Search results for query: *

Agree - I don't see Wells coming back in this week. It's almost last roll of the dice for him. Think about the situation where he gets another calf injury. That's another couple of months out (usually he is slow to recover) and wouldn't he then be considered to risky, even if he was ready, to be...

Yes. Do you realise there is more to selection than that? :)

All fair points as there are lot's of different perspectives on any given game. Bucks did mention Callum in the post game favourably. So, I guess my perspective is that it can be harsh on a player to be dropped in that scenario. As I said, I like Sier, I don't know if bringing him back will have...

I agree - why do people just assume he should be pushed out of the team? Can people explain why they are so strong on Sier - I like him too but I feel like the desire for him outmatches his true value at this point in time. Again, I don't think it is good for players to get dropped unless it is...

Totally agree - and he did it with half the support off field that current players have. For long periods he also played in teams which meant he copped heavy tagging every minute he was on the field.

Let me try a left field answer; Callum Brown. I think it was last year he played against WCE and had a bit of it. To me, I recognised a bit of Sam Mitchell in how clean he was with the ball and how much that allowed him to pick the right option and get the ball there effectively. So, I agree...

Perhaps you missed the point I was making.

I don't necessarily disagree with you though it is probably worth considering team balance. You need people like Varcoe for their leg speed. If only to match up on the opposition speedsters but then also to bring the crucial element of pressure which is a key part of the pies style. Sure, he was...

I agree with the more measured view. Taking a deep breathe is probably a first step to take before thinking about any changes. Totally understand that round one brings higher expectation and anticipation so the loss hits more emotions. Every team in every round is based on structures. Those...

I will take a risk here and say Wells, here is my thinking on why he will have the most impact: - The pies are right in the hunt for a premiership, with a chance to compete against the likes of Richmond, WCE, GWS, or others. With the addition of Beams it could be argued that he makes the team...

He is a high draft pick, physically ready player so will get some focus ahead of round one. If you focus on the other side of this discussion, that is who he replaces to get a spot the situation is clearer. In my opinion, he will not be able to pinch a spot of an incumbent so is therefore not...

Anyone know if this was recorded? Hoping to watch as missed it live.

I asked who captured the times. As you highlight above Jen told you about the spacing between places and that she put up a video of the placing. Beside the point anyway, I was interested as to the accuracy of the timings which is why I asked about the times rather than the placings/footage...

Thanks again (and to Jen). Can't say I can see the reference you mention above - which is the only reason I asked!

Thanks for the report, the detail is very insightful. Who captured the times you quoted?

What is the story with turner?

During the season the best 22 changes - horses for courses, match ups, injuries all become considerations. A significant indication though is that he is keeping Fas out of the side. He is also one of few that has speed which is a premium attribute in today's game. So, whether he is a pure best...

I understand the lack of confidence - a trip to Adelaide's home deck is certainly putting us against the odds. Let's try and be objective it no optimistic. For example, Fasolo is not a automatic selection. Of late, he has had mental and physical issues, seemingly culminating in form not...

Sier??

Yeah, but we rested our starting centre for the whole game. So, you could say the teams were even in the last quarter.

good point :)

Who do you think will be the most improved player and why? For me, I think it will be De Goey. He was pretty poor last year but has all the tools to be a top line player. The penny has now dropped that he will be left behind quickly, and now has to fight for a spot in the midfield so the...

Ask about France.

So, did James do anything else while he was in France?

Strange views on here. Do you think re-generating the list is done while moving up the ladder? No, it was a necessary by product of improving a list that was not going to win a flag. He is a strong leader and that's what all clubs need. Wrapping him up for longer removes the distracting...

Hey Domus, Are you a Collingwood supporter? We are watching the beginning of a career that was stalled by severe injuries. This is a person you could say literally is finding his feet. This is against teams of hardened AFL professionals. Now, I don't know about you but I am prepared to back the...

You must admit that very few young and injury hit teams win premierships. Take the hawks last year - sure they had injuries but they were not young. The year before the romped home as the were neither young nor injury hit. I wouldn't say Collingwood are particularly injury hit this year...

Which is a terrific thing. Winning not as relevant right now - disappointing sure but let's keep the big picture in mind.