Search results for query: *

Shit take, has clearly been instructed not to be sucked into the contest but puts his body on the line when it’s his turn to go.

Went from captain Sutherland to Brown just before the second game, sick choice 🤦

Lovely from Fergus, not leaving many runs for captain Brown to get though 😭

Graham + Baker for 14 is still a shit deal

834 with Sutherland, Seifert, Brown (C), JFM, O’Neil, Zampa (is a scoring player for me currently thanks to Allen) sadly have two tons on the bench.

Both

Zorko isn’t even a mid, Berry being considered A grade is extremely generous. Most contending teams have 2-3 elite midfielders and good/great role players (think Rowbottom/Berry) around them.

How many elite mids did Brisbane have this season? Are you assuming none of these needs can come from the 20 plus 21 or under players on the list?

Certainly seems more of a crapshoot than the footy mode, how many gades/stars players do you go out of interest?

Just based on what I’ve been seeing in terms of projected scores, must have gone too many gades/stars players in hindsight. Have 643 with Overton live and 9 scores to come including captain. Thinking that works out to be roughly 1100 - 1150 dependent on how the captain goes.

Slightly confused by the double players, they get their combined score from both games? On track for a large total if that’s the case.

I’m not convinced that 1.6 goals a game across your 3rd season is elite key forward trajectory unless there are 15 elite key forwards in the league.

Surely we exile this campaigner already.

What makes you say that first sentence? Is this backed up by anything in particular? The second paragraph is a bold faced lie. Are you suggesting Chesser is no chance of becoming an AFL standard player?

The eagles round 24 side featured 4 players > 10 AFL games, 7 players > 50 games, Hough who has played 53 games and a 24yo ruck. To think that team won’t improve is downright trolling. For those saying there won’t be the elite top end within 5 years, how many elite players does a premiership...

I’d suggest there aren’t many teams with as many inexperienced players in their 22 than eagles 2024, natural progression is a near certainty.

Nah, no one is going to want the 25yo KPF who’s proven to be capable of kicking 50+ in a season.

Went with Brown as captain, straying to fade a lot of the really popular options (Webster, Short).

Apologies, named on a wing. I think he and Ginbey have certainly shown enough that one of them could easily be a Rowbottom type which is all you really need surrounding 2 a graders in Reid and Warner. Time will tell I suppose.

Who am I using as a loop in bowling please?

Just found it strange you wrote off the Champs AA centre as a part time mids before he’d played an AFL game. Reckon theres a number of older players/proven youngsters that would fit in a contender in 2028/2029 assuming they were to grab Warner and a number more unproven players that should...

Very pessimistic view calling Ginbey and Allan part time mids, assume Lalor is one as well in your eyes?

Think any “issue” is seriously overstated, rookies can take time. Hobbs and Ward had similar seasons, Erasmus is stuck in the WAFL.

Looking forward to the Chesser apology forms in 2025. Hawks pick was the easy choice, both have similar ceilings but the hawks a much lower floor.

Not sure it was intentional mate, Richmond’s best players were leaving a sinking ship devoid of talent, we will see how it ends up long term. You think it’s impossible the eagles are contending within 6 years?

You surely aren’t suggesting Sturt and Chapman should be rated higher/equal to Watson and Weddle? Clueless.

Is it? A lot of fuss being made over one draft considering they are coming from a position where, if we’re being very generous they have 3 players under 23 that have looked like they belong at AFL level.

Have you seen the Richmond list? Can’t be furthest from finals while that group of state league players exist.

What have you seen of Corey to decide he has higher upside than Chesser?