AFL Player #16: Archie Perkins - Re-signed for two more years - 3/6

Remove this Banner Ad

Who cares, he will have down games. Progression is not linear in young players.
6 days is a ****ing long time on this board. You really are only as good as your last game round these parts
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I’d like to see a hungry Shiel and tsatas play as genuine starting mids against Gold Coast, and have duz perk and Caldwell, play in different roles or have a rest.
Bryan for goldy too.
We could also switch McKay to a wing, put Ridley in the forward pocket and play Cox in the ruck.

Ok, probably being a bit of a smart alec there, but think Duz and Caldwell have earned some consistency in the middle. They’ve been great at hunting some of the better midfields this year.

Love Tsatas and think he’ll be a star but the GCS mids (Rowell, Miller, Anderson) would slaughter his underdeveloped frame.

Not sure what’s going on with Shiel, but he’s not making the grade under coach this year. Think he must have parked his car in coaches’ spot.
 
We could also switch McKay to a wing, put Ridley in the forward pocket and play Cox in the ruck.

Ok, probably being a bit of a smart alec there, but think Duz and Caldwell have earned some consistency in the middle. They’ve been great at hunting some of the better midfields this year.

Love Tsatas and think he’ll be a star but the GCS mids (Rowell, Miller, Anderson) would slaughter his underdeveloped frame.

Not sure what’s going on with Shiel, but he’s not making the grade under coach this year. Think he must have parked his car in coaches’ spot.
To me Shiel has struggled with injury. He looks the part but hasn't been durable IMO.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Needs to be dropped or moved up forward. Total liability in the middle. Go back and watch the amount of times his direct opponent (usually Rowell or Anderson) was 15m ahead of him while Perkins was standing still or jogging.

Then go watch every clearance he was in where his opponent just walks away from him and wins the ball while he's ball watching
 
Had to clip the last stoppage I remembered him doing this, but this happened almost every single time he was in the middle. It's especially bad when he's in center clearance. Watch him and Rowell here.


I would also like to know who was meant to be on Touk Miller in the MIDDLE OF THE GROUND!?!?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

AFL Player #16: Archie Perkins - Re-signed for two more years - 3/6

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top