2007 Trades

[BEEG]

Judd to roos
fev to wb
didak to crows

Umm yeah and what do we get????? or we give Didak away for free i know our teams full of talent but we wont be doing that lol

 

[Evil Betty]

Jarrad Brennan for farren ray.
Thomas Murphy for Prismall + a 3rd rounder.
Murphy could be your ideal replacement Milburn & is a quality player but i just cant see a spot for him.

Who are Thomas and Murphy?

 

[Evil Betty]

not saying I agree with the trade, but out of curiousity, how old do you actually think mcphee is?

25/26 I'm guessing

 

[rumblah]

Justin Sherman to the Bombers for Kepler Bradley & a 3rd rounder.
Adam Schnider to the hawks for a 2nd round draft pick.
David Mundy & Ryan Murphy to Melbourne for Travis Johnstone & a 3rd rounder.

no
no
and.... no

 

[sydney eagle]

Judd to roos
fev to wb
didak to crows

As trades or do you think they will all go into the pre season draft ? What would the roos/bulldogs/crows ofer for these three players ?

 

[rumblah]

Jarrad Brennan for farren ray.
Thomas Murphy for Prismall + a 3rd rounder.
Murphy could be your ideal replacement Milburn & is a quality player but i just cant see a spot for him.

no
NO

Brookers, what team in their right mind would offer Brennan for Ray, no disrespect for Ray or the Bulldogs but they'd have to offer more.

Murphy is a talent from what ive seen in the ressys, will replace an aging Smith.

 

[rumblah]

All i know from this thread is that every club in the AFL should be happy that brookers has nothing to do with trading.

amen, in all honesty though, what is he thinking....

 

[BK Eaglesfan]

amen, in all honesty though, what is he thinking....

Well at least most clubs are being disadvantaged, not like he's being discriminatory.

 

[Longy413]

What club in their right mind would want Kepler Bradley??

Melbourne...

 

[Albo's opinion]

Wood to the pies, didak to adelaide, knights & a 2nd rounder to brisbane with the 2nd rounder on traded to collingwood.

The only semi-plausible trade suggested in this thread

 

[anjing merah]

Bomber Thompson to Essendon for Kevin Sheedy a couple of Martians, a flock of seagulls, an aquamax, a set of plumbers tools and the kitchen sink.

 

[The Teflon Dean]

Farren Ray for Leigh Brown
Travis Johnstone for Brad Moran
Leigh Harding and David Hale for Carltons pick 3.

 

[Rockster]

Carlton get pick 2 pick 17 and Jay Schultz from Richmond

Carlton give Richmond their pick 3 and Fevola

Chris Judd joins Carlton

WCE get pick 1 and 2 from Carlton

Carlton end up with Judd and pick 17 and Shultz from Richmond

Richmond end up with Fevola and pick 3

WCE loose Judd but end up with picks 1 and 2.

 

[The Teflon Dean]

Carlton get pick 2 pick 17 and Jay Schultz from Richmond

Carlton give Richmond their pick 3 and Fevola

Chris Judd joins Carlton

WCE get pick 1 and 2 from Carlton

Carlton end up with Judd and pick 17 and Shultz from Richmond

Richmond end up with Fevola and pick 3

WCE loose Judd but end up with picks 1 and 2.

WCE would probably be happy with pick 3 and Fevola for Judd. Their time is now, not in 5 years.

 

[SOT4]

Prismall to Essedon.

Yes Please!

 

[Bosun]

Carlton get pick 2 pick 17 and Jay Schultz from Richmond

Carlton give Richmond their pick 3 and Fevola

Chris Judd joins Carlton

WCE get pick 1 and 2 from Carlton

Carlton end up with Judd and pick 17 and Shultz from Richmond

Richmond end up with Fevola and pick 3

WCE loose Judd but end up with picks 1 and 2.

With our history of trading high draft picks for quality like McGuane and Charles, I cant see us trading either picks one or three.

I cant see Fev being traded either, we have little experience as it is, why trade more especially key position fwds that have the potential to break games open.

 

[Esky Lid]

We'll take Judd

Eagles will take Buddy & Williams

 

[nicko99]

Prismall to Essedon.

talking to my mate, who is best friends with prismalls younger brother, he told me that his going to essendon next year

 

[TheHawthornWay]

We'll take Judd

Eagles will take Buddy & Williams

Ahh dont think so..They can keep Judd!!

 

[sarah.13]

How about Prismall + 1st Rd pick for Ryder?

 

[PHX]

Carlton get pick 2 pick 17 and Jay Schultz from Richmond

Carlton give Richmond their pick 3 and Fevola

Chris Judd joins Carlton

WCE get pick 1 and 2 from Carlton

Carlton end up with Judd and pick 17 and Shultz from Richmond

Richmond end up with Fevola and pick 3

WCE loose Judd but end up with picks 1 and 2.

Yeah-errr great except for the fact Carlton CANT trade pick 1.

And why Richmond would want Fev?

 

[Longy413]

How about Prismall + 1st Rd pick for Ryder?

Nope.

 

[Demonheart]

Yeah-errr great except for the fact Carlton CANT trade pick 1.

And why Richmond would want Fev?

Fremantle wanted traded their PP a few years back so the AFL didn't bring in that rule.

 

[PHX]

Fremantle wanted traded their PP a few years back so the AFL didn't bring in that rule.

What??

I think I understand what you're trying to say so I'll reply with. . . . .


After 2001 when Freo traded their priority pick the rule was made that they couldn't be traded.

 

[rumblah]

Ahh dont think so..They can keep Judd!!

yeh i agree.