Player Watch Fischer McAsey - Steps Away from Football, Not Returning

Do you think Fischer McAsey will be at the AFC in 2022?


  • Total voters
    52
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Working my way thru SANFL games .....watching the Crows v Sturt

Loving the potential of McAsey ......is approaching contests in different ways .....he's not a one trick pony

Taken a mark 4 deep & goaled .....he sticks his body at the foot of contests, muscling ala Fogs ....and he leads
Just a good footy IQ

View attachment 1498353

Let's see if the Club is thinking like me .......you just have to persevere with McAsey .....don't look at his stats, look at his movement, his thinking in contested situations ......FFS he's only 21 !!
Looks like us two are just about the only ones willing to give him a chance.
Its funny, our SANFL forward line has always been a graveyard for key forwards. Even the last times we were strong in SANFL I don't recall many big bags.
Himmelberg's been there forever and is only just becoming dominant now and I still don't recall him getting more than 3 in a game, Fish is getting 1 here and there, Berg did that for ages too. That's because the normal oppo tactic is to flood our forward line, so the bigger and more lumbering you are, the worse off you are. That's why its people like Newchurch, McAdam and Wright who have got the big bags. Gollant has admittedly done well once or twice too but he's still a size smaller and therefore a degree more mobile than a key.

I thought from about a qtr of the way thru the season there started to be lots of good signs with Fish. Didn't get towelled up in defense for a few games in a row, took his oppo right out of it. Got moved up forward. V inconsistent to start with up there and having a hard time of it for a while but is getting more consistent and more involved. Has improved and improved. I think with a lot on his mind and falling a year behind where he should be in fitness and strength, has really delayed him, but I still think he can make it. Last week was his best game I think. A lot of nearly's. Those are the sort of things that change when you can get a good preseason in, get that little bit more strength, that little bit more tank, then you go from having a middle of the range game to being one of the best.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Not only does McAsey rhyme with Degrassi (and Kris Massie), but there is also great optimism and hope in that theme song and BigFooty should probably give the kid a chance.



Wake up in the morning
feeling shy and lonely
gee I gotta play Aussie Rules

I don't think I can make it
don't think I can take it
I wonder what I'm gonna do

But when I look around I see
Carmo and Waynesworld smiling right at me

Wait! That someone’s talkin' bout me
Hey, I got a new friend

Everybody can succeed
all you need is to believe
be honest with yourself
forget your fears and doubts
come on give him a try
McAsey is your guy
 
He clearly has the physical attributes to be a good player, great size, strong hands, presents at the footy well.

But his intensity is nowhere near it, dunno if he’s lacking confidence, or just never had it, but struggle to see him making it at this rate.
 
He clearly has the physical attributes to be a good player, great size, strong hands, presents at the footy well.

But his intensity is nowhere near it, dunno if he’s lacking confidence, or just never had it, but struggle to see him making it at this rate.
I'd go as far as saying today in isolation had we had a player with better intensity and competitiveness as that key forward, we probably win
 
No one on here wants McAsey to fail. But he’s showing nothing that suggests he would be more than an average SANFL player and quite frankly, if he wasn’t on the Crows list, he’d be struggling to get a SANFL game.

Let’s hope he can turn it around because he will be a costly fail, but crikey, he’d want to start doing football
 
No one on here wants McAsey to fail. But he’s showing nothing that suggests he would be more than an average SANFL player and quite frankly, if he wasn’t on the Crows list, he’d be struggling to get a SANFL game.

Let’s hope he can turn it around because he will be a costly fail, but crikey, he’d want to start doing football

Just think from day dot there has been 0 indication of what abilities he has.

This is one of those where I would love the recruitment staff to sit down and explain to me exactly what it was they saw in him.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

He wouldn't have been moved FWD if he was performing as a KPD ??.......it's logical

Are you now going to move Fogarty to CHB after his season forward ? ......nope
This is a horrible call and so wrong on so many levels and one can't imagine what your smoking but don't try and rewrite history if you know nothing about it.

Weitering 26 disposals in his 3rd game which was round 3 and was the rising star nomination in his 1st year which he went on to finish 3rd.
Average 6 marks and 18 disposals in his 1st year as a KPD.

