-
AFLW 2024 - Round 7 - Pride Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Your All Australian Team after 6 rounds
- Thread starter melbournemartin
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Apr 2, 2000
- 75,507
- 25,343
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, Chicago Bulls.
Some of your forward lines are a joke.
HF - Hall Tredrea Brown
FF - Neitz Gehrig Lloyd
Why not??
I mean seriously.... PHILLIP MATERA!
HF - Hall Tredrea Brown
FF - Neitz Gehrig Lloyd
Why not??
I mean seriously.... PHILLIP MATERA!
im sorry to everyone for daring not to care what team name was on the players.. i shall endevor to care more from now on.
melbournemartin
Brownlow Medallist
- Thread starter
- #79
nietz has had a better year than hall so far at FF
and the selectors will never have hall, gerhig and nietz on the FF line
in my books the ebst Hall can hope for is the bench
and the selectors will never have hall, gerhig and nietz on the FF line
in my books the ebst Hall can hope for is the bench
May as well have a go..probably different to a few others
Backs: B. Voss (St. K) Michael (Bris) Penny (St. K)
Half-Backs: McPhee (Ess) McPharlin (Frem) C. Cornes (P. Adel)
Centres: B. Harvey (Kang) Hasleby (Frem) Ricciuto (Adel)
Half-Forwards: Hird (C - Ess) Tredrea (P. Adel) Bruce (Melb)
Forwards: N. Brown (Rich) Gehrig (St. K) Neitz (Melb)
Rucks: J. White (Melb) Cousins (WCE) West (W. Bull)
Interchange: J. Brown (Bris) P. Burgoyne (P. Adel) Kirk (Syd) Bell (Frem)
Coach - Neale Daniher
Backs: B. Voss (St. K) Michael (Bris) Penny (St. K)
Half-Backs: McPhee (Ess) McPharlin (Frem) C. Cornes (P. Adel)
Centres: B. Harvey (Kang) Hasleby (Frem) Ricciuto (Adel)
Half-Forwards: Hird (C - Ess) Tredrea (P. Adel) Bruce (Melb)
Forwards: N. Brown (Rich) Gehrig (St. K) Neitz (Melb)
Rucks: J. White (Melb) Cousins (WCE) West (W. Bull)
Interchange: J. Brown (Bris) P. Burgoyne (P. Adel) Kirk (Syd) Bell (Frem)
Coach - Neale Daniher
- Apr 27, 2002
- 16,224
- 13,299
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Edmonton Oilers, Newcastle
If Brisbane have less than 3 AA's this year, I will chew off one of my own testicles.@Having said that I do not relish the thought of trying to pen a team.
melbournemartin
Brownlow Medallist
- Thread starter
- #84
i think that Neile Daniher would be a great option for coach
why?
grant thomas and leigh matthews have great lists that you know are gunna preform each match
as opposed to Neile who has had to drag his team out of 2003 into this year and has done it exceptionally
why?
grant thomas and leigh matthews have great lists that you know are gunna preform each match
as opposed to Neile who has had to drag his team out of 2003 into this year and has done it exceptionally
- Banned
- #85
Neitz should be at FF
Gehrig is not worthy of AA
He is just another Scott Cummings. Right place at the right time, feeding off a very very good midfield
as for Neitz, not only is he AA full forward, but he should be AA captain
Gehrig is not worthy of AA
He is just another Scott Cummings. Right place at the right time, feeding off a very very good midfield
as for Neitz, not only is he AA full forward, but he should be AA captain
Ahead of Hird who is clearly dominating the competition (universally regarded as much)
- Sep 6, 2003
- 2,042
- 2
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Demons/Liverpool/Victory
Although I'm a Melbourne fan I'd have to disagree with you there.
Gehrig's form this year has been exceptional IMO. Neita has been very good too.
Midfield delivery shouldn't come into consideration IMO.
- Banned
- #88
Pull you head out of your arse, young man.
melbournemartin
Brownlow Medallist
- Thread starter
- #89
nietz and gerhig have to both be in the AA team
one at FF and one in the pocket or perhaps the bench
i think that OVERALL nietz is a better full forward but gerhig has had a stellar start baring the game vs brisbane
neitz only kicked 2 and was held held vs carlton and one goal was from a dodgey free kick but since we thrashed them no one realli cared
one at FF and one in the pocket or perhaps the bench
i think that OVERALL nietz is a better full forward but gerhig has had a stellar start baring the game vs brisbane
neitz only kicked 2 and was held held vs carlton and one goal was from a dodgey free kick but since we thrashed them no one realli cared
Brown ahead of Hall?
Although i think brown is an awesome player but he isn't as good as hall yet and he doesn't hurt teams enough on the scoreboard like hall does!!!!
The bottom line is there have been a lot of good players over the first 6 weeks and it's impossible to squeeze them all in. We'll have to wait for the halfway mark until we get a better indication of who might/might not make it.
It's true that he was buggered by the end of the match on Friday night. There was a crucial piece of play when scores were tied when the ball seemed as if it was going to go out-of-bounds on the centre wing.
But it just stopped before the line and Ben Marsh was able to get to it first because his opposing player, Everitt, was basically buggered and was praying it didn't go out. But it was easy to see why Everitt was so tired, because he worked so hard during the match, trying to make up for the lacklustre efforts of his teammates. BOG for mine.
Hard to see how Burns could get an AA spot atm as he was completely ineffective against Richmond (lowest possession tally in a match since 2001), was carrying an injury against Freo and was stationed in the forward line for the latter stages and was injured for 3-quarters of the match against Port.
Ben Johnson is a good pick though. The way he's played this year in a struggling side has leadership stamped all over it.
As for potential candidates from Richmond... none come to mind. Brown has been our best but I think he's a fair way off AA material at the minute.
Go_Muddies
Rookie
Have u even seen tredrea play this year, his form so far is up there for brownlow contention let alone all australian centre half forward.
melbournemartin
Brownlow Medallist
- Thread starter
- #94
brown still has a presence that i dont think tredrae has as much
im mainly talking about a physical one here
tredrae is a better CHF but brown is the future
how old is tredrae anyway?
im mainly talking about a physical one here
tredrae is a better CHF but brown is the future
how old is tredrae anyway?
So what if Brown is the future of key position forwards, if he isn't the best player in his position he shouldn't get an AA gurseney.
Tredrea is still only 25, hardly a relic of the AFL as you seem to think.
Go_Muddies
Rookie
i agree with Mcphee going into the side. in the few essendon games i have watched he has been near best on ground every time.
melbournemartin
Brownlow Medallist
- Thread starter
- #98
if brett voss and mcphee are automatic inclusions then Green should definatly be in there
From an unbiased perspective:
How was Neitz meant to kick more than 2 goals when the ball kept going through the goals from 40, 50, 60m's out?
Hardly any kicks landed in the hot spot bar a few.
The Melbourne engine room is up and running. I think everyone better start showing some respect.
