2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

[tommyv49]

He did didn't he. Thanks

Mitch Robinson v Zaka?

Depends which do you think is going to have a better breakout year. If i had to pick between those 2 i'd say zaharakis (assuming thats what you meant by zaka). However personally i would try and get an extra 50-60k and go for a chapman or a martin.

Another option around the same price is sidebottom who i would probably pick up over zaharakis

 

[Donslad]

Would go with Zaka, only coz i'm biased

Koby Stevens (WCE) or Devon Smith (GWS)?

 

[MightyMark]

Would go with Zaka, only coz i'm biased

Koby Stevens (WCE) or Devon Smith (GWS)?

Right now probably Stevens, but I would just wait until after the NAB cup before you make any decisions on rookie priced players, mostly speculation at the moment. Other players might suprise you.

 

[joydivision22]

Hey unsure on a few players...

Dylan Grimes V Robbie Tarrant V Hargrave V Lake (already got Howard though)

Getting Tarrant or Hargrave or Lake means I can get Lucas in Mids too for J Mcdonald.

Thoughts?
Thanks!

 

[Caek]

Hey unsure on a few players...

Dylan Grimes V Robbie Tarrant V Hargrave V Lake (already got Howard though)

Getting Tarrant or Hargrave or Lake means I can get Lucas in Mids too for J Mcdonald.

Thoughts?
Thanks!

Hargrave. Should score well this season and can be easily upgraded to a premium later in the season.

I'd keep Mcdonald and use the extra money on upgrading a mid-priced player to a premium.

 

[Caek]

Birchall vs. Fisher

Rockliff vs. Priddis

Thoughts on both of these??

 

[V_23]

Birchall vs. Fisher

Rockliff vs. Priddis

Thoughts on both of these??

Very difficult but probably Fisher and Priddis, don't take my word for it though.

Tough question to answer but:

Wingard v Koby Stevens

 

[BLUES9898]

Very difficult but probably Fisher and Priddis, don't take my word for it though.

Tough question to answer but:

Wingard v Koby Stevens

Tough one but I probably say Stevens as I can see wingard as sub for most games

 

[toxic]

Wingard sub? are u serious - he is the future of the club and is ready for senior footy

 

[devize]

Hargrave + Sidebottom vs rookie + Franklin? Currently have Franklin in.

 

[toxic]

must have franklin

 

[Falchoon]

must have franklin

upgrade target no.1

Hawthorn have a tough start.

 

[Billy1]

H. Shaw & Pavlich

Or

Enright & Goodes?

 

[pie_punter]

H. Shaw & Pavlich

Or

Enright & Goodes?

If you could Shaw and Goodes, Shaw is looking in great form and Sydney has a great early draw. Pav will be up there I'm sure aswell

 

[Billy1]

If you could Shaw and Goodes, Shaw is looking in great form and Sydney has a great early draw. Pav will be up there I'm sure aswell

The way my team is at the moment I'm $12,500 short. Will try and make a minor adjustment somewhere to squeeze them both in.

 

[Fatboy64]

The way my team is at the moment I'm $12,500 short. Will try and make a minor adjustment somewhere to squeeze them both in.

If you can't find the extra cash, I would be going with your first option. Shaw is a must in my humble opinion.

I am tossing us between Scotland / Enright / K. Stevens or Birchall / Broughton / Gaff.
I am trying to get Andrew Gaff into my side as the big improver this year. Any thoughts?

 

[Keatz]

Scotland and broughton stand out to me out of those options, my dilemma is: H. McIntosh or Kruezer
I'm after consistency that can make a bit of cash to trade up later on for a cox-like figure

 

[rocker_oz33]

Never had scotland before might swap him with one of lids fisher/goddard prob be lids with hammy injury.make hargave lids in 6 weeks that might work.
morris v ellis both should be games surely.
l dont think many cats from the lastest draft will getting games.

 

[pie_punter]

Never had scotland before might swap him with one of lids fisher/goddard prob be lids with hammy injury.make hargave lids in 6 weeks that might work.
morris v ellis both should be games surely.
l dont think many cats from the lastest draft will getting games.

Think this will be the first year in the last few i start without Lids, but who knows he could destroy a nab game and get in

 

[pie_punter]

3 prem + 5 rookie midfield set up.

vs

1 prem 3 rookie ruck set up.


Thinking of going with the 3 rookie midfield then being able to upgrade quite quickly depending on price rises.

 

[rocker_oz33]

l'm going with 4 guns in the guts and mummy plus his rookie b!tches in the ruck.
l had horror run last year with 3 guns in the middle with mundy and watson going down and price fall killed my centre line.

some dam good rookie mids this year though.

 

[Sprout]

Heppell/Motlop v Shaw/Pfeiffer

 

[MightyMark]

Heppell/Motlop v Shaw/Pfeiffer

Shaw and Pfeiffer all the way.

 

[Keatz]

Cox/H.Mac vs. Mummy/Krooz
Pretty much same $ for these 2 combos

 

[devize]

Franklin + Enright + D.Smith vs Swan + Dangerfield + M.Clarke?