He signed a 4 year deal after his 1st season.

He was Drafted 1 year after McKay yet made his debut 1 year earlier.

McKay was injured at the start of 2017 and Bolton f**ked up badly.

Thursday, 9 March 2017
Jacob Weitering will play primarily in defence in 2017, but Carlton plans to develop the talented tall into a weapon that can eventually be deployed at both ends of the ground.
"I'm just really mindful that we as a club understand that he is only in his second year and if we chop and change things for him too randomly that can unsettle young players," Carlton coach Brendon Bolton said.
"So we just want to make sure he's totally solidified as a defender first and then he can grow into other roles.
"But the long-term plan is he can play at both ends and we've already started to do that, but we just haven't done it flippantly."

Nek Minnut

Thursday, 23 March 2017
Jacob Weitering bags three goals as a forward in Carlton's season opener against Richmond.
"For his growth we'll develop him at both ends. We drafted him originally as a defender but we think in time he can be a genuine swingman," Carlton coach Brendon Bolton said.
"This was another opportunity. He played a lot in defence in the JLT (Community Series), and this was a really good bite up forward. We think for his growth he'll play at both ends."

McAsey is a bust, blame recruiters, developers, attitude, circumstances probably all 4, I have no idea but don't try and polish a turd and we should never have taken him at 6 and all the melts again proven right.
 
Just think from day dot there has been 0 indication of what abilities he has.

This is one of those where I would love the recruitment staff to sit down and explain to me exactly what it was they saw in him.
It wasnt just our recruitment that saw his potential

1662323630178.png
 
Just think from day dot there has been 0 indication of what abilities he has.

This is one of those where I would love the recruitment staff to sit down and explain to me exactly what it was they saw in him.
Just watch McAsey's positioning, what he's doing B4 the ball arrives .....and his methods of trying to get a kick .....his deft tap-on's .....his thinking after missing the first possession

Forget for a moment about watching the outcome of the incoming ball & just watch the player alone .......watch his thinking & you'll see an AFL footballer

Very different to a Frampton who racks up easy possessions ......often at SANFL level, it's not the mass possession accumulators who succeed in a better structured AFL team environment

Interesting, the Club has not changed his role one bit all year ....
 
Just watch McAsey's positioning, what he's doing B4 the ball arrives .....and his methods of trying to get a kick .....his deft tap-on's .....his thinking after missing the first possession

Forget for a moment about watching the outcome of the incoming ball & just watch the player alone .......watch his thinking & you'll see an AFL footballer

Very different to a Frampton who racks up easy possessions ......often at SANFL level, it's not the mass possession accumulators who succeed in a better structured AFL team environment

Interesting, the Club has not changed his role one bit all year ....
Crikey, did you watch him yesterday? If he wasn’t on a Crows list he wouldn’t have made the side as a top up player.

You are absolutely clutching with McAsey and trying to see things that aren’t there. Ignore the outcome of the ball? You serious?? The only reason you’d say that is because he can’t win the ball at SANFL level.

The club has kept him up there because they’ve seen him play as a defender and are hoping like hell he might make it as a forward.
 
Crikey, did you watch him yesterday? If he wasn’t on a Crows list he wouldn’t have made the side as a top up player.

You are absolutely clutching with McAsey and trying to see things that aren’t there.

The club has kept him up there because they’ve seen him play as a defender and are hoping like hell he might make it as a forward.
I've watched the last 8 x SANFL games over the last week .....my attitude isn't based on 1 game

We'll always disagree on player assessments, George ........he's an AFL Defender !
 
At this stage he may go the way of Gooch and get delisted. If we can get something for him this year just grab it.
If it wasn't our seconds team, he wouldn't get a game with any other SANFL side, that's a sad indication of where he's at. Mentally not up to the physical side, SANFL defenders are under sized and part time fitness/hardness compared to AFL defenders and he's getting bullied at SANFL level!

Might get a late pick this year but the way he's tracked in three seasons, he's a certain delist next year so get him out while we can.
 
McAsey and our 2023 3rd to Carlton for Pick 28 anyone?
Pick 28 or we may as well keep him & hope he come good.

No point trading McAsey out for peanuts.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch Fischer McAsey - Steps Away from Football, Not Returning

Back
Top