Lions)
Rd 16 - Adam Selwood (West Coast Eagles)
Rd 17 - Anthony Corrie (Brisbane Lions)
Rd 18 - Kade Simpson (Carlton)
Rd 19 - Jarryd Roughead (Hawthorn)
Rd 20 - Adam Bentick (Carlton)
Rd 21 - Nathan Ablett (Geelong)
Rd 22 - Raphael Clarke (St Kilda)
2004
Jared Rivers (Melbourne)
Brent Hartigan (Richmond)
Adam Cooney(Western Bulldogs)
Brent Stanton (Essendon)
Daniel Cross (Western Bulldogs)
Beau Walters (West Coast Eagles)
Sam Butler (West Coast Eagles)
Brent Reilly (Adelaide)
Mark Seaby (West Coast)
Jay Schulz (Richmond)
Karl Norman (Carlton)
Richard Hadley (Brisbane Lions)
Brett Ebert (Port Adelaide)
Brent Moloney (Geelong)
Guy Richards (Collingwood)
Andrew Mackie (Geelong)
Brent Staker (West Coast Eagles)
Kane Tenace (Geelong)
Andrew Walker (Carlton)
Paul Bevan (Sydney)
Jared Rivers (Melbourne)
Michael Firrito (Kangaroos)
Aaron Davey (Melbourne)
2003
Ashley McGrath (Brisbane) / Matthew Lokan (Collingwood)
Andrew McDougall (West Coast Eagles)
Leigh Montagna (St Kilda)
Marc Bullen (Essendon)
Lewis Roberts-Thomson (Sydney)
Richard Cole (Collingwood)
Daniel Motlop (Kangaroos)
Ted Richards (Essendon)
Aaron Sandilands (Fremantle)
Byron Schammer (Fremantle)
Brad Fisher (Carlton)
Daniel Wells (Kangaroos)
Jarrad Waite (Carlton)
Graham Polak (Fremantle)
Ashley Sampi (West Coast Eages)
Brendon Goddard (St Kilda)
Michael Osborne (Hawthorn)
Adam Schneider (Sydney)
Jared Brennan (Brisbane Lions)
Trent Sporn (Carlton)
Luke Ball (St Kilda)
Sam Mitchell (Hawthorn)
2002
Paul Medhurst (Fremantle)
Chris Judd (West Coast Eagles)
Steven Armstrong (Melbourne)
James Bartel (Geelong)
Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda)
Jason Cloke (Collingwood)
Xavier Clarke (St Kilda)
David Rodan (Richmond)
Shane Birss (Western Bulldogs)
Mark McGough (Collingwood)
Ryan Hargrave (Western Bulldogs)
James Kelly (Geelong)
Shaun Burgoyne (Port Adelaide)
Mark Coughlan (Richmond)
Luke Hodge (Hawthorn)
Alan Didak (Collingwood)
Nick Ries (Hawthorn)
Jordan McMahon (Western Bulldogs)
Tadhg Kennelly (Sydney)
Ty Zantuck (Richmond)
Jamie Charman (Brisbane Lions)
Campbell Brown (Hawthorn)
best: chris judd
worst: mark mcgough (lol)
That comment is the worst comment i have seen on BF EVER. Mitchell broke the record of clearances in one game and if he didn't miss games due to injury this year he would've been a contender for the brownlow.ndot said:
Shows how much you know bout footy.
****************.It's called injuries. His whole footy carrer was distroyed by them. But he was good at the beginning, than he did fall off the pase. I still can't believe the stupid comment about Mitchell!waspy said:
Mighty Hawk
Team Captain
- Sep 17, 2005
- 483
- 3
- Other Teams
- Hawthorn
ndot said:
You typical arrogant West Coast ********er!
- Banned
- #39
from best to worst:
1993 Nathan Buckley (Brisbane)
1996 Ben Cousins (West Coast Eagles)
2000 Paul Hasleby (Fremantle)
2003 Sam Mitchell (Hawthorn)
1997 Michael Wilson (Port Adelaide)
2004 Jared Rivers (Melbourne)
1995 Nick Holland (Hawthorn)
1994 Chris Scott (Brisbane)
2001 Justin Koschitzke (St Kilda)
2002 Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda)
1999 Adam Goodes (Sydney)
1998 Byron Pickett (North Melbourne)
1993 Nathan Buckley (Brisbane)
1996 Ben Cousins (West Coast Eagles)
2000 Paul Hasleby (Fremantle)
2003 Sam Mitchell (Hawthorn)
1997 Michael Wilson (Port Adelaide)
2004 Jared Rivers (Melbourne)
1995 Nick Holland (Hawthorn)
1994 Chris Scott (Brisbane)
2001 Justin Koschitzke (St Kilda)
2002 Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda)
1999 Adam Goodes (Sydney)
1998 Byron Pickett (North Melbourne)
- Banned
- #41
xavsam said:
lol all you want, but the fact is Goodes is the most overrated player of the century, Riewoldt is becoming quite close
Still trying to work out Riewoldts greatness, he takes uncontested marks on the wing, so? He cant kick straight, something I noticed last year but most people only picked up on late this year. I wouldnt take him at Collingwood, definately not worth what he would want
Yze_Class said:
exactly, Daniher is probably gunna have to go before we see the best of Rivers
- Jun 23, 2004
- 13,506
- 38
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Chris Scott. Overrated hackerama.
Bucks is the best, just quietly.
Bucks is the best, just quietly.
ndot said:
The thread is a little mischevious, many could misconstrue it's meaning to be who doesn't deserve the rising star??
All winners were deserving of the award, Wilson's career has been cruelled by injuries as had Holland's.
Is the question:
which player, post winning the award has had the least impact??
or
which player was the worst player at the point of winning it??
In either instance it would be hard to justify Wilson's inclusion.
hollis_tom
Team Captain
- Sep 6, 2005
- 300
- 0
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Essendon
Jared Rivers is crap, most of those rising stars have had at least one season where they have been great players, Rivers spent his in the twos, and will continue to stay there, didn't see how he was any good in his first season anyway.
Wonder Years
Team Captain
- Apr 6, 2005
- 438
- 4
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
All players at the time of winning it and at other times during their career have or will be champions but few can sustain it such as Buckley/Cousins. To say there is a worst one is a joke because they were clearly the best eligible player that won in any given year. 3 of 13 are Brownlow Medallists which is a pretty good strike rate.
Wonder Years
Team Captain
- Apr 6, 2005
- 438
- 4
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
ndot said:
Just cause he shattered your rubbish defence!
hollis_tom said:
your a moron mate honestly take a look at his 2004 season. He was voted as the best young player by all the judges and the only other player that had any chance was his teammate Aaron Davey. Whether or not he plays good from now on who knows? but that year he was a gun and he was a big part of our winning streak early in the year. He has only had one season since and whilst not blowing anyone away he did have a few goodgames, give him another preseason of bulking up and he will improve dramatically.
Similar threads
