Mega Thread 2011/12 Trade/Draft/Delist Megathread - Mid-Trade-Week edition

[Sammy J]

Josh Hill...gets a massive 'meh' from me.

When I think of his game, I think 'lazy' and 'soft'. Doesn't exactly inspire me.

Ah well, perhaps being traded and playing at Subiaco will lift his work rate and intensity. We'll see I guess.

 

[new breed]

Josh Hill has been traded in to capitalise on our Inside Midfielders ie Hill will be a reciever of the ball , WCE have very few of these and hopefully it works well !

The Deal might be done later today if not , .... on Monday according to S Silvagni . After this deal GWS will be opting out of trade week most likely !

 

[QS]

The Deal might be done later today if not , .... on Monday according to S Silvagni . After this deal GWS will be opting out of trade week most likely !

Not quoting TWR are you? They were saying it would be done yesterday.
I think they are as speculative as us here on BF at times

 

[new breed]

I have listened this morning , seems Silvagni ( GWS ) has finished there dealings = No Coniglio .

TWR is gruelling radio conducted by Egomaniacs about Team Managers and Staff with big Ego's .

EDIT Terry Wallace seems pretty good guy

 

[larrikin]

.

TWR is gruelling radio conducted by Egomaniacs about Team Managers and Staff with big Ego's .

Doesn't sound like AFL people and footy journo's

 

[Special Agent Utah]

Brad Dick looking at walking away from football according to HS footy.

PSD or Rookie if he can't get a deal done with the Pies?

 

[new breed]

Dick is Recovering from second Knee reconstruction and has had two shoulder reconstructions ,.... his body cant cope ATM but has very good talent .

 

[new breed]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/125075/default.aspx


AFL article , suggested WCE may give up 45 in the 4 way deal and end up with a GWS pick ,... hopefully it is in the low 20 s

Article is guessing !

 

[Special Agent Utah]

Dick is Recovering from second Knee reconstruction and has had two shoulder reconstructions ,.... his body cant cope ATM but has very good talent .

Yeah it is a fair point but if he passed a medical, came back home certainly wouldn't be the worst rookie pick.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/125075/default.aspx


AFL article , suggested WCE may give up 45 in the 4 way deal and end up with a GWS pick ,... hopefully it is in the low 20 s

Article is guessing !

GWS have 31 (unless they've traded it). don't think they've got anything between that and pick 14.

They could send us the Palmer compo pick maybe.

 

[pantskyle]

Slow news day, rumour that Woosha will be appointed Saints coach this arvo. lol

 

[pantskyle]

Would we take 31 and 33 and Hill for Ebo?

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Yeah I'd take that.

Would end up being 31, 33 and Hill for Ebert and 45, but we wouldn't use that pick anyway.

 

[TradeDraft]

Guess the Pies where not Interested in Stevenson then

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Guess the Pies where not Interested in Stevenson then

As I said earlier Dave, I don't know where you'd find the list room for Stevo.

Currently it's In - Clarke, Elliott, three draft picks or rookie upgrades
Out - Brown, McCarthy?, Macaffer?, Toovey?, Dick?, other??

 

[WCE_Phill]

4 way deal ey.

P.A send Corns/Brogan to GWS + pick 51 to the dogs + 33
GWS send (1st round compo pick 18-20 next year) to WCE
Hill to WCE
Ebert to P.A + 45

P.A Gain Ebert + 45
P.A Lose Cornes, Brogan and 33 & 51

GWS Gain Cornes and Brogan
GWS Lose (End on first round compo)

WB Gain 51
WB Lose Hill

WCE Gain Hill and first round compo (18-20 next year) + 33 (this year)
WCE Lose Ebert + 45

 

[ThePuma #9]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/125075/default.aspx


AFL article , suggested WCE may give up 45 in the 4 way deal and end up with a GWS pick ,... hopefully it is in the low 20 s

Article is guessing !

4 way deal.

GWS: Give Pick 49. Get Pick 57 Brogans/Cornes

PORT: Give Pick 28,33,69 Cornes/Brogan Get Ebert, Pick 39, Pick 49.

WCE Give Ebert Picks 28,33,45,63 C.Wilson Get picks 17,69 and Hill.

WBD: Give Hill, picks 17 and 49, 57 Get picks 28, 33, 45, 63 and C.Wilson.

Something like this. if WBD are really after picks this could work. Is anyone unhappy with this?

You could even throw picks 57 and 63 around to appease WBD and like WCE Phil mentioned above GWS do have compo picks but i think they want to hold on to them.

 

[pantskyle]

Would take that Phill in a heartbeat.

 

[PRANKSTER666]

Can't see GWS givng up a compo pick, they will want to bank as many as them as possible, if they have pick 31 then that may be surplus given all their first round picks this year.

31, 33 and Hill for Ebert and 45 would be a pretty good result for us IMO.

 

[ziad]

4 way deal.

GWS: Give Pick 49. Get Pick 57 Brogans/Cornes

PORT: Give Pick 28,33,69 Cornes/Brogan Get Ebert, Pick 39, Pick 49.

WCE Give Ebert Picks 28,33,45,63 C.Wilson Get picks 17,69 and Hill.

WBD: Give Hill, picks 17 and 49, 57 Get picks 28, 33, 45, 63 and C.Wilson.

Something like this. if WBD are really after picks this could work. Is anyone unhappy with this?

You could even throw picks 57 and 63 around to appease WBD and like WCE Phil mentioned above GWS do have compo picks but i think they want to hold on to them.

Assume it isnt on the table or we would have signed

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

4 way deal ey.

P.A send Corns/Brogan to GWS + pick 51 to the dogs + 33
GWS send (1st round compo pick 18-20 next year) to WCE
Hill to WCE
Ebert to P.A + 45

P.A Gain Ebert + 45
P.A Lose Cornes, Brogan and 33 & 51

GWS Gain Cornes and Brogan
GWS Lose (End on first round compo)

WB Gain 51
WB Lose Hill

WCE Gain Hill and first round compo (18-20 next year) + 33 (this year)
WCE Lose Ebert + 45

We smash that trade, pretty much at GWS's expense.

They give up a decent compo pick for two guys they could get in the 7th round if necessary.

 

[WCE_Phill]

Would take that Phill in a heartbeat.

I think it's a fair trade all round imo.

 

[Special Agent Utah]

I thought i was in a timewarp when i read Sierakowski was being traded.

I thought we where bringing David out of retirement.

 

[WCE_Phill]

We smash that trade, pretty much at GWS's expense.

They give up a decent compo pick for two guys they could get in the 7th round if necessary.

True, might need to send them a sweetner

 

[Pure_Ownage]

GWS have 31 (unless they've traded it). don't think they've got anything between that and pick 14.

They could send us the Palmer compo pick maybe.

GWS traded that pick to GC along with OMeara.

GWS have no picks between 14 and 49 as far as I know.

Maybe it would be a player they are adding? (i.e. not one of their recent signings but someone they took in their original intake of kids that have been running around this year?) I'm guessing, but it'd be either that or some sort of compo pick you'd think.