Player Watch #11: Jason Castagna - signed to 2023

Should Castagna be dropped for the Port game after his 2 disposal effort vs the Swans?

  • Yes - for Cumberland

  • Yes - for anyone

  • No

  • Make him Sub


Results are only viewable after voting.

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

He is not a star. Think about our best players. They’re stars.

This bloke is a role player. Which is fine. But when you can’t do that, that’s when you get dropped and rightfully so. He should be on very thin ice right now.

This post sums it all up, no shame in being a role player and if you don't get enough of the ball you get dropped. Which is exactly what happened.

So many immature posts on here calling him a spud. I've seen so many dud players pull on the jumper for Richmond and George is nowhere near that level. Nowhere near it.
 
Out of interest Knackers, who's winning the FANTASY Brownlow?
Your mother champ, everynight with the Kaos King lol

Screaming The Muppets GIF
 
Bottom line is our superstars are ageing and not going to continually get us over the line.
You need an even spread , can’t ride on the coattails of Dusty/Cotch/JR anymore.

You want to persevere with underperforming players like George then the rest of the competition will pull away from you.

People need to acknowledge it’s no longer 2020, start the build now or be left behind
Sure, there's that. Having that perspective doesn't have to come with a lack of respect.
 
Bottom line is our superstars are ageing and not going to continually get us over the line.
You need an even spread , can’t ride on the coattails of Dusty/Cotch/JR anymore.

You want to persevere with underperforming players like George then the rest of the competition will pull away from you.

People need to acknowledge it’s no longer 2020, start the build now or be left behind

So have we put the cue in the rack and time to get rid of our underperforming ageing stars? What is George’s replacement going to do? Break team rules and get 35 possessions.?
What you have stated is the biggest non build going around. Lose games and keep replacing the player that no one kicks to. There is just so much of the pie to be shared in the forward line .
It’s already started though . Young Judson only got 3 games at getting the scraps.
 
So have we put the cue in the rack and time to get rid of our underperforming ageing stars? What is George’s replacement going to do? Break team rules and get 35 possessions.?
What you have stated is the biggest non build going around. Lose games and keep replacing the player that no one kicks to. There is just so much of the pie to be shared in the forward line .
It’s already started though . Young Judson only got 3 games at getting the scraps.
Since when was avoiding possessions a team rule?

Rule #1 - don't go near the ball. we don't want possessions.
 
Rule number 3, when you attempt to handball, contact with the ball with your fist is optional. Fresh air Handball attempts are not frowned upon.

Even his missed handballs on the weekend were from possessions that only a contested pace God of a player could have gotten . One was the shimmy of the year and it was only because he thought everyone else ran at warp speed like himself that it missed the mark. The other he beat 4 opponents single handled and it only broke down because those around him were too busy staring in awe at his tenacity and had forgotten the Richmond way of on your bike ….they will learn
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Even his missed handballs on the weekend were from possessions that only a contested pace God of a player could have gotten . One was the shimmy of the year and it was only because he thought everyone else ran at warp speed like himself that it missed the mark. The other he beat 4 opponents single handled and it only broke down because those around him were too busy staring in awe at his tenacity and had forgotten the Richmond way of on your bike ….they will learn
God hey?
 
Every player that has pulled on our jumper and given it his all is a star.
Just wonder when Relton will be the next homecoming hero as apparently, he was a star. How on earth can someone justify this useless dud is beyond me.
 
So have we put the cue in the rack and time to get rid of our underperforming ageing stars? What is George’s replacement going to do? Break team rules and get 35 possessions.?
What you have stated is the biggest non build going around. Lose games and keep replacing the player that no one kicks to. There is just so much of the pie to be shared in the forward line .
It’s already started though . Young Judson only got 3 games at getting the scraps.
Hope you watched that game against GC mate. Now make an argument for him
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch #11: Jason Castagna - signed to 2023

Back
Top