2011 Captains Mega Thread (Part 1)

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Re: Round 15 Captain

how do stevie j's numbers stack up against the dons?

He averages 107 according to TS, and that's before this year when he's been a lot more consistent. Wouldn't be a bad roll of the dice.
 
Re: Round 15 Captain

Went with Griffin last week and it paid dividends (145x2).

Thinking a similar approach this week, or I may go a bit safer with Judd / Swan.

Buddy also on the radar.
 
Re: Round 15 Captain

They are tough numbers to ignore but there just seems to be better (safer) options other than Roo. I'm kinda doubting myself with Pav for some reason after thinking about how Buddy went that week against GC..from memory the small forward type players feast not the big forwards.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Re: Round 15 Captain

Great preview as always IDIG, but you may have missed Ryan O'Keefe.

Last 3 against Adelaide have produced 124, 134 and 167! He also has an average of 134 at AAMI Stadium in his last 3 games there. Adelaide are terrible, ROK is in some form... weather permitting he may be a good unique choice.
 
Re: Round 15 Captain

Great preview as always IDIG, but you may have missed Ryan O'Keefe.

Last 3 against Adelaide have produced 124, 134 and 167! He also has an average of 134 at AAMI Stadium in his last 3 games there. Adelaide are terrible, ROK is in some form... weather permitting he may be a good unique choice.

Fair call and funnily enough he's always on there but no one ever votes for him and i added Swallow and Sammy Fish this week so someone had to make room :D

Is it me or is Fyfe the perfect type of player to cause havoc against Gold Coast?
 
Re: Round 15 Captain

only stupid if you actually choose him - would be an ultimate gamble

Yea I've come to my senses now. He's out of consideration. I'm just sick of playing it safe and gettin shit scores from my captain. If im gonna get shit scores I may aswell take a gamble.

Captaincy choices have costed me aloooooot of points this year.

Probably pick Swan even tho he bent me over with his 2 80s, but might look at Chappy
 
Re: Round 15 Captain

My first captain choice was going to be Pav this week playing his 250th but as I analysed the teams for Freo Vs GC Im thinking of a roughie...

Broughton.

He had a ripper last week and just starting to find his own ball again. His kicks are more accurate then Pav as he tries to thread the needle more than throwing it on the boot from the centre square. It looks like Ablett will win many clearances but that will cancel out with Freo fielding a strong back 6 for the first time this season.(SNOS, Grover, Duff, Ibbotson, McPharlin and Broughts).
I can just see Broughton running the ball out ALOT and having some time on the ball as well with Barlow and Mundy missing from the midfield. Pav will be hopefully spending more time and CHF kicking goals.

Thought on the gamble? Will Broughton score more than Pav/Fyfe?

I think my reasoning stacks up...:cool:
 
Re: Round 15 Captain

My first captain choice was going to be Pav this week playing his 250th but as I analysed the teams for Freo Vs GC Im thinking of a roughie...

Broughton.

He had a ripper last week and just starting to find his own ball again. His kicks are more accurate then Pav as he tries to thread the needle more than throwing it on the boot from the centre square. It looks like Ablett will win many clearances but that will cancel out with Freo fielding a strong back 6 for the first time this season.(SNOS, Grover, Duff, Ibbotson, McPharlin and Broughts).
I can just see Broughton running the ball out ALOT and having some time on the ball as well with Barlow and Mundy missing from the midfield. Pav will be hopefully spending more time and CHF kicking goals.

Thought on the gamble? Will Broughton score more than Pav/Fyfe?

I think my reasoning stacks up...:cool:

Good reasoning. Good luck with it (if ya don't chicken out within next few hours) :p

Pretty sure all 3 Pav, Fyfe and Broughton will ton up with ease.

Only reason why me personally im leaning towards Pav is because I can really picture him tearing it to shreds in MID + FWD and could def kick 4+ goals. Obviously you would know heaps more about Freo im just going with instinct and gut feel...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top