2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

[dUkezz]

Option 1 there devize imo

 

[joydivision22]

Franklin + Enright + D.Smith vs Swan + Dangerfield + M.Clarke?

FRANKLIN enright SMITH!!

upgrade swan later.
still try for danger though, clarke looks dodgy get someone like webberley n save 60k.
not convinced on enright this year - looks like scott will rest him a few times. broughton, birchall, suckling even adcock look like better options...imo of course haha

my troubles are as such...
Christian Howard Vs Jayden Pitt
Dangerfield Vs N Riewoldt

 

[sparkyblue]

Danger over NRoo for my money. Adelaide have a very soft start to the year. Still not convinced that Reiwoldt will get back to anywhere near his previous scores.

 

[Swallow9]

5 Defence premiums

VS

5 Foward premiums

 

[Pocket_Pears]

5 Defence premiums

VS

5 Foward premiums

Finally a question that interests me! I'd say 5 defence premiums, since there are an abundance of forward rookies, and not so many defence rookies with good scoring potential AND job security.

 

[masterp]

wingard v coniglio?

both high priced rookies with big upsides, not too keen to have both.

thoughts?

 

[Pocket_Pears]

wingard v coniglio?

both high priced rookies with big upsides, not too keen to have both.

thoughts?

If you can't split em, pick the one that suits your bye strategy best.

 

[oneredfrog]

Boyd ($626K) vs Selwood ($605K)?

Had Boyd all last year and was excellent. Traded Selwood out after knockout.
Selwood also suspended which caused him to miss games.

Trying to save some cash to use elsewhere so cheaper price is tempting.

 

[Falchoon]

Boyd ($626K) vs Selwood ($605K)?

Had Boyd all last year and was excellent. Traded Selwood out after knockout.
Selwood also suspended which caused him to miss games.

Trying to save some cash to use elsewhere so cheaper price is tempting.

if you can't decide go with the one more likely to play 22 games

 

[Weiterbot23]

Fisher or Broughton?

 

[Turly]

Fisher or Broughton?

If you've already got Goddard I'd say Broughton mate. Broughton should improve on his average whilst Fisher probably won't.

Killing myself over a couple of these decisions.

Pavlich vs Fyfe vs Goodes

Chapman vs Harvey

Mumford vs Sandilands vs McCevoy

Birchall vs Broughton vs Enright



Cheers for any assistance guys

 

[tommyv49]

If you've already got Goddard I'd say Broughton mate. Broughton should improve on his average whilst Fisher probably won't.

Killing myself over a couple of these decisions.

Pavlich vs Fyfe vs Goodes

Chapman vs Harvey

Mumford vs Sandilands vs McCevoy

Birchall vs Broughton vs Enright



Cheers for any assistance guys

After the game on the weekend im leaing towards fyfe
Chapman
Mummy (1 bad tackle away from disaster though)
Birchall or Broughton. If broughton plays in the mid like he did on sunday then he would definately be worth it.

Now for me
Pendlebury + N.Roo or J.Roo
Or
Thomas + Chapman

 

[Jair]

I've got a similar decision to make as the only mid-pricer in my side:

Danger, N. Reiwoldt or Gray?

The way I see it is; Danger to midfield means great SC numbers finally or maybe Gray is poised to break into premium status or Roo back to his best this year?

 

[dazk]

Cox and McIntosh

OR

Sandilands and Kreuzer

 

[dazk]

I've got a similar decision to make as the only mid-pricer in my side:

Danger, N. Reiwoldt or Gray?

The way I see it is; Danger to midfield means great SC numbers finally or maybe Gray is poised to break into premium status or Roo back to his best this year?

I reckon Dangerfield, although I doubt he will consistently score 100s I think an increased midfield role could see him improve enough to average solidly in the 90s.

 

[V_23]

Option A: Lake, Coniglio, Redden (ruckman) and Chapman

OR

Option B: Broughton, K. Stevens, Rowe and Dangerfield

 

[scaryness]

Jobe Watson or Trent Cotchin?

I'm Really struggling with that

 

[Cheannn]

Cox and McIntosh

OR

Sandilands and Kreuzer

Option A.

But Kreuzer and McIntosh are bad picks in my book anyway.

 

[liam_13]

Jobe Watson or Trent Cotchin?

I'm Really struggling with that

Watson is a guarantee to finish in the top 10-12 you'd think, can't predict injury or anything. Cotchin I reckon could explode (I'm tipping he will), but chances are he will be 15-20 range. I would go Cotchin though.

Gilbert and Martin vs Deledio and Bennell...keep in mind it doesn't have to be those exact players, just basically mid price def and prem forward vs prem def and mid price for

 

[rjslcM]

1.

Option a: Franklin and Sidebottom
Option b: Chapman and Rioli


2.

Or better yet help me pick 4 forwards with $2,071,100.

ATM I've got Franklin, Martin, Sidebottom Dangerfield using that money. But I feel like there might be better options.

Ps. I've got Fyfe in the midfield

Thankyou.

 

[rjslcM]

Hurley, Dangerfield, Sidebottom

Pick two

 

[toxic]

Watson is a guarantee to finish in the top 10-12 you'd think, can't predict injury or anything. Cotchin I reckon could explode (I'm tipping he will), but chances are he will be 15-20 range. I would go Cotchin though.

Gilbert and Martin vs Deledio and Bennell...keep in mind it doesn't have to be those exact players, just basically mid price def and prem forward vs prem def and mid price for

Ok, so why pick cotchin if Watson will finish higher in total points??
Lids a much better option (or make h shaw, adcock) than Gilbert but dusty Martin is a must have imo, shave rookies to get Martin and a premium def, no point being half dressed.

 

[dUkezz]

boyd v watson +52k.... leaning towards watson

 

[d-12]

boyd v watson +52k.... leaning towards watson

Watson personally, but with the slight injury risk.

Tough choice

H. Grundy, Watson and Priddis

V

Heppel, Scott Thompson (adel) and A. Swallow

Mind you, Swallow and Thompson have good draws playing GC and GWS twice.

 

[dlanod]

Hurley, Dangerfield, Sidebottom

Pick two

Dangerfield and Sidebottom. Hurley being thrown back and forward and depending on goals as a KPF worries me.

H. Grundy, Watson and Priddis

V

Heppel, Scott Thompson (adel) and A. Swallow

Mind you, Swallow and Thompson have good draws playing GC and GWS twice.

I like the Swallow/Thompson combo better, and Grundy v Heppell is a bit of a wash so I'd take the latter three.