2009 Trade Discussion

[Masss#10]

I must be the only person in the world to not have that dud on my bench rucks, Spencer..

My rookies atm are causing me headaches, im thinking of using 2 trades before the money changes, so i can make some dough..

Backs: Bowden, Enright, Cornes, Adcock, Raines, Houlihan, Hill. (Broughton, Suban)

Midfield: Swan, Kornes, Cross, T.Tuck, Haselby, Rich. (Beams, Anthony)

Rucks: Mcintosh, Cox. (Jacobs, Pyke)

Fowards: Deledio, Franklin, Chapman, Daisy, Skipworth, Higgins, Krakouer. (Garlett, Brown)

I was at Uni till 5:30 so when i found out about the teams, i couldn't get in and make changes..

My backline is worrying me if Hill or Suban gets dropped because then i might need to cop a donut..

 

[swans4eva]

I must be the only person in the world to not have that dud on my bench rucks, Spencer..

My rookies atm are causing me headaches, im thinking of using 2 trades before the money changes, so i can make some dough..

Backs: Bowden, Enright, Cornes, Adcock, Raines, Houlihan, Hill. (Broughton, Suban)

Midfield: Swan, Kornes, Cross, T.Tuck, Haselby, Rich. (Beams, Anthony)

Rucks: Mcintosh, Cox. (Jacobs, Pyke)

Fowards: Deledio, Franklin, Chapman, Daisy, Skipworth, Higgins, Krakouer. (Garlett, Brown)

I was at Uni till 5:30 so when i found out about the teams, i couldn't get in and make changes..

My backline is worrying me if Hill or Suban gets dropped because then i might need to cop a donut..

Dont worry mate i dont hav spencer instead i have...andrew browne gave me a handy 12 points

 

[swans4eva]

I think evryone should stop worrying about the possibility of getting a zero if hill or suban dont play...they will only add 40-50 points to your team which may help but if u get a zero it isnt the end of the world...i say u wait till the end of round 2 and trade raines off then, i have broughton and petrenko as reserves and i am confident that one will play and if one doesnt then it is only one week and i will be able to hav a lot better look at who an appropriate trade for raines is.

 

[theone5]

Despite the unpredictability of M.Harvey and his coaching staff, i am confident that both S.Hill and N.Suban will play.
It will not do much to their confidence if they were dropped after only 1 round and they both showed good signs and will continue to improve.

Murphy, Head and Browne look to be the next in line to get dropped with guys like Drum no certainty to play either.
They should be safe.

J.Petrenko will also play and G.Broughton is a slight chance accumulating 25 touches in the WAFL this week.

Everyone just needs to relax.

 

[WeninRome]

How do people see Malcheski going? i am seriously considering getting rid of him before his price drops. I just dont see players from the swans scoring that well this year.

thoughts?

 

[Papa Juggs]

Might just swap Raines for Kyle Cheney if he gets a game this week.

 

[flea29]

Nathan Brown (Rich) - Sack him or keep him?
Was going to get rid of him on Thursday but just didnt get around to it. Fair to say he will do bugger all this week & plummet in value after round 3, just wondering if I should cut my losses now.

 

[Big_Tazz]

Nathan Brown (Rich) - Sack him or keep him?
Was going to get rid of him on Thursday but just didnt get around to it. Fair to say he will do bugger all this week & plummet in value after round 3, just wondering if I should cut my losses now.

You my friend are a very dumb person... y would u want to take him out now? His over 400k and you will be wasting a trade, he has had a full pre season and the first round was just unlucky in the second half, as the whole team was playing crap, this was the case with deledio last year.... im not saying that he will pull out a deledio of 2008, but he will be close to it, if he dosnt get 100 this week, he will the next...

 

[Juddtastic]

Nathan Brown (Rich) - Sack him or keep him?
Was going to get rid of him on Thursday but just didnt get around to it. Fair to say he will do bugger all this week & plummet in value after round 3, just wondering if I should cut my losses now.

I'm guessing you picked him to perform for 22 rounds not just 1... keep that in mind before you pull the trigger

 

[swans4eva]

You my friend are a very dumb person... y would u want to take him out now? His over 400k and you will be wasting a trade, he has had a full pre season and the first round was just unlucky in the second half, as the whole team was playing crap, this was the case with deledio last year.... im not saying that he will pull out a deledio of 2008, but he will be close to it, if he dosnt get 100 this week, he will the next...

Thinking about it more and more, Richmond players are very good players to pick up when prices go down as they are playing geelong this week and a lot of them will score badly. So i might think of picking up brown at about round 5 or 6 and trading him for one of my cash cows as he will be a pretty low price by then... same goes with deledio(except i already have him).

 

[flea29]

You my friend are a very dumb person...

Bit over the top dont you think? Might have been a silly decision IF I gave him the flick but I was just putting it out there for discussion.

I'm guessing you picked him to perform for 22 rounds not just 1... keep that in mind before you pull the trigger

Well thought out response, cheers.

Silliest ideas always pop out earliest in the week anyway, thats why you dont trade before Fridays!

