2009 club best and fairests

[Firrito24]

With the season drawing to a close for us lower placed teams, what do people think will be the top 10 in their club's B&F?

North Melbourne

1. Andrew Swallow
2. Hamish McIntosh
3. Scott McMahon
4. Adam Simpson
5. Scott Thompson
6. Brady Rawlings
7. Drew Petrie
8. Leigh Harding
9. Brent Harvey
10. Josh Gibson

 

[AG]

Sydney:
1. Adam Goodes
2. Jude Bolton
3. Ryan O'Keefe
4. Rhyce Shaw
5. Brett Kirk
6. Craig Bolton
7. Darren Jolly
8. LRT
9. Kieran Jack
10. Heath Grundy

Probably forgotten someone.

Predict the other teams:

Adelaide: Bernie Vince
Brisbane: Jonathan Brown
Carlton: Marc Murphy
Collingwood: Dane Swan
Essendon: Jobe Watson
Fremantle: Aaron Sandilands
Geelong: Corey Enright
Hawthorn: Sam Mitchell
Melbourne: Aaron Davey
North Melbourne: Andrew Swallow
Richmond: Daniel Jackson
Port Adelaide: Jacob Surjan
St Kilda: Nick Riewoldt
West Coast: Adam Selwood
Western Bulldogs: Matthew Boyd

 

[robertg22]

Swan
Pendlebury
Maxwell
Prestigiacomo
Davis
Didak
O'Brien
Shaw
Lockyer
Anthony

 

[AG]

^ Forgot Davis?

 

[robertg22]

^ Forgot Davis?

Knew there was one, will edit

 

[marcmurphy3]

1. Chris Judd2. Marc Murphy3. Bryce Gibbs4. Brendan Fevola5. Brett Thornton6. Kade Simpson7. Paul Bower8. Matt Kreuzer9. Eddie Betts10. Aaron Joseph

 

[TassieSaint]

my prediction would be
1 Leigh Montagna
2 Nick Riewoldt
3 Lenny Hayes*
4 Brendan Goddard
5 Nick Dal Santo
6 Sam Gilbert*
7 Clinton Jones
8 Sam Fisher
9 Jason Blake
10 Justin Koschitzke
* lower than they should be due to missing multiple games (I think that's how it works)

numbers 9 and 10 could also be Ray, Schneider or Gardiner.

 

[simba_]

Dom
Surj
Tredders

 

[Johno01]

1. Tyson Edwards
2. Bernie Vince
3. Kurt Tippet
4. Chris Knights
5. Nathan Bock (missed a lot of games though)
6. Andy Otten
7. Scott Thompson
8. Michael Doughty
9. Graham Johncock
10.Jason Porplyzia

 

[La Vache]

Hawthorn. Tough one as we have had very few contributors all through the year.

1. Brad Sewell
2. Jordan Lewis
3. Sam Mitchell
4. Cyril Rioli
5. Lance Franklin
6. Luke Hodge
7. Aaaah uuuum hmmm... Ben McGlynn
8. Chance Bateman
9. ........ Jarryd Roughead
10. ............. Maybe Steven Gilham?

 

[HolyRioli]

1. Sewell
2. Mitchell
3. Rioli

Daylight

4. Franklin
5. Bateman
6. Lewis
7. Roughead
8. McGlynn
9. Guerra
10.Osbourne?


After the first 3 it gets seriously tough unfortunately ... too many players inconsistant with form or fitness over the course of the year.

 

[Richmond 2014]

Hawthorn. Tough one as we have had very few contributors all through the year.

1. Brad Sewell
2. Jordan Lewis
3. Sam Mitchell
4. Cyril Rioli
5. Lance Franklin
6. Luke Hodge
7. Aaaah uuuum hmmm... Ben McGlynn
8. Chance Bateman
9. ........ Jarryd Roughead
10. ............. Maybe Steven Gilham?

Surley your season hasnt been that horrible to put in Gilham who has played 6-8 games a top 10 mention. also Hodge has been poor i would have him lower, as well as bateman.

Mitchell i rekon has been outstanding, deserves to be BnF. close behind is sewlley.

 

[La Vache]

Surley your season hasnt been that horrible to put in Gilham who has played 6-8 games a top 10 mention. also Hodge has been poor i would have him lower, as well as bateman.

Mitchell i rekon has been outstanding, deserves to be BnF. close behind is sewlley.

Well I dunno, maybe Birchall but he has been very ordinary. Guerra??

Hodge had an ordinary first half but since he returned from injury he has been one of our best players, definately not poor had three outstanding games recently against your mob, Collingwood and North.

Lewis has been just about our most consistent player this year. Not outstanding but has had over 20 disposals in every game he's played.

 

[Scham]

Sandilands
Tarrant
Duffield
Haselby
Pavlich
Broughton
Schammer
Mundy
Dodd
Suban

 

[Ninty]

Selwood for Geelong.

Sewell for Hawthorn.

 

[Shawt]

Swan
Pendlebury
Maxwell
Prestigiacomo
Davis
Didak
O'Brien
Shaw
Lockyer
Anthony

Pay that... if you want a dark horse for top 10, I would think that Toovey's efforts this year wouldn't have gone unnoticed. I'd almost put him in that 10 over Tarks

 

[Coin_Toss]

1. Dane Swan
2. Alan Didak
3. Scott Pendlebury
4. Leon Davis
5. Nick Maxwell
6. Simon Prestigiacomo
7. Harry O'Brien
8. Shane O'Bree
9. Dale Thomas
10. Heath Shaw

 

[fpm84]

1. Joel Selwood
2. Gary Ablett
3. Corey Enright
4. Paul Chapman
5. Matthew Scarlett
6. Steve Johnson (dropped numerous places due to injury interrupted second half to season)
7. Cameron Ling
8. Andrew Mackie
9. Joel Corey
10. Jimmy Bartel

 

[blues4flag]

Going by the Carlton Board POTY (see sig):

1. Murphy (55)
2. Judd (51)
3. Gibbs (37)
4. Fevola (26)
5. Simpson (19)
6. Kreuzer (18)
7. Bower (17)
8. Waite (16)
9. Thornton (12)
10. Joseph (11)

Goes to show how good Waite was pre-injury to still be eighth.

First 4 looks clear cut but I think Thornton might be a touch higher up.

 

[cougar000]

1. Davey
2. Moloney
3. Bruce
4. Sylvia
5. Grimes
6. Morton
7. Martin
8. McLean
9. Jones
10. Green

 

[crows dude]

1. Tyson Edwards
2. Bernie Vince
3. Kurt Tippet
4. Chris Knights
5. Nathan Bock (missed a lot of games though)
6. Andy Otten
7. Scott Thompson
8. Michael Doughty
9. Graham Johncock
10.Jason Porplyzia

mmmm

Me thinks Goody will be in top 10 some how.

I'll go

Thompspn
Edwards
Vince
Goodwin
Doughty
Otten
Bock
Tippett
Porps
Mcleod/Knights

 

[Cudi]

1. Matty Boyd
2. Brian Lake
3. Brad Johnson
4. Jarrod Harbrow
5. Ryan Hargrave
6. Jason Akermanis
7. Shaun Higgins
8. Adam Cooney
9. Daniel Cross
10. Dale Morris

 

[kfleong2000]

1. Adam Selwood
2. Mark LeCras
3. Darren Glass
4. Matt Priddis
5. Matt Rosa
6. Quinten Lynch
7. Shannon Hurn
8. Dean Cox
9. Josh Kennedy
10. Andrew Embley

 

[Swans120]

Sydney:
1. Adam Goodes
2. Jude Bolton
3. Ryan O'Keefe
4. Rhyce Shaw
5. Brett Kirk
6. Craig Bolton
7. Darren Jolly
8. LRT
9. Kieran Jack
10. Heath Grundy

Probably forgotten someone.

1. Goodesy
2. Jude
3. ROK
4. Shaw
5. Jolly
6. Kirk
7. C.Bolton
8. LRT
9. McVeigh
10. Grundy

Places 4-8 will be really tight. Could be any kind of order of those guys i reckon. Top 3 places will be Goodes, Jude and ROK and im almost certain it will be in that order.

 

[raskolnikov]

1. Jobe Watson
2. Andrew Lovett
3. Brent Stanton
4. Paddy Ryder
5. Tayte Pears
6. Dustin Fletcher
7. Ricky Dyson
8. Adam McPhee
9. Jason Winderlich
10. Courtney Dempsey