2nds 2023 Adelaide Crows SANFL thread

Who is the unlikely player who will spend most of the year in the reserves

  • Sloane

    Votes: 4 4.7%
  • Crouch

    Votes: 53 62.4%
  • O"Brien

    Votes: 2 2.4%
  • Keays

    Votes: 2 2.4%
  • Walker

    Votes: 1 1.2%
  • Himmelberg

    Votes: 36 42.4%
  • Doedee

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Schoenberg

    Votes: 23 27.1%
  • Milera

    Votes: 6 7.1%

  • Total voters
    85

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

For those advocating leaving the SANFL & joining the VFL ...... 40 goal win the other week in QLD .....sides regularly getting walloped ....and now this

Anyone thinking our players will develop better in a lopsided comp ? .......and the amateur nature of umpires, is the same as in the SANFL

1690011976559.png
 
For those advocating leaving the SANFL & joining the VFL ...... 40 goal win the other week in QLD .....sides regularly getting walloped ....and now this

Anyone thinking our players will develop better in a lopsided comp ? .......and the amateur nature of umpires, is the same as in the SANFL

View attachment 1748591
No one wants to join the VFL do they?

People have been talking about an AFL Reserves competition
 
No one wants to join the VFL do they?

People have been talking about an AFL Reserves competition
That's what the eastern state's competition is called ......the VFL ( VIC, NSW, QLD)

They would rename it ......but that's what it is, an expanded VFL
 
That's what the eastern state's competition is called ......the VFL ( VIC, NSW, QLD)

They would rename it ......but that's what it is, an expanded VFL
Except all AFL teams including the WA and SA clubs and none of the standalone VFL clubs
 
For those advocating leaving the SANFL & joining the VFL ...... 40 goal win the other week in QLD .....sides regularly getting walloped ....and now this

Anyone thinking our players will develop better in a lopsided comp ? .......and the amateur nature of umpires, is the same as in the SANFL

View attachment 1748591

Was curious so went and looked, most of the standalone VFL clubs are struggling, Coburg are winless, yet Werribee sit top, what’s the story there?
 
Except all AFL teams including the WA and SA clubs and none of the standalone VFL clubs
It appears out of a 22 team comp .....8 are stand alone, including Southport

I haven't read, they wouldn't be included .....that said, if not, does the VFL end up with a 7 team comp ?

I stand by the comment though, the reserves comp, full of young players, can't be of a higher standard than the SANFL ......it becomes an elevated U19's comp
 
Was curious so went and looked, most of the standalone VFL clubs are struggling, Coburg are winless, yet Werribee sit top, what’s the story there?
I'm not close enough to know the full reasons .....maybe some players can't travel due to work ?.......pure guesswork though ;)
 
For those advocating leaving the SANFL & joining the VFL ...... 40 goal win the other week in QLD .....sides regularly getting walloped ....and now this

Anyone thinking our players will develop better in a lopsided comp ? .......and the amateur nature of umpires, is the same as in the SANFL

View attachment 1748591

Maybe the bull ants are just bad
 
Was curious so went and looked, most of the standalone VFL clubs are struggling, Coburg are winless, yet Werribee sit top, what’s the story there?
they shunned the pokies money and are paying for it. the standalone clubs not at the bottom still have pokies.


seldom pays to do the right thing
 
For those advocating leaving the SANFL & joining the VFL ...... 40 goal win the other week in QLD .....sides regularly getting walloped ....and now this

Anyone thinking our players will develop better in a lopsided comp ? .......and the amateur nature of umpires, is the same as in the SANFL

View attachment 1748591

Just like playing West Coast
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

they shunned the pokies money and are paying for it. the standalone clubs not at the bottom still have pokies.


seldom pays to do the right thing
That’s pretty sad.

Respect to those clubs for wanting to compete, but surely dropping back to the ammos and being really strong there is better for them.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

2nds 2023 Adelaide Crows SANFL thread

Back
Top