 

[cuzz is back]

should i trade raines or should i put him in my emg list and put petrenko in i was thinking of tradeing raines for cheny or petterd and help would be great

 

[AjsGuns]

dont worry NGB will gun it this season. One of my first picked. Worried about Boooomer now though

 

[cuzz is back]

well hill and zeibell get sent back to the vfl or well they keep there place in the team i have both so im realy worried about them

 

[JDWCE]

should i trade raines or should i put him in my emg list and put petrenko in i was thinking of tradeing raines for cheny or petterd and help would be great

looks like raines could be out for more than 4, will need to get some match fitness up

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/74004/default.aspx

 

[AjsGuns]

well hill and zeibell get sent back to the vfl or well they keep there place in the team i have both so im realy worried about them

I dont think Hill will.
No idea about Ziebell but i hope not.

 

[swansational05]

cousins ---> T.Tuck/M.Morton

now i need help; i have the option of trading myers or raines or walker. I will reserve one of them to Suban (probably walker)

 

[Bert1]

Id be surprised if Hill got sent to the Vfl hahaha

 

[Juddy88]

Strong word that Reilly may be dropped this week for Thompson.

Should I, A) Hold onto him and start Otten.

B) Downgrade him to Robinson, making 200K and start Robbo.

C) Sideways trade to a T.Tuck, or someone else like that(few around that price).


Shit start.

 

[AjsGuns]

A then B then C

 

[Pumbi]

Strong word that Reilly may be dropped this week for Thompson.

Should I, A) Hold onto him and start Otten.

B) Downgrade him to Robinson, making 200K and start Robbo.

C) Sideways trade to a T.Tuck, or someone else like that(few around that price).


Shit start.

I would definitely lean towards A. I don't see why Otten can't replicated a similar score of around 70, which is sufficient for the mean time. It also gives you another week to assess the situation. Reilly may get dropped, who knows. If he does, he may play a 45 possession 8 goal blinder in the reserves and get back into the side and score well like he can. Or he may play poorly and struggle to get his spot back. Plus with the added week, it allows you to assess Robinson and Tuck more so, with the advantage of no price change.

 

[Juddy88]

I would definitely lean towards A. I don't see why Otten can't replicated a similar score of around 70, which is sufficient for the mean time. It also gives you another week to assess the situation. Reilly may get dropped, who knows. If he does, he may play a 45 possession 8 goal blinder in the reserves and get back into the side and score well like he can. Or he may play poorly and struggle to get his spot back. Plus with the added week, it allows you to assess Robinson and Tuck more so, with the advantage of no price change.

Yeah definitely leaning towards option A, although then I have no bench.

Also watching Reilly, he looked really slow and seemed to be tagging at times. Not a good sign.

Even if he isn't dropped, I'm not really confident in keeping him.
Not really sure why I chose him, bloody Grigg just had to get injured..

Trading in Robinson will also give me 200K, but he may not keep his spot for longer than 2-3 more weeks.

Tuck I really liked the look of on Thursday night, was everywhere. Plays Sydney this week, but it appears the Sydney curse is a thing of the past.

 

[Cartman121]

Yeah definitely leaning towards option A, although then I have no bench.

Also watching Reilly, he looked really slow and seemed to be tagging at times. Not a good sign.

Even if he isn't dropped, I'm not really confident in keeping him.
Not really sure why I chose him, bloody Grigg just had to get injured..

Trading in Robinson will also give me 200K, but he may not keep his spot for longer than 2-3 more weeks.

Tuck I really liked the look of on Thursday night, was everywhere. Plays Sydney this week, but it appears the Sydney curse is a thing of the past.

Reilly is firmly cemented in Adelaides 22. This is just my personal view, alot of others will have different opinions. He's a class player and will rebound quickly, I have no doubts over his scoring potential just his ability to stay on the ground. I think it is a good idea to have a plan in mind if he isn't chosen on Thursday though. But if he is I would definitely be keeping him. If picked I would think you're crazy to trade him out after one round. He's extremely cheap for what he is able to produce. Remember why you chose him, have faith sir!

Hope that helped you out .

 

[Juddy88]

Reilly is firmly cemented in Adelaides 22. This is just my personal view, alot of others will have different opinions. He's a class player and will rebound quickly, I have no doubts over his scoring potential just his ability to stay on the ground. I think it is a good idea to have a plan in mind if he isn't chosen on Thursday though. But if he is I would definitely be keeping him. If picked I would think you're crazy to trade him out after one round. He's extremely cheap for what he is able to produce. Remember why you chose him, have faith sir!

Hope that helped you out .

Lol cheers, yeah I doubt I will trade him.

Impulse trading at its finest .

The gaining of 200K is just so tempting, which then could be used to upgrade Robbinson if and when he reaches 250K

Therefore, in the end only costing me 2 trades to upgrade Reilly, rather than 1.5.

Although I definitely cannot see Robbo kicking 3 goals and scoring 90 each week.

 

[Juddbemetron]

just wondering
when do price changes takje affect
if i want to wait till after round 3 to make a trade will the price changes have come into place??