People who demote Gibson from the side greatly undervalue what he brings on a weekly basis.
I'm a big fan of his spread as well but let's not forget it is the ONLY thing he brings to the side. He doesn't carry the ball when he gets it and too often he kicks high floaters along the wing when he does find the ball in space.
Don't forget that spread and carry is what has made Dal Santo a star of the competition for 10 years and it is also a huge part of Luke McDonald's game. Throw in Mason Wood and hopefully Keiran Harper as similar types.
There is a large class gap between Gibson and many others on our list, Dal Santo and McDonald will help and the others need to prove they can work as hard as Gibson does if they are going to displace